China's strategy in Afghanistan.

Arnies

Junior Member
Registered Member
Seeing as how Trump was all about Murica and getting people out of "shithole countries" you'd be completely wrong about that.

Trump was a reaction to White people being demographically replaced by non-Whites. It's too late though. America is already only 58% White and will likely be minority White in less than 15 years.

Just wait for it Trump and his gang will be back stronger than ever tho not in 2025 but in 2029 and not Trump as their leader but they will find a new leader and 100 times more fanatical than trump and they could carry out violence across the US sometime around the early 2030s
 

Mohsin77

Senior Member
Registered Member
This basic commerce and an economy is what was just starting to emerge in Afghanistan and would have given the country hope.

"Commerce"... ?

Here's a ball-park estimate of that "commerce": 90% of US Dollars were pumped to US contractors, who pumped 20% to local warlords, who pumped 10% of that to the Taliban. Keep in mind that the money your pet-warlords didn't forward directly to the Taliban (for their own protection) was mostly put in their own pockets, while they extorted the local population and raped their kids, while investing in opium fields which feed America's own heroin addiction. That was the 'emerging economy' of Afghanistan, all funded by the US taxpayer.

But that hope is dead.

Drink some more Kool Aid. You'll be fine.
 

FireyCross

New Member
Registered Member
I think it's safe to say that the US/NATO occupation in Afghanistan was a completely squandered opportunity in terms of nation-building. Afghanistan's economy is still one the least developed in the world. You'd have to have a *very*.... unique... view of economic development to get a positive spin on the last 20 years. Even most western analysts admit that whoever "inherits" Afghanistan is basically going to be starting from scratch.

China has a window of opportunity right now. The west is out of the picture, and the Taliban are desperate for both legitimacy and access to international financial and trade systems. China can offer both aid, trade and access to financial systems in return for the Taliban's co-operation in preventing cross-border terrorism and drugs smuggling. The Taliban might be many things, but they aren't stupid and have shown themselves to be open to making deals. China's willingness to not seek to impose a specific ideology or political model but merely to reach a basic agreement gives them a significant upper hand over western powers who are being a tad optimistic in the number of strings they can attach to "recognition".

Potentially, Afghnistan could, in the longer term, be a strategic asset for China, giving her an alternative overland route through the Pamirs to Pakistan and Iran should the karakorum highway be damaged - the tax revenue from which the Taliban is unlikely to turn their nose up at.
 

FireyCross

New Member
Registered Member
What exactly had you so creeped out?
The degree of fear in the place. There was a very dystopian edge to it, that anything other than total conformity was just waiting for trouble to fall on you. It's the worlds biggest official "no fun zone". Music? Nope. Style/fashion? Nope. Take a boat out diving, or explore heritage sites in the desert? Hope you've got a shit ton of police permissions *and* that the cops are in a good mood, and the stars are correctly aligned, cos otherwise you're grounded. Until the last year or so, solo women weren't even allowed into the country, least we taint the place with sin or something stupid.

In Iran, you can, ya know... just get on a train. No biggie. Everything in Saudi Arabia was such a frikkin "big deal" and drama. Every move you make is suspicious or dangerous. Everything you do has to be scrutinised, stamped, approved, and "allowed". When they say Iran is a "prison" for women it's 90% hyperbole and bullshit and 10% exaggerated kernel of truth, but Saudi Arabia really feels like that, even as a westerner only there for a few months. God knows how it feels to be born there :( I wouldn't know, because it's pretty much impossible to have any meaningful friendships or contacts with the locals, because they're too bloody scared to share anything.

It's ironic how westerners are disturbed or disgusted about the social credit system in China, yet are totally A-OK with Saudi Arabia doing basically the same thing, but with lower tech, and instead of being blocked from booking comfy seats on the train (the brutish commies!), you get tied up in public, and flogged until you're half-dead instead (good law and order policing!). Iran also has corporal punishment, but nothing like the enthusiastic dedication to it that the Saudis have, and nothing like the creepily over-extended surveillence state of crazed religious nuts spying on every tiny little thing every single person does 24/7. You'd have to do something fairly blatant and in-the-face of the govt in Iran to seriously piss them off (I used common sense, but was never especially cautious, and never reached the line). In Saudi Arabia, trying to buy a can of drink at the wrong time of day is enough excuse for a good kicking (for reals - I actually saw this happen to some poor sod).
 

