Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 is Missing

broadsword

Brigadier
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

Flight MH370: Terrorism expert backs theory of pilot suicide flight

By Vaimoana Tapaleao
4:15 AM Thursday Mar 27, 2014

A New Zealand criminologist has come out in support of a theory that the captain of the missing Malaysia Airlines aircraft was on a suicide mission.

University of Canterbury Professor Greg Newbold, who lectures on terrorism, said the only person who could have changed MH370's computerised flight plan and switched off its electronics was someone who was highly experienced.

That person, he acknowledged, could only have been the pilot, Captain Zaharie Ahmad Shah - a man with 30 years' flying experience.

His co-pilot on the March 8 flight, 27-year-old Fariq Abdul Hamid, was fairly inexperienced; having only been on his sixth flight in the cockpit and the first time as an unaided pilot.

"We know that after changing course, the aircraft flew briefly above its maximum ceiling. If the pilot had then depressurised the aircraft, all passengers and the crew - including the pilot - would have lost consciousness within a few minutes," Professor Newbold said.

"From here, the re-computerised flight plan would have allowed the plane to fly itself at a predetermined altitude and course until it eventually ran out of fuel and crashed.

"If this is correct, it would explain why no one on board apparently attempted to raise the alarm using a cellphone."

Professor Newbold's comments come after a Herald story, yesterday, of an exclusive interview with one of Captain Zaharie's closest friends, who is a pilot himself.

The man, who did not want to be named for fear of repercussions, said the captain was in no state of mind to be flying a Boeing 777.

It is understood Captain Zaharie had personal issues; having recently separated from his wife - whom he had children with. It is thought his relationship with another woman was also on the rocks.

The man said his old friend's world was crumbling and felt the captain had taken MH370 on a "last joyride".

- NZ Herald
 

plawolf

Lieutenant General
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

Its just like clockwork.

The first thing any organisation tries to do when something they do go horribly wrong is to try and pin the blame on a single crazy employee.
 

broadsword

Brigadier
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

If there was any organization that blame any of its employees for the disaster, it was not MAS. They have not done it yet. It was a criminologist who came out with his own theory.
 

Jeff Head

General
Registered Member
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
I have heard a lot about satellite photos, and new French sat photos. But I have not heard at all that any ship or aircraft had either positively identified from the air, much less picked up out of the sea, any confirmed pieces of the aircraft to date.

I watched all of the new reports this evening and there is no such report...and that would be big news.

As to the Doppler effect, what they have done is ingenious...but not new. Doppler effect is used all the time in combat aircraft...just never had to be applied to this situation before. And, their calculations are based on some important presumptions, that being the range of the aircraft (where the altitude, which they do not know, has a lot to do with that), and the speed of the aircraft (which also impacts range). If they are off in the speed, and the fuel range, they could also be way off in the location.

They simply have to find some confirmed wreckage to narrow the search...and I pray they do.
 

B.I.B.

Captain
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

If there was any organization that blame any of its employees for the disaster, it was not MAS. They have not done it yet. It was a criminologist who came out with his own theory.

Prof Newbold served time in prision for drug dealing is well positioned to speak on the mind of crazies and the depressed.. A big portion of his life had been spent hanging around them.
 

delft

Brigadier
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

Perhaps nothing from the aircraft will be found at sea and we will have to wait until some identifiable things are found on a Chilian beach in two years time.
 

Quickie

Colonel
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


I finally had some time to watch this video from CNN regarding how doppler effect was used by Inmarsat to figure out which direction the plane went. Perhaps they have left out some more technical details, but I don't think doppler effect alone, at least in the way that this guy explained it would have pointed out which of the two directions the plane took. Since the distance to satellites are basically circles on the map, the plane could have taken the northern route and still generated the same doppler effects at each of the pings.

There are lots of false information and news out there, sometimes simply out of sensationalism, hate or whatever. A news network reported that a MAS flight was hit by a flock of ducks during landing, damaging the screen but the pilots never bothered to report the incident and just walk away. MAS said the report is simply not true. A MAS flight was indeed hit a by a flock of ducks but it was the landing light that got damaged and the pilot did immediately report the incident to the Nepal authorities.

Perhaps they have left out some more technical details, but I don't think doppler effect alone, at least in the way that this guy explained it would have pointed out which of the two directions the plane took. Since the distance to satellites are basically circles on the map, the plane could have taken the northern route and still generated the same doppler effects at each of the pings.

The northern corridor and southern one are at a slightly different distance and heading in relation to the satellite. From this information, they apparently work out how this would affect the Doppler effect which they then match to the satellite data.
 
Last edited:

Jeff Head

General
Registered Member
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

Perhaps nothing from the aircraft will be found at sea and we will have to wait until some identifiable things are found on a Chilian beach in two years time.
Sadly, something like this may be the case. You are the first I have heard mention it like this...and if it turns out that way, I will point people back to your post.

As it is, apparently they are moving the search area almost 1,000 km to the Northeast now.
 
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


I finally had some time to watch this video from CNN regarding how doppler effect was used by Inmarsat to figure out which direction the plane went. Perhaps they have left out some more technical details, but I don't think doppler effect alone, at least in the way that this guy explained it would have pointed out which of the two directions the plane took. Since the distance to satellites are basically circles on the map, the plane could have taken the northern route and still generated the same doppler effects at each of the pings.

helpful information regardless. good to hear they found some debris. i hope they can find everything soon..
 

Jeff Head

General
Registered Member
Re: Malaysia Airlines Plane is Missing

helpful information regardless. good to hear they found some debris. i hope they can find everything soon..
They have not found any debris from the aircraft. The title to that article is misleading.

No identifiable debris from Flight MH370 has been found or recovered yet.
 
Top