Ladakh Flash Point

Status
Not open for further replies.

akcountant

Banned Idiot
Registered Member
Since no figures have been released officially, we cannot say for certain. A couple Chinese sources (including SCMP and someone who participated in the clashes) said zero Chinese soldiers were killed although there were some injuries. Another Chinese source said 2 were killed but also that 47 Indian soldiers were killed (although this later got deleted, likely because of faulty information). I don't know why you are being needlessly provocative towards other posters.
what is this Sources?? Tell you dont know!! Why no chinese people questioned the silence of Casualty of Soilders!! how soilders family would get respect? You are just assuming the casualty.. No doubt why india and world are making fun of chinese people, govt and PLA!! If you dont know, Just answer you dont NOOOO...
 

Figaro

Senior Member
Registered Member
what is this Sources?? Tell you dont know!! Why no chinese people questioned the silence of Casualty of Soilders!! how soilders family would get respect? You are just assuming the casualty.. No doubt why india and world are making fun of chinese people, govt and PLA!! If you dont know, Just answer you dont NOOOO...
You will have to dig through this near 300 page thread for yourself. I am not your servant. On the contrary, your commentary really suggests you have an ulterior motive at hand. How do we know you are not some sort of troll? Quite a few posters have already provided you reasons on why China did not release the casualty numbers and yet you completely dismiss them and press on with your provocative attitude. It looks like you do not believe the PLA suffered zero killed which alone raises suspicions of what I just said.
 

akcountant

Banned Idiot
Registered Member
It's called the first rule of Art of War. You achieve victory by knowing yourself and your enemy. By denying useful information to India China ensures they make mistake at least 50% of the time, and by the look of things I kind of doubt India knows itself either.
Just say you dont know or no chinese people know!! No doubt why world is making fun of China government and PLA!! No one will respect if you hide all details!!
 

akcountant

Banned Idiot
Registered Member
You will have to dig through this near 300 page thread for yourself. I am not your servant. On the contrary, your commentary really suggests you have an ulterior motive at hand. How do we know you are not some sort of troll? Quite a few posters have already provided you reasons on why China did not release the casualty numbers and yet you completely dismiss them and press on with your provocative attitude. It looks like you do not believe the PLA suffered zero killed which alone raises suspicions of what I just said.
Did China government release it? Its same like so called Propaganda media of India, usa which you guys claim...Why to boost about PLA when they are afraid to say the casualty count!! You dont have to be my servant...I got your answer...The Answer is you dont know!! Thanks
 

plawolf

Lieutenant General
Thats shameless...Sorry....No this is called covering up and not given due respect to final respect to Chinese soilders!! Dont you feel its shameless to hide Sacrifice of China soilders? And you try to give a another dimension of justifying to keep this secret!! Woww.....I repeat my question again. How many chinese soilders died in galwan?? If you dont know ...pls back off brother..i dont want to your justification!! You wrote all bla bla of PLA but cant answer a simple question. You said its to not escalate tension with India. No one will believe this. There is ful blown escalation from both sides and do you thing china is keeping secret to maintain relation with India. Do you want me to believe this?? Again Shameless

Yawn, another Indian troll.

Looks like someone has a quota for ‘shameless’ they need to hit. :rolleyes:

I gave you the facts, not my problem if you don’t like them.

But just to address your nonsensical point, different nations honour the scarify of their servicemen in different ways. Just because the west, and the west worshippers Indian like to plaster their dead all over the papers does not mean that is the only way a nation can or should honour its fallen.

That is assuming there were PLA fatalities at all. If there weren’t, which is entirely reasonable given how badly the Indians lost that fight (as evidenced by so many of them having died in their sheer desperation to flee), explicitly saying so would be rubbing Indian noses in it, which isn’t the Chinese way.

Chinese philosophy stresses the importance of compassion and restraint, in that by giving an opponent the chance to back down gracefully, you can potentially avoid further needless conflict and could even win the respect of an honourable foe for not disgracing them even though you could have.

OTOH, if an opponent proves too barbaric and/or blinded by hate to appreciate such niceties, such behaviour will be noted and reflected in future treatment of said foe.
 

Figaro

Senior Member
Registered Member
Just say you dont know or no chinese people know!! No doubt why world is making fun of China government and PLA!! No one will respect if you hide all details!!
Did China government release it? Its same like Propaganda media of India...Why to boost about PLA when they are afraid to say the casualty count!! You dont have to be my servant...I got your answer...The Answer is you dont know!! Thanks
Okay I think this is enough to conclude you are a troll, most likely an Indian troll who disguised his location as being from China. I have to say, these individuals are becoming increasingly sophisticated with their infiltration tactics. Completely disregarding answers from other posters and repeating the same question every single time in a provocative manner is really telling of your true identity. If you want to infiltrate this forum as a fake Chinese, try harder next time.
 

akcountant

Banned Idiot
Registered Member
Yawn, another Indian troll.

Looks like someone has a quota for ‘shameless’ they need to hit. :rolleyes:

I gave you the facts, not my problem if you don’t like them.

But just to address your nonsensical point, different nations honour the scarify of their servicemen in different ways. Just because the west, and the west worshippers Indian like to plaster their dead all over the papers does not mean that is the only way a nation can or should honour its fallen.

That is assuming there were PLA fatalities at all. If there weren’t, which is entirely reasonable given how badly the Indians lost that fight (as evidenced by so many of them having died in their sheer desperation to flee), explicitly saying so would be rubbing Indian noses in it, which isn’t the Chinese way.

Chinese philosophy stresses the importance of compassion and restraint, in that by giving an opponent the chance to back down gracefully, you can potentially avoid further needless conflict and could even win the respect of an honourable foe for not disgracing them even though you could have.

OTOH, if an opponent proves too barbaric and/or blinded by hate to appreciate such niceties, such behaviour will be noted and reflected in future treatment of said foe.
You cant answer and justifies with it as China way!! Wow...This shows what PLA ...Its just a coward people who cant even say to world what happened in Galwan!! These big statement does not even tell my answer!! How many chinese soilders died in galwan?? Why PLA or chinese army did not release the figures? I thought you have given big answers to lot of people so i thought you would know the answer!! Sorry i was wrong. You can continue with self boosting of PLA fight in galwan!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top