Chinese Economics Thread

PopularScience

Junior Member
Registered Member
Having spend some time in Chongqing and XI'an, China, I actually find that the cost of food in China is very affordable. In my country just 3 years ago I can buy a meal for say $5, 3 years later the same meal now cost me $10. Yet our wages hardly keep up with inflation. I found meals in Chongqing and Xi'an much cheaper than Malaysia, and I was there spending as a tourist.

The low inflation in China means even if you have a "low growth rate" of 4%, you will still enjoy a good afforable lives. However, given cash subsidies to encourage spendings is only good in short term and not effective to stimulate the overall economy.

China's medical and education expenses are way too expensive. As a socialist country China should do better in subsiding these. Free medical expenses in government hospitals and free educations can help many citizens in saving their monthly incomes and also encourage them to spend more on other consumables. This is way better than giving out cash.

Also the government should take the opportunity to implement public housing with affordable rentals similar to Singapore. And I do agree that let those housing developers go with slow pace of bankcruptcies to lessen disruption in economies and employments.
university tuition fees is less than 8,000 per year. This is very affordable.
 

Randomuser

Senior Member
Registered Member
The reality is that the world, led by moves in the US and EU, is becoming more protectionist. It may not ever get as bad as the Age of Mercantilism when countries actively blocked trade except between their colonies and so every great power was incentivized to colonize as much as possible, but still trends are shifting.

The question is what is China doing or should be doing to adapt and exploit this new reality.
Just shows the west was never about free trade and the mask is coming off now.
 

manqiangrexue

Brigadier
I think medical treament costs in US and Canada are among the highest in the World. China is not cheap either, especially as a percentage of average earning of her citizens. As to why people from Canada and USA go to China for treatment, I think the major factor isthat the costs in China is relativelt cheap as a percentage of their income in USA and Canada. Also another reason could be the waiting time for appoinment.

The main difference is the gap of average income between people in China and those in USA and Canada. Thus people from North America would naturally think that medical expenses in China is not expensive but local Chinese people would think otherwise.



To be objective, I asked Microsoft Copilot AI chatbot the same question as above posters, and the reply is a below.

The cost of medical treatment varies significantly between China, Canada, and the USA. Let’s break it down:

  1. United States (USA):
    • The U.S. has higher prices for most health care services and prescription drugs compared to other high-income countries.
    • Despite having fewer office visits and shorter average hospital stays, the U.S. spends twice as much per person on healthcare than comparable countries.
    • Per capita spending for health costs in the U.S.
      Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
    • Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
  2. China:
    • International-standard medical care in China is relatively expensive because it is not supported by the State system. Hospitals are essentially privately run.
    • Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
    • Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
  3. Canada:
    • Canada spends less per person on healthcare than the U.S.
    • Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
In summary, while the U.S. has higher healthcare costs, China and Canada offer more affordable options. Keep in mind that these are general trends, and individual cases may vary. Always consult local sources and consider insurance coverage when seeking medical treatment.
China is a very obvious choice in healthcare for Westerners because it is all the quality at a lower, though not insanely low, price. China's healthcare maintains a world-beating level of quality, oftentimes exceeding that in the West, though those countries will never allow that to turn into mainstream knowledge in their population. There are many other countries that are much cheaper than China, but often, the professionalism and quality are lower. They are good for routine/small needs with very little risk of fucking up and oftentimes, you can pay a few hundred dollars for something that would cost $10-30K in the US.

My wife went to a fertility clinic in the US to do her tests to make sure her body was ready for IVF before heading off to Kazakhstan, where we would do IVF+surrogacy for a paltry price. When the clinic passed her and began their IVF sales pitch on her, she told them she was going to Kazakhstan to do it. They strongly recommended against it and said that the US is more expensive but they are the best and don't you want the best for your baby? She then told them that she's going to use surrogates for 4 kids so the US is not a choice due to the cost. When they realized they weren't getting her business, they put all their cards on the table and told her they recommend she go to China because Chinese IVF is equal to American but significantly cheaper. They then cautioned that they'd be very worried about the quality in Kazakhstan because they have no idea what they'd do to her over there. But they were not aware that surrogacy is not legal in China.

