Yeah, maybe few meters? This is so funny.
The PLA posts and PP19 aren't kilometers away, just meters. If you include Chinese armored columns, then it's way less.
Ladakh Flash Point
- Thread starter Mt1701d
- Start date
- Status
The PLA posts and PP19 aren't kilometers away, just meters. If you include Chinese armored columns, then it's way less.
Subject : GOGRA (PP17A to PP19)
Enlighten us confused members by preparing a map taking satellite images of Detresfa and your knowledge about where PP19, PP17A, PP18, PP20 lies.
You seem to insist that these patrol points are somewhere different.
Detresfa's image clearly shows it is 15km from Indian gogra post, and by extension over 6 k m from pp19. It is clear you have no idea where Gogra and the PLa post actually are.
Once again, already been posted ages ago, but here it is again
Exact location of Chinese post
Yes. China's camp is on China's side of LAC (however one interprets LAC that's within general consensus). And what? You're saying China lost land LOLOLOLOLOL
Explain what China lost.
@twineedle... how does showing a satellite image of China's camp right on the border of territory they won after winning 1962 war, show that China lost land??
It only shows China has a major military position right on the edge of land it won in the past and sitting right on land that India claims.
May I remind you that India claims the dotted stretch in between? On which this PLA camp is right on the western side edge?
It only shows China has a major military position right on the edge of land it won in the past and sitting right on land that India claims.
May I remind you that India claims the dotted stretch in between? On which this PLA camp is right on the western side edge?
Once again, you still have not showed evidence of the "armored columns" supposedly meters away from pp19. Or for that matter, any evidence of a buffer zone including Indian territory.
I am simply countering xsizor's assertion that there is a buffer zone excusively on India's side of the lac. Everything I have said is going by his logic, not mine. Even if there is a buffer zone according to him*which I have argued against) that must mean that buffer zone includes parts of Chinese territory, since the nearest Chinese base is over 6 km away.
Yes. And this is what I've marked.
The issue now seems to be about location of Patrol Points, specifically pp19.
Make a map for Patrol Points that you think are right.
Yeah, I'm surprised too. It's too close. But then they have, reportedly, Artillery support from the hills just behind.
The Gogra post would be in sight of the Artillery.
I am going by what Ajai Shukla uses, since that is the source of the map you have used.
- Status