Star Wars talk!! Ok I'd like to start a sci-fi military discussion.
"George said the Imperial weapons attacking Hoth should look like walking tanks. The intention with the walker was to make it more frightening and anthropomorphic so it would look like a big robot. The idea of having a head and shapes that looked like big eyes and a big jaw was really to make it look more frightening."
- Joe Johnston
Art Director/Visual Effects Creator
These AT-AT walkers were
slow moving
large, easy to spot
top heavy and accident prone
very limited line of sight
terrible attack radius
vulnerable from air (hit them from an higher altitude) harder to pick off airplanes
Also vulnerable to mines? Why didn't the rebels lay plasma mines or have a speeder fly in front of them and lay 100s of mines?
Highly impractical... Did the Empire have just no competition militarily so they built everything just to intimidate and inflict fear?
I know it would ruin the plot and but I'd like to just discuss it.