I required a surgery that cost $40K in the US (with a 9 month wait), $10K in China, $1.2K in Kazakhstan. Since I would already be in Kazakhstan and this surgery is not typically associated with life threat or serious adverse effects, I did it in Kazakhstan, with a 1 day wait. Result was very good but the hospital amenities sucked big time. If I had to do it again, my choice would be the same, but if I needed something more serious, like open chest surgery, I'd go to China.
The reality is that the world, led by moves in the US and EU, is becoming more protectionist. It may not ever get as bad as the Age of Mercantilism when countries actively blocked trade except between their colonies and so every great power was incentivized to colonize as much as possible, but still trends are shifting.

The question is what is China doing or should be doing to adapt and exploit this new reality.
The answer is obvious. China's making the best stuff at all ends of the spectrum all the way to the most modern technology. So if the EU and US want to circle jerk with thier own expensive low quality low tech bullshit, they can. China will export to all the countries that the Western Europeans and Americans looked down upon. And the US/EU consumers will feel more and more like they slap themselves everytime they don't buy Chinese. Eventually, it will be too late for them when they're driving around in old gass guzzlers with bullshit smartphones and they see some Africans/Latinos fly by in a Chinese self-driving car levitated 2 feet off the ground while surfing the internet with a Chinese phone that projects the screen into the air. Then they'll know they have effectively fucked themselves into the third world.
 
Last edited:

MortyandRick

Senior Member
Registered Member
I think medical treament costs in US and Canada are among the highest in the World. China is not cheap either, especially as a percentage of average earning of her citizens. As to why people from Canada and USA go to China for treatment, I think the major factor isthat the costs in China is relativelt cheap as a percentage of their income in USA and Canada. Also another reason could be the waiting time for appoinment.

The main difference is the gap of average income between people in China and those in USA and Canada. Thus people from North America would naturally think that medical expenses in China is not expensive but local Chinese people would think otherwise.



To be objective, I asked Microsoft Copilot AI chatbot the same question as above posters, and the reply is a below.

The cost of medical treatment varies significantly between China, Canada, and the USA. Let’s break it down:

  1. United States (USA):
    • The U.S. has higher prices for most health care services and prescription drugs compared to other high-income countries.
    • Despite having fewer office visits and shorter average hospital stays, the U.S. spends twice as much per person on healthcare than comparable countries.
    • Per capita spending for health costs in the U.S.
      Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
    • Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
  2. China:
    • International-standard medical care in China is relatively expensive because it is not supported by the State system. Hospitals are essentially privately run.
    • Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
    • Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
  3. Canada:
    • Canada spends less per person on healthcare than the U.S.
    • Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
      .
In summary, while the U.S. has higher healthcare costs, China and Canada offer more affordable options. Keep in mind that these are general trends, and individual cases may vary. Always consult local sources and consider insurance coverage when seeking medical treatment.
Just a couple thoughts on this. Not to say its definitive but I was interested in running some numbers

1. US health care expenditure per capita is 13,400$ per year on a GDP per capita of $76,400 which is ~20%

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

China health care expenditure per capita is $2,850 yuan per year across the country

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

and the a GDP per capita of Gansu (which is one of the lowest in the country) is ~$45,000 yuan. So using the lowest GDP per capital province in China, the national health care expenditure is around 5%.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

If we look at health care expenditure per capita in Beijing, it's $4,304 yuan in 2022, which is an even smaller percentage of the per capital GDP of a person in Beijing of $190,313 yuan. Thus cost is <3%

In Canada, health care expenditure is around $8,563 CAD per Canadian in 2022 on a GDP per capita of $62,356 CAD.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

This health care expenditure is 13.7% of GDP per capita. All in CAD.

So I'd say china health care is so far still affordable.

2. Not sure why open AI used the term "international standard" hospitals? Is that to say china standard hospitals are not good enough and that's why they are cheaper? That's a bit biased and frankly a bit insulting.

