Ladakh Flash Point

Status
Not open for further replies.
SteelBird

SteelBird

Colonel
Figaro said:
Apparently the location of the standoff occurred was close to a very steep cliff. I would not be surprised in the slightest if some soldiers fell over and were killed during the scuffle.
Click to expand...
The news never claim anybody fell off the cliff. It first reported that 3 Indian soldiers died and then 17 others died due to serious injures. The deaths of the later 17 lives cost by serious of the injures though it never mentioned how come the injures. Apparently, the soldiers didn't die at the scene. So, the cliff is not in concern. What I want emphasize here is 20 lives is very serious, let alone this caused by cold stone-age weapons. I doubt this news is anywhere near truth.
 
Xizor

Xizor

Captain
Registered Member
What's the possibility that there were Bullets involved? It is pretty hard to digest that a gladiator style massive melee match went down in sub-zero temperatures that too on high altitude thin air. We are talking about 100 VS 100 soldiers.

I don't believe that not a single soldier went for their guns. Unless, some kind of vehicles were involved. Maybe someone in the Chinese side decided to use their trucks to ram into Indian troops?

Or maybe someone kept their trucks in neutral and decided to let it roll down a steep cliff (apparently Chinese were at a higher elevation). Maybe there was a group of Indian soldiers who decided to march up the cliff and then one Chinese soldier decided to let the truck in neutral be a bowling ball.


I simply can't fathom how even 10 or 20 deaths can happen with no guns.
 
P

Petrolicious88

Senior Member
Registered Member
Xsizor said:
What's the possibility that there were Bullets involved? It is pretty hard to digest that a gladiator style massive melee match went down in sub-zero temperatures that too on high altitude thin air. We are talking about 100 VS 100 soldiers.

I don't believe that not a single soldier went for their guns. Unless, some kind of vehicles were involved. Maybe someone in the Chinese side decided to use their trucks to ram into Indian troops?

Or maybe someone kept their trucks in neutral and decided to let it roll down a steep cliff (apparently Chinese were at a higher elevation). Maybe there was a group of Indian soldiers who decided to march up the cliff and then one Chinese soldier decided to let the truck in neutral be a bowling ball.


I simply can't fathom how even 10 or 20 deaths can happen with no guns.
Click to expand...

Stones and bats and clubs. No guns needed
 
localizer

localizer

Colonel
Registered Member
It's obviously indian/US fault, China has managed to not get into a violent conflict in decades. Track record ruined by indians.
 
G

gadgetcool5

Senior Member
Registered Member
Another discussion group I am in, an American said it's good for them that China and India are at odds because it lets America pit India against China as another counterweight.
 
manqiangrexue

manqiangrexue

Brigadier
gadgetcool5 said:
Another discussion group I am in, an American said it's good for them that China and India are at odds because it lets America pit India against China as another counterweight.
Click to expand...
Goodness gracious, we're so glad to have a mole like you telling us what the Americans think. Quickly, warn the Indians that they're being used so they withdraw and give up that land to us that you say is so useless! I'm sure they'll agree with you; you can convince someone to agree with you, right? Not every country thinks you're out of your mind to ask them to cede "useless, toxic" territory for "good relations", right? LOL
 
Last edited:
F

foxmulder

Junior Member
gadgetcool5 said:
Another discussion group I am in, an American said it's good for them that China and India are at odds because it lets America pit India against China as another counterweight.
Click to expand...

I dont blame US at all with this one. India should use some brains. They are willingly playing a pawn. Indians are keep passing to the Chinese side of LAC and crying foul. Seriously, you can not make this up.


Xsizor said:
What's the possibility that there were Bullets involved? It is pretty hard to digest that a gladiator style massive melee match went down in sub-zero temperatures that too on high altitude thin air. We are talking about 100 VS 100 soldiers.

I don't believe that not a single soldier went for their guns. Unless, some kind of vehicles were involved. Maybe someone in the Chinese side decided to use their trucks to ram into Indian troops?

Or maybe someone kept their trucks in neutral and decided to let it roll down a steep cliff (apparently Chinese were at a higher elevation). Maybe there was a group of Indian soldiers who decided to march up the cliff and then one Chinese soldier decided to let the truck in neutral be a bowling ball.


I simply can't fathom how even 10 or 20 deaths can happen with no guns.
Click to expand...

They (at least the most) don't even carry guns during this incidents. You can watch the videos.
 
L

LesAdieux

Junior Member
SteelBird said:
The news never claim anybody fell off the cliff. It first reported that 3 Indian soldiers died and then 17 others died due to serious injures. The deaths of the later 17 lives cost by serious of the injures though it never mentioned how come the injures. Apparently, the soldiers didn't die at the scene. So, the cliff is not in concern. What I want emphasize here is 20 lives is very serious, let alone this caused by cold stone-age weapons. I doubt this news is anywhere near truth.
Click to expand...

dozens of indians were captured and released, they'll tell their side's story later.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top