PLA Strategy in a Taiwan Contingency

siegecrossbow

General
Staff member
Super Moderator
A Unitree Go2 robot dog sold for as low as $2,399 on Amazon. A mass produced suicide robot dog probably will cost less. They might be nightmare to enemy, especially if they charge like wolf pack or sneak in at dark night, with explosive equivalent to 155mm artillery shells.

Here’s the catch though. The 2,399 price is only for remote controlled version. The cost for one with AI bells and whistles is a lot higher.
 

CannedFish

New Member
Registered Member
How would the robot dogs differentiate between soldiers and civilians? Or identify decoys?
That is a problem for all drones, it isn't unique to robo dogs.
What can they do that an actual artillery piece can't? Perhaps trench clearing? But then wouldn't a flying drone be more effective?
They can be more precise/surgical than artillery, while being more quiet than flying drones. It's relatively easy to knock down a flying drone down, a robo dog would far more stable. Clearing a building would be far easier with one as well.
 

00CuriousObserver

Junior Member
Registered Member
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

Shi Haoyong 石好勇

Previously, he was the Vice Minister of the Ministry of State Security (国家安全部副部长)

During the 2016 North Korean nuclear crisis and the 2017 military tensions on the Korean Peninsula involving the U.S., he was assigned to a temporary post (挂职) in Yanbian prefecture (boarder between Jilin province and North Korea)

Now, he is a member of the Standing Committee of the Fujian Provincial Party Committee and Secretary of the Political and Legal Affairs Commission of the Provincial Party Committee(福建省委常委、省委政法委书记)

"挂职" (guà zhí) refers to a temporary job assignment or secondment, often used in the context of Chinese governance and organizational structures. It typically involves an individual being temporarily assigned to a position in another organization, region, or department to gain practical experience, exchange expertise, or assist in specific tasks or projects.

gzxqOqu.png


xzxnVWD.png
 

solarz

Brigadier
That is a problem for all drones, it isn't unique to robo dogs.

They can be more precise/surgical than artillery, while being more quiet than flying drones. It's relatively easy to knock down a flying drone down, a robo dog would far more stable. Clearing a building would be far easier with one as well.

Their intended role as a suicide bomber is not clear to me. If they need to be surgical, then they must be able to identify their targets. Flying drones are mainly used for recon and anti-tank roles, therefore they don't have that problem.

If they don't need to be surgical, then why not just shell the location with artillery strikes?

What kind of explosives would you use to clear out a building? If it's a large amount, it will just demolish the building instead. If you use small amounts, then you would need a lot of robo dogs to clear out even a single building. I would think a gun-dog would be more useful in that role than a suicide-pup.

Robodogs are much more expensive than flying drones. I think flyers are more effective as suicide bombers. Robodogs would be more useful as remote controlled assault units. Even outfitting them with grenade launchers would make them more effective than suiciders.
 

vincent

Grumpy Old Man
Staff member
Moderator - World Affairs
Their intended role as a suicide bomber is not clear to me. If they need to be surgical, then they must be able to identify their targets. Flying drones are mainly used for recon and anti-tank roles, therefore they don't have that problem.
No need to identify a target. GPS location or remote control can be used.
If they don't need to be surgical, then why not just shell the location with artillery strikes?
Guided artillery shells are more expensive. I think American ones cost more than $100k
What kind of explosives would you use to clear out a building? If it's a large amount, it will just demolish the building instead. If you use small amounts, then you would need a lot of robo dogs to clear out even a single building. I would think a gun-dog would be more useful in that role than a suicide-pup.
How do you plant the explosives? Send someone over?
Robodogs are much more expensive than flying drones. I think flyers are more effective as suicide bombers. Robodogs would be more useful as remote controlled assault units. Even outfitting them with grenade launchers would make them more effective than suiciders.
Robotic dogs can carry more load than drones with equivalent volume and are a lot more quiet.
 
Top