International hospital in China are a thing but they usually charge a lot more for the same service in my experience and foreign travellers and expats use insurance to pay so the costs are inflated. They are quite multilingual which is beneficial for travellers and expats, but many of the same doctors work in Chinese and international hospitals.

So I don't think you need to go to "international standard" hospitals to get good care as evidenced by chinas increasing life expectancy and QOL.
 

BlackWindMnt

Captain
Registered Member
The reality is that the world, led by moves in the US and EU, is becoming more protectionist. It may not ever get as bad as the Age of Mercantilism when countries actively blocked trade except between their colonies and so every great power was incentivized to colonize as much as possible, but still trends are shifting.

The question is what is China doing or should be doing to adapt and exploit this new reality.
That would be GG well played China you're now the number 1 economy in the world.
Like some say China will just rugpull the west into low or middle income status.

The euro & dollar only has value because they allowed you to trade easier and buy equipment, tooling and semi conductors to escape low income status. If china can offer those things of a better quality and a lower price what use or value does the Euro and dollar hold?
 

AndrewS

Brigadier
Registered Member
The reality is that the world, led by moves in the US and EU, is becoming more protectionist. It may not ever get as bad as the Age of Mercantilism when countries actively blocked trade except between their colonies and so every great power was incentivized to colonize as much as possible, but still trends are shifting.

The question is what is China doing or should be doing to adapt and exploit this new reality.

You can see that today there are 3 concentrations of economic wealth and industrial activity, namely:

1. Europe (centred around the EU)
2. North America (centred on the USA)
3. East Asia (centred on China)

Each can be relatively self-sufficient because of their size in terms of population, natural resources, economic/industrial activity etc.
But we can already see that East Asia is already significantly larger than either Europe or North America. Furthermore, this lead should continue to grow.

Overall, the world outside of the West accounts for 88% of global population and 60% of global economic activity.
And as time goes, this non-Western share will continue to increase, to 70% and potentially to 80+% of global economic activity.
If China becomes wealthy and developed, then China by itself would be significantly larger than the US and EU combined.
So the US and the EU become increasingly irrelevant in the global scheme of things.

Those countries which embrace low-cost electricity generation and low-cost EVs from China will be able to outcompete the other countries such as the USA which block Chinese imports.

---

Overall, the strategy is to:
1. move up the value chain and develop world-class products. If China becomes hi-tech, won't China be high-income as well?
2. continue domestic economic development. That results in higher wages, a larger economy and is the basis of all other power.
 

Michaelsinodef

Senior Member
Registered Member
8000 yuan is a lot for an average Chinese
It's not lmao.

A service job (not needing college) in some tier 3 city is already like 3k, while for tier 1 is like 6-7k a month.

In other words, far less than 1 year of work (in comparison to US universities loans/costs, which isn't gonna be paid off in years for the vast majority lol, especially if they take a student loan).
 

doggydogdo

Junior Member
Registered Member
It's not lmao.

A service job (not needing college) in some tier 3 city is already like 3k, while for tier 1 is like 6-7k a month.

In other words, far less than 1 year of work (in comparison to US universities loans/costs, which isn't gonna be paid off in years for the vast majority lol, especially if they take a student loan).
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

Average Chinese income was 33,036 yuan last year. 8000 yuan would be a 1/4 the average Chinese income.
 

supercat

Major
Goldman is extremely hated by those who want to conceal the facts and pretend the opposite is true. Basically most of the mainstream media, political class, and internet peanut gallery.
Yes, few US pundits would say something like this:
Every American policy shop signed on to tech war against China, and virtually all of them bought into the China's-going-to-collapse fairy tale. The tech war flopped, as I predicted it would, and China's manufacturing grew fast enough to more than compensate for the property bust, as China shifted exports to the Global South. They don't want acknowledge the facts, because the facts make them look silly.

Here is his take on China's surging export to the Global South, which renders the US regime's "decoupling" pointless.

2 words explain China export ‘surge’: Global South​

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
 
Top