To be honest, that is exactly what I am dissatisfied and unhappy with a lot of these Chinese current-event online commentators.
- A lot of them can go bombastic with super clickbaity titles to attract viewerships.
- A lot of them don't even have concrete topics to discuss and talk about, but because they have to release content once or twice per day, they choose to pump out video that either has little to no new information, and/or basically just repeat the same information over and over again.
- A lot of them are also regurgitating the information from their peers, i.e. similar commentators on the Internet.
- Some of them went as far as going hyperbole, or even just invent fake news and information just to rile up their audience and attract even more viewerships.
Therefore, apart from
Shilao and
some on Guancha, honestly I could only find two Chinese commentators that carry actual weight in their information and news delivery and discussion:
1.
Liu Xiaofei (刘晓非说). The commentator is Liu Xiaofei(刘晓非), who is an experienced military expert, analyst and writer.
2.
Inspector Lei's Observation Room (瞩望云霄).The commentator is Fu Qianshao(傅前哨). He joined the PLA in 1968, graduated from Northwestern Polytechnic University in 1977, majoring in aerodynamics, and served as a mechanic, sub-captain, editor and director. Now he is the deputy editor of Air Force Aviation Magazine.
Albeit, there are information here and there from these two that can be outdated or inaccurate at times, but both of them are generally very reliable, in my opinion.
Other than those two, some on Guancha, and Shilao (albeit I rarely listened to Shilao, if ever), I couldn't find any other Chinese commentator with comparable weights and calibre as these commentators (or at least, not yet).