The hard lesson over the last 18 months has been that you can't win the PR war as long as you don't control platforms.I am not suggesting China to take offensive in PR war, let alone to fight an ideological war with the US beyond the borders.
But, within China, there are still battles to win the minds and hearts. As I said in one of my previous posts, even with the approval rate of 90% or 95%, there are still tens of millions unhappy mainland Chinese. And you mentioned HK, TW and XJ.
I found it quite interesting that you and some others keep saying that China cannot win the PR war with the US and/or the west. Why is that? CPC won the PR war with KMT. Even if CPC has stopped exporting its communism ideology, it still has PR battles to fight within China and it must not lose. What happened in 1986 and 1989 are clear examples of compaigns on minds and hearts followed by physical sabotages and riots by the west.
Also, you and some others seem to suggest that, if China is to fight back in the PR war, China would necessarily go down the path of the western media and to start doing evils. Why is that?
Your YouTube channel with 5 million followers can be shadow banned or deleted in an instant and so can all your social media pages. Don't even talk about Wikipedia where you pages are edited from Langley
You have got a news app with millions of downloads? It just takes an article on Bloomberg to manufacture consent and it is removed from the App and Play stores.
China's control of platforms at home is why it is very difficult for western Intel agencies to run and win propaganda there.
The same is true for western control of platforms in the rest of the world.
That's why the Huawei and Tiktok battles are very important. Their success means the success of Chinese platforms worldwide and building a PR machine on top of them is a breeze