No think tank is going to openly say America lost are they? They were all claiming America could win right up until the Taliban took Kabul. 50 years on from Vietnam you still get Americans in denial about the massive L they took there. "we didn't lose, it was a tie!"That's not really what the report said though. It didn't say that Russia was "winning". Indeed, it is doubtful that any American think tank would ever say that out loud.
What the report said, was that protracted conflicted increases the potential for a direct NATO-Russia conflict and potential Russian nuclear use. Therefore, it is in the interest of United States to facilitate an end to the war. As for who's really "winning". It's far too soon to call it for any side. Ukraine has had a lot of success in the last 6 months, and we've been through periods when Russia was making progress, only to be setback by new forms of Western aid or a successful Ukrainian counter attack.
We'll see how the war goes, but just looking at the situation in Ugledar, there is more ugliness to go through before a resolution to the conflict can be found.
Going from "lets bleed Russia as much as we can" to "Okay that's enough, time to wrap it up" in less than a year is as much as a tacit acknowledgement of defeat as you'll ever see from a American.
Maybe, just maybe, the statement was designed to be as ambiguous as possible? The Russians aren't going to give away the game plan before it's happened.Entire width of the front? From Kherson to Kharkov? What are they trying to do? Man would have thought that they by now learnt about schwepunkt... Especially it was the whole concept of Soviet Cold War doctrine.
What did Napoleon once said in similar situation: "Are they trying to stop smuggling?"
When former Russian general think's that 7 km Russian progress is insignificant in comparison what the Red Army could in WW2- that's allright. But when I repeat that- that's mocking of Russia.
Obviously you have to be a Russian general to be allowed to mock Russia- presumably they have insider knowledge about the subject.
BTW being from a former Soviet state doesn't automatically give you pro-Russian credentials.