I suppose the question is what is a "genuinely transcendent work of art in its own right".
For the type of game that it is -- a primarily action RPG, that is by design not open world but still with extensive secret items/miniquests/boss fights, and side paths, I consider this game to be among the best. If you combine that with respect for the lore and culture that is depicted in an original way, with also some excellent characterization and cutscenes (beyond say, the likes that Fromsoft usually has), all wrapped up in a technically impressive package with excellent art direction, boss design, and combat mechanics, I think for the type of game that it is it really is a work of art that stands up with the best among the genre it lies in.
For example, if we are talking about action RPGs, many people are moving towards a more "souls-flavoured" design these days, but that doesn't mean Demons Souls (or Kings Field before it) meant that the successors (Dark Souls 1, 2, 3, Bloodborne, Sekiro, Elden Ring) didn't have "genuinely transcendent works of art" among them either or that other action RPGs which takes souls-esque elements like God of War 2018/Ragnarok and Jedi Fallen Order/Survivor didn't take significant elements from them as well or that they were not also works of art with their own strengths.
If you are talking industry changing games like Counter Strike for FPS or the original Starcraft for RTS (or more recently, Genshin Impact as a Gacha game with AAA quality), I certainly agree that Black Myth isn't that -- but at the same time I don't think there have been many games like that in modern history.
If we are comparing it to J-20, I suppose it also depends on what we view J-20 as.
IMO J-20 was proof that the Chinese aerospace industry could produce a highly competitive product that was in many of the important aspects at minimal equal to the best of what could be produced elsewhere, and set a foundational benchmark for future expectations of new products and development, while also having both industry success and success in providing immense military capabilities to its specified customers.
For Black Myth, I see it as proof that the Chinese videogame development industry are able to produce a highly competitive product that is broadly excellent and competitive at minimum in many important domains of its genre, and it sets a foundational benchmark for what future products of this category are expected to match or exceed, while also being critically and commercially successful domestically and abroad.
As someone whose preferred videogame genre are action RPGs of the Souls or Souls-adjacent variety (I've played Dark Souls, Dark Souls III, Bloodborne, Sekiro, God of War 2018, Jedi Fallen Order, Elden Ring, a bit of Stellar Blade), while also having exposure to some other varieties over the years (Last of Us, Horizon, Starcraft II, Diablo III, Genshin Impact, Persona 5, Armoured Core 6, Ratchet and Clank), I very much consider Black Myth to be in the action RPG/Souls-adjacent category and it was always advertised as such.
As an action RPG, the most important features I personally value are: combat mechanics, enemy design and variety, boss design and variety, level design.
Other features that help an action RPG stand out include: art direction, graphics, lore/world building, characterization, voice acting.
For the "important features of an action RPG", I consider all of them to be "excellent or spectacular" for Black Myth, except for level design which I would rate as "competent to good" (which isn't bad per se -- for example I would say level design in Black Myth is no inferior to Demons Souls, or Sekiro in terms of linearity, maybe a bit better for some levels in terms of open-worldness, and worse in terms of invisible walls/boundary setting)
For the "other features" that help an action RPG stand out, I consider all of the factors to be "excellent or spectacular" except for possibly graphics which is dependent on your own setup (and even then at minimum I'd rate it as "excellent").
Last edited:
