The War in the Ukraine

LawLeadsToPeace

Senior Member
Staff member
Moderator - World Affairs
Registered Member
Probably not all correct but an interesting tactical analysis on the Russian advances over the last few days
but rather young hipster Russian? military historian.
His videos on Ukraine are pretty good and unbiased when you compare them to the other "analyses" done by "experts" in the West. Unlike the other analysts who analyzes and predicts what may happen using their feelings, he actually uses historical examples and some military terminology and tactics to analyze the war efforts by both sides. That's commendable. Also, he is Canadian.
 

james smith esq

Senior Member
Registered Member
No, there's been lots of movements in the last 2 weeks, and today the last major road was cut:
View attachment 89435
There's actually a little road that goes from Bakhmut to Siversk that's still open, but the capacity is much lower than the Lysychansk-Bakhmut highway, cut today at Bilohorivka. Lyman is also nearly in Russian hands:

Yes, to physically close the pocket will probably need a bridge head across the Siverskyi Donets River from the north, hence that previous river crossing disaster. But besides that major transport links into the Severodonetsk pocket is already cut.
I think they might be going for a single-envelopment, from the south, as opposed to the pincer-encirclement (double-envelopment) from the north. They can close the pocket by simply continuing the northward advance.
 

gelgoog

Lieutenant General
Registered Member
FV2dyyr.png

t8fPDdc.png


So much for the Donbass offensive being a stalemate like Western journos were claiming. The Russian blob has been moving relentlessly ever since the second stage of the special operation began. And Ukraine didn't take advantage of the Russian withdrawal near Kharkov to attack the railways supplying the Russian offensive. They never crossed the river. Major fail. Russia rolled out of strategically non important terrain in north of Kharkov and those idiots neither used that to attack Russian rear supply areas, nor did they reinforce the Donbass area. And now that they are reinforcing the Donbass area the Russians have already broken through their lines.
 
Last edited:

LawLeadsToPeace

Senior Member
Staff member
Moderator - World Affairs
Registered Member
FV2dyyr.png

t8fPDdc.png


So much for the Donbass offensive being a stalemate like Western journos were claiming. The Russian blob has been moving relentlessly ever since the second stage of the special operation began. And Ukraine didn't take advantage of the Russian withdrawal near Kharkiv to attack the railways supplying the Russian offensive. They never crossed the river. Major fail.
Supposedly Ukraine’s high command actually reinforced the cauldron with elite forces from Kharkiv that could have taken part in the counter offensive. It’s just an absolute mess.
 

Atomicfrog

Major
Registered Member
Supposedly Ukraine’s high command actually reinforced the cauldron with elite forces from Kharkiv that could have taken part in the counter offensive. It’s just an absolute mess.
The biggest problem is they act like they will receive reinforcement from NATO or allies and need to buy some times. The only things they received are weapon systems from old stockpiles and a couple of new-tech weapons for testing them on Russians. The troops in that cauldron will turn to boiled blood if they don't surrender, what a mess.
 

Corona

Junior Member
Registered Member
Russian special operations forces destroyed a group of militants in the Donbass.
Russian kamikaze drones Kub landing among a group of ukrainian troops, The filming is done by a ZALA drone :

Video of the escape of the Ukrainian paratroopers of the 79th ODSHBR fromLyman. In the process of retreating,the Ukrainian BTR-80 stops and picks up soldiers who have fled through the woods from the Russian shelling, which is haunting the retreating column :

Drone providing assistance to Russian BM-27 Uragan :
 

Abominable

Major
Registered Member
No, there's been lots of movements in the last 2 weeks, and today the last major road was cut:
View attachment 89435
There's actually a little road that goes from Bakhmut to Siversk that's still open, but the capacity is much lower than the Lysychansk-Bakhmut highway, cut today at Bilohorivka. Lyman is also nearly in Russian hands:

Yes, to physically close the pocket will probably need a bridge head across the Siverskyi Donets River from the north, hence that previous river crossing disaster. But besides that major transport links into the Severodonetsk pocket is already cut.
Frontlines haven't been stationary, but in the scheme of things all these advances have been small. In a country the size of the Ukraine a frontline shifting to a village 2-5km down the road isn't changing much. The past few days it seems that

There were videos posted of some of the towns captured. All with small numbers of troops and not much damage compared to somewhere like Mariupol. That means the Ukrainians fell back rather than stand and fight. It's the exact same thing as what happened around Kharkov in reverse. I didn't consider that to be a big shift and nor are these.

Taking out a bridge could mean the Russians are getting serious about finishing things up but remember all the roads leading to Ukrainian lines were in artillery range. Even with the bridge supplies or the prospect of retreat was limited.
 

Zichan

Junior Member
Registered Member
No, there's been lots of movements in the last 2 weeks, and today the last major road was cut:

There's actually a little road that goes from Bakhmut to Siversk that's still open, but the capacity is much lower than the Lysychansk-Bakhmut highway, cut today at Bilohorivka. Lyman is also nearly in Russian hands:
There's also a railroad connection that passes through Bakhmut from the west and goes past Siversk to a fuel processing plant 10km southwest of Lysychansk.

If they take Siversk, then their supply lines will be effectively severed and the cauldron nearly closed. However, they need to firmly cross the Donets river in order to do that from the northern axis.
 
Last edited:

LawLeadsToPeace

Senior Member
Staff member
Moderator - World Affairs
Registered Member
The biggest problem is they act like they will receive reinforcement from NATO or allies and need to buy some times. The only things they received are weapon systems from old stockpiles and a couple of new-tech weapons for testing them on Russians. The troops in that cauldron will turn to boiled blood if they don't surrender, what a mess.
I believe the Ukrainians are doing dumb maneuvers like that because Zelenskyy is afraid of losing Western support if he appears to be losing. If I remember correctly, this happened before during the Battle of Shanghai during the Second Sino-Japanese War: Jiang Jieshi wanted the West to militarily intervene and defeat Japan and doubled down in Shanghai. As a result, he lost all of his German trained elite troops and a huge chunk of his best troops and had to retreat anyway. Plus, the League of Nations only condemned Japan but didn’t do anything.
 

Topazchen

Junior Member
Registered Member
Russian special operations forces destroyed a group of militants in the Donbass.
Russian kamikaze drones Kub landing among a group of ukrainian troops, The filming is done by a ZALA drone :

Video of the escape of the Ukrainian paratroopers of the 79th ODSHBR fromLyman. In the process of retreating,the Ukrainian BTR-80 stops and picks up soldiers who have fled through the woods from the Russian shelling, which is haunting the retreating column :

Drone providing assistance to Russian BM-27 Uragan :
holy fvck! that Kamikaze drone was brutal. It looks like most were killed, and the two guys on the left, who look like they survived, sustained serious injuries.
 
Top