I'm amazed this was actually published.
Western exceptionalism is confirmed to be an actual mental disease, now backed up by a peer-reviewed study produced by one of the world's most respected experimental neurology journals:
People in the U.S. Think They Are Better Than They Actually Are.
Western individualism may promote a “better than you actually are” mindset
Specifically, we looked at the magnitude of the “alpha wave”—a pattern of activity that appears when a person’s mind wanders and engages in internally directed thoughts. We observed the alpha effect when Americans thought about themselves within a fraction of a second after learning that something good happened to them. This early attention predicted the magnitude of Americans' "positive illusions"— a cognitive bias that makes you feel more competent, more blessed, more fortunate and better than you actually are. Taiwanese participants did not show this pattern when thinking about either success or failure happening to the self, nor did they show evidence of holding positive illusions, as mentioned above.
Some Western psychologists have tried to explain the absence of positive illusions by arguing that "East Asians disguise their true feelings" to avoid appearing too self-focused, under the racial stereotype that East Asians value and act under "false modesty". But our data show that this explanation is inaccurate. We saw no added brain activity, for instance, that would correlate with effortful concealment of one’s true feelings among the Taiwanese people who participated in our study.
Westerners take an additional step to boost their good feeling when something good happens to them. Westerners spontaneously maximize good feelings about the self through an automatic neural response. It occurs within a fraction of a second, without apparent effort, let alone any deliberation or conscious strategizing. Such a response might seem "natural" and "inevitable", but it is not. Instead the response is cultural, having formed through years of socialization. The brain is to produce this response because it supports attitudes that help a person fit into their individualistic culture, valuing self-promotion and initiative. East Asians show no such spontaneous or automatic response. They would seem to be more accepting of various events as those events happen to them. Other work we have done has found that while self-esteem predicts health in the West, it does in East Asian societies.
In many cultures outside the West, people regard their selves as interdependent and embedded in social relationships. They feel protected and secure when connected to a larger social community. From that cultural perspective, there is no need to feel particularly good about one’s independent, individual self.
From the Western perspective, East Asians might appear excessively polite in their attention to social ties or could seem disengaged or even depressed or maladjusted in their ambivalence toward self-promotion and initiative. Our data, however, show that East Asians respond to events naturally and realistically, without extra thought. From the East Asian perspective, the Western tendency to boast good feelings about oneself could come across as futile, unnecessary or even childish because it shows how the person is failing to appreciate the relational nature of the self.
Ok fair enough. The Three Body Problem series were much more serious than TWE. Maybe the filmmakers did a poor job adapting TWE into cinema.Don't confuse the movie with the book (actually a short story). The movie has an entirely different plotline to make it an action blockbuster, ngl I enjoyed it even though some parts is a little cringy. The original story has a much more mature tone, mostly exploring the concept of wondering earth and it's implications to our civilization..... and politically take a massive dump on populism.
My gripe with TWE is not really about the concept of moving the Earth around; though I still dislike that concept. My problem is the supposedly serious setting of TWE. Star Trek is set in its own fictional universe. Along with Star Wars, and Warhammer 40k. If TWE was set in the W40k universe. Then fine, put some massive god engines on Holy Terra and off we go. We can shut off our brains and enjoy the show. I can even argue that many of W40k technology is also remotely feasible. But TWE is set in the near feasible future, with contemporary political and social settings, and contemporary understanding of science. So TWE was meant to be hard sci-fi, not the fantastical sci-fi of W40k or Star Trek. Hard sci-fi need not be accurate, but it is supposed to showcase a better appreciation of science by the filmmaker. I see TWE as an underwhelming representation of that.Also the concept of wondering earth isn't as ridiculous as you may think. Yes, even with fusion energy, all the deuterium in the ocean is not even enough to give earth 1m/s of delta-v, but what if human learnt to fuse heavier atoms? Entire Earth mass can be used as fuel and reaction mass, burn off 0.1% of earth mass can give us enough delta-v to leave the system.
Is it ridiculous? of course it is. Is it physically impossible? No it is not, hell of a lot more plausible than star trek teleporter, as least it doesn't requires Heisenberg compensator....
