Looks like the Indian fake news machine is at work once again ... last time it was one Sikh soldier single handedly murdered 15 Chinese soldiers and now it is India capturing 15 vantage points.
Here is a better analysis:
Last edited:
Ladakh Flash Point
- Thread starter Mt1701d
- Start date
- Status
Here is a better analysis:
It's called the first rule of Art of War. You achieve victory by knowing yourself and your enemy. By denying useful information to India China ensures they make mistake at least 50% of the time, and by the look of things I kind of doubt India knows itself either.
plawolf
Lieutenant General
The Chinese government acknowledged casualties but did not release numbers to not embarrass the Indians. Note that China only acknowledged casualties but did not specify fatalities. There have been rumours of one or two fatalities from Chinese sources, but nothing official or confirmed.
As for the huge disparity in fatalities even if we assume a couple of PLA were killed, well that would not be surprising in the least considering the fact that the overwhelming majority of Indian fatalities resulted from injuries and exposure sustained while fleeing (some fell/jumped off cliffs and others fell/jumped/fled into the river in freezing temperatures). Only the 3 Indian fatalities first reported were killed fighting, which would make 0-2 PLA fatalities entirely reasonable.
No this is called covering up and not given due respect to final respect to Chinese soilders!! Dont you feel its shameless to hide Sacrifice of China soilders? And you try to give a another dimension of justifying to keep this secret!! Woww.....I repeat my question again. How many chinese soilders died in galwan?? If you dont know ...pls back off brother..i dont want to your justification!!
If no Chinese soldiers died at Galwan (which is by far the most likely case), then why is it necessary to say none of them died out loud? It would likely aggravate tensions with India quite significantly since the latter suffered at least 22 killed. If at least one or more PLA soldiers died, the Chinese probably would have released casualty statements. Keeping the dead a secret would bring no tangible benefits.
Thats shameless...Sorry....No this is called covering up and not given due respect to final respect to Chinese soilders!! Dont you feel its shameless to hide Sacrifice of China soilders? And you try to give a another dimension of justifying to keep this secret!! Woww.....I repeat my question again. How many chinese soilders died in galwan?? If you dont know ...pls back off brother..i dont want to your justification!! You wrote all bla bla of PLA but cant answer a simple question. You said its to not escalate tension with India. No one will believe this. There is ful blown escalation from both sides and do you thing china is keeping secret to maintain relation with India. Do you want me to believe this?? Again Shameless
Why are you saying shameless? Has it occurred to you the probability that no Chinese soldiers were killed? There is nothing to gain about bragging you suffered zero dead while an already furious country suffered over 20 dead.
Iam asking the same question. If you dont know ...you can back off ...let me ask someone else..How many chinese soilder died in galwan?? Answer straight.
Since no figures have been released officially, we cannot say for certain. A couple Chinese sources (including SCMP and someone who participated in the clashes) said zero Chinese soldiers were killed although there were some injuries. Another Chinese source said 2 were killed but also that 47 Indian soldiers were killed (although this later got deleted, likely because of faulty information). I don't know why you are being needlessly provocative towards other posters. Russia kept quiet that 200 of their soldiers were killed in a US airstrike in Syria back in early 2018. Even if one PLA soldier died, being under wraps is not that bad as you suggest.
Why no chinese people questioned the silence of Casualty of Soilders!! how soilders family would get respect? You are just assuming the casualty.. No doubt why india and world are making fun of chinese people, govt and PLA!! If you dont know, Just answer you dont NOOOO...
- Status