Saw Wolverine with our CoOp today. Funny thing is we were originally going to see Pacific Rim but the Theatre screwed up the schedule, so we settled with Wolverine instead.
Overall I enjoyed the film (though one of my colleagues didn't) but didn't like it as much as I thought I would. Guess Jeff is a bit responsible in that respect. It was a fun ride but didn't quite live up to my expectations. Time for what I liked and didn't like about the film.
What I liked:
Believe it or not, I thought that the fact that the film concentrated on a new setting (Japan) and not on the mutants was a great move. By focusing on a relatively small number of normal (Wolverine's body guard didn't count since her power had no combat applications) I thought that the film succeeded on a grittier and more "realistic level". I never I thought that I would say this about a film with clawed mutants mowing down grappling arrow firing ninjas, but I think this film is perhaps the most emotional one out of the X-Men series. We see Logan actually interacting with non-powered people in meaningful ways (something the previous Wolverine film attempted but failed at).
The action scenes were intense, and the fact that wolverine didn't have his healing factor for a good portion of the film kept me on the edge. Good thing they did that or else the audience won't be invested.
What I didn't like:
Stereotypical portrayal of oriental culture and especially the men. There was only one Japanese guy who was half decent (Japanese Hawkeye, I'll call him that since the name eludes me) and all the other ones are corrupt womanizers, power hungry jerk who slap women, or power hungry jerk who wants immortality. Basically, this is the mall ninja or otaku's vision of Japan. You have Yakuza mobs with submachine guns and ninjas running around in stereotypical black outfits. People still fight with samurai swords, blah blah... I know that a lot of it is done in the rule of cool, but I still wished that they could have shown more respect. They also showed horny Japanese men consistently hitting on Caucasian chicks while it is OK for Logan to do the same to a Japanese chick... I think many oriental viewers might find unfortunate implications in those scenes and take it the wrong way.
The villain motive was equally bizarre. I couldn't figure out for my life what the Viper's motive was (for eviluz????). The Japanese corporate leader's turn to villainy was also a bit sudden. They took care to cast him in a sympathetic life during the flashback and he is suddenly a evil murderer in the present day. There should have been more foreshadowing.
Despite the setbacks, all the bad elements were cancelled out by Ian McKellan and Patrick Stewart's cameos in the post-credit scene. Overall, an enjoyable film with issues that need to be tweaked out.