I think it is indeed so. This kind of 'psychological problem' is just a sense of superiority brought about by the advantages accumulated over a long period of time."American Exceptionalism" is simply the Dunning-Kruger effect on a cultural scale.
I will say that I'm mildly surprised Taiwanese still retain a somewhat sane sense of self given the extreme cultural contamination they've been subjected to.
I think if they did the same study on Indians, the results might shock them even more. Not all people in Asia behave the same way.I'm amazed this was actually published.
Western exceptionalism is confirmed to be an actual mental disease, now backed up by a peer-reviewed study produced by one of the world's most respected experimental neurology journals:
People in the U.S. Think They Are Better Than They Actually Are.
Western individualism may promote a “better than you actually are” mindset
Specifically, we looked at the magnitude of the “alpha wave”—a pattern of activity that appears when a person’s mind wanders and engages in internally directed thoughts. We observed the alpha effect when Americans thought about themselves within a fraction of a second after learning that something good happened to them. This early attention predicted the magnitude of Americans' "positive illusions"— a cognitive bias that makes you feel more competent, more blessed, more fortunate and better than you actually are. Taiwanese participants did not show this pattern when thinking about either success or failure happening to the self, nor did they show evidence of holding positive illusions, as mentioned above.
Some Western psychologists have tried to explain the absence of positive illusions by arguing that "East Asians disguise their true feelings" to avoid appearing too self-focused, under the racial stereotype that East Asians value and act under "false modesty". But our data show that this explanation is inaccurate. We saw no added brain activity, for instance, that would correlate with effortful concealment of one’s true feelings among the Taiwanese people who participated in our study.
Westerners take an additional step to boost their good feeling when something good happens to them. Westerners spontaneously maximize good feelings about the self through an automatic neural response. It occurs within a fraction of a second, without apparent effort, let alone any deliberation or conscious strategizing. Such a response might seem "natural" and "inevitable", but it is not. Instead the response is cultural, having formed through years of socialization. The brain is to produce this response because it supports attitudes that help a person fit into their individualistic culture, valuing self-promotion and initiative. East Asians show no such spontaneous or automatic response. They would seem to be more accepting of various events as those events happen to them. Other work we have done has found that while self-esteem predicts health in the West, it does in East Asian societies.
In many cultures outside the West, people regard their selves as interdependent and embedded in social relationships. They feel protected and secure when connected to a larger social community. From that cultural perspective, there is no need to feel particularly good about one’s independent, individual self.
From the Western perspective, East Asians might appear excessively polite in their attention to social ties or could seem disengaged or even depressed or maladjusted in their ambivalence toward self-promotion and initiative. Our data, however, show that East Asians respond to events naturally and realistically, without extra thought. From the East Asian perspective, the Western tendency to boast good feelings about oneself could come across as futile, unnecessary or even childish because it shows how the person is failing to appreciate the relational nature of the self.
Surely indians and other countries that are far less well off than any in Asia have this as well. More likely, it is a mental disorder created by insufficient education and too strong government propaganda.I think it is indeed so. This kind of 'psychological problem' is just a sense of superiority brought about by the advantages accumulated over a long period of time.
Then these people mistakenly view the accumulated advantage as an inherent racial advantage.
If the Chinese or Russians did the same thing to the anglos you can bet there’d be sanctions and cries of being unfriendly and wanting a Cold War.
No, even when presented with incontrovertible fact, the Indian solipsistically rejects it in favour of his desired substitute for reality. We saw this in Galwan, and even if you take a cursory glance at the Indians on twitter, you have Indians honestly believing Indians are taller, bigger and stronger than Chinese and superior in every way.” Vishwaguru” it’s now commonly mocked.I think if they did the same study on Indians, the results might shock them even more. Not all people in Asia behave the same way.
This is a classic work that exudes a sense of despair.I wish that book will be translated in English so that I can hand out some copies of the book for people to read, comprehend, and contemplate. Too many books written are ALL TOO WESTERN CENTRIC and whenever there's a translation of books that are not of the western indoctrination they dilute the translation which loses the books meaning and purpose along with the authors intent.