manqiangrexue
Brigadier
On the one hand, it's personally painful for Japanese athletes (and people in general), especially those with good relationships with China, to have to go through this. They were not educated correctly by their government so to them, they wonder how can their Chinese friends be so vicious and cold to suddenly cut off all contact just because they visited a shrine in their own home country?I think we should give these Japanese athletes a break. With the history book changes in Japan the past ~20 years, the limited education these professional athletes have, and the generally nationalist lean of many sports associations, I doubt they really understand the history behind a lot of these shrines, especially the less prominent ones. Take Hayata for example, she said her reason for visiting the Kamimaze museum is to appreciate the value of life, which is in line with at least the museum's advertised purpose of emphasizing the value of life by showing the wasteful suicide runs of young kamikaze pilots.
Netizens would be right to educate her and Ishikawa/Harimoto/etc. on the history, but probably shouldn't lash out at them since they're unlikely to be trying to be militant or willfully ignorant.
On the other hand, if we cut them slack, then we allow the Japanese tactic of revisionist teaching to be successful. They put their civilians up in a game of Chicken to see if we can hold true to our self-respect and be hostile to those who are not actively hostile to us or if we will let it go and give in to the I'll-be-nice-to-anyone-who's-nice-to-me natural instinct.
Lastly, stop putting Harimoto in there with Ishikawa. She might be poorly educated on the matter but he is deliberately in that situation. Both his parents knew the seriousness of his actions; both of them made a conscious decision to turn him into a hanjian abomination. There is nothing to like, no possibility of redemption for him or his family.
Right now, it's not possible to make any progress. But ultimately the solution is to displace the US in Asia. Japan acts this way because the US, which is the dominant power, doesn't mind its revisionism because that causes emnity with China, which is the most important thing. South Korea is collateral damage and Americans themselves don't care because after you nuke someone into your cartoon lap dog, nothing's that serious with them. But if the US were to be displaced by China, then it would no longer make sense for Japan to keep doing this because it will continuously incurr the wrath of the dominant power. As a small country, Japan must always align itself with the wishes of the dominant power.Because Japanese history education is a total whitewash (based on what I know), Japanese are totally unaware of the horrendous crimes committed by their forefathers. All those shrines and "museums" reinforce the whitewashing and make the visitors think Japs are the victims of WWII, or at least make them think Imperial Japan did nothing wrong. Most of the people in power today are remnants and descendants of Imperial Japan's officials and elites. They are driving Japan toward confrontation with China with the support or at least apathy from the populace and that can be disastrous for both Japan and China.
Other countries can't force the Japanese government to change their history books. However, by punishing any Japanese celebrities economically for visiting those "shrines" and "museums", there is a chance the publicities will make at least some Japanese aware of the crimes committed by their forefathers the Japanese elites try so hard to cover up.
1. Kamikaze Museum is worse than Togo Shrine for Chinese people?? Kamikaze pilots killed Americans while fighting defensively; Togo Heihachiro killed Chinese offensively!Hina Hayata is cancelled in China, CCTV removed all footage of her, even Korean players also unfollowed her. The other two Japanese atheletes Kasumi Ishikawa and Tomokazu Harimoto might still be redeemable in China.
2. What kind of redemption is there for Harimoto?? He's a hanjian with parents who taught him to fight against China and to do whatever it takes to become more Japanese, worshipping war crime shrines being on that list. There's nothing to redeem because there was never anything in that boy's life that would have even been mildly acceptable to Chinese people.