Gatekeeper

Brigadier
Registered Member
The degree of fear in the place. There was a very dystopian edge to it, that anything other than total conformity was just waiting for trouble to fall on you. It's the worlds biggest official "no fun zone". Music? Nope. Style/fashion? Nope. Take a boat out diving, or explore heritage sites in the desert? Hope you've got a shit ton of police permissions *and* that the cops are in a good mood, and the stars are correctly aligned, cos otherwise you're grounded. Until the last year or so, solo women weren't even allowed into the country, least we taint the place with sin or something stupid.

In Iran, you can, ya know... just get on a train. No biggie. Everything in Saudi Arabia was such a frikkin "big deal" and drama. Every move you make is suspicious or dangerous. Everything you do has to be scrutinised, stamped, approved, and "allowed". When they say Iran is a "prison" for women it's 90% hyperbole and bullshit and 10% exaggerated kernel of truth, but Saudi Arabia really feels like that, even as a westerner only there for a few months. God knows how it feels to be born there :( I wouldn't know, because it's pretty much impossible to have any meaningful friendships or contacts with the locals, because they're too bloody scared to share anything.

It's ironic how westerners are disturbed or disgusted about the social credit system in China, yet are totally A-OK with Saudi Arabia doing basically the same thing, but with lower tech, and instead of being blocked from booking comfy seats on the train (the brutish commies!), you get tied up in public, and flogged until you're half-dead instead (good law and order policing!). Iran also has corporal punishment, but nothing like the enthusiastic dedication to it that the Saudis have, and nothing like the creepily over-extended surveillence state of crazed religious nuts spying on every tiny little thing every single person does 24/7. You'd have to do something fairly blatant and in-the-face of the govt in Iran to seriously piss them off (I used common sense, but was never especially cautious, and never reached the line). In Saudi Arabia, trying to buy a can of drink at the wrong time of day is enough excuse for a good kicking (for reals - I actually saw this happen to some poor sod).

This is it. You got it spot on. But they do some here still feel it's the other way around? MSM that's what.

Don't forget, the Saudis are our biggest buyer of........ arms! Also we keep them proped up because they control OPEC on our behalf. So the MSM propaganda often played down Saudis less than "civilised" behaviours.

They have religious police, yet we criticise the Taliban but kept stump about Saudis. Women not allowed to drive, go out without somebody of the same family in tow.

They literally get away with murder. (The case of the recent killing of one of its citizens) and what do we do? Nothing. Trump even said, they are our friends and ally.

Back even I was a boy, I remember the killing of the princess. And what do Our governments do. Nothing.

And now they are bombing the sxxt out of Yemen. Again nothing said.

So much for being a liberal paradise on earth.
 

Arnies

Junior Member
Registered Member
The degree of fear in the place. There was a very dystopian edge to it, that anything other than total conformity was just waiting for trouble to fall on you. It's the worlds biggest official "no fun zone". Music? Nope. Style/fashion? Nope. Take a boat out diving, or explore heritage sites in the desert? Hope you've got a shit ton of police permissions *and* that the cops are in a good mood, and the stars are correctly aligned, cos otherwise you're grounded. Until the last year or so, solo women weren't even allowed into the country, least we taint the place with sin or something stupid.

In Iran, you can, ya know... just get on a train. No biggie. Everything in Saudi Arabia was such a frikkin "big deal" and drama. Every move you make is suspicious or dangerous. Everything you do has to be scrutinised, stamped, approved, and "allowed". When they say Iran is a "prison" for women it's 90% hyperbole and bullshit and 10% exaggerated kernel of truth, but Saudi Arabia really feels like that, even as a westerner only there for a few months. God knows how it feels to be born there :( I wouldn't know, because it's pretty much impossible to have any meaningful friendships or contacts with the locals, because they're too bloody scared to share anything.

It's ironic how westerners are disturbed or disgusted about the social credit system in China, yet are totally A-OK with Saudi Arabia doing basically the same thing, but with lower tech, and instead of being blocked from booking comfy seats on the train (the brutish commies!), you get tied up in public, and flogged until you're half-dead instead (good law and order policing!). Iran also has corporal punishment, but nothing like the enthusiastic dedication to it that the Saudis have, and nothing like the creepily over-extended surveillence state of crazed religious nuts spying on every tiny little thing every single person does 24/7. You'd have to do something fairly blatant and in-the-face of the govt in Iran to seriously piss them off (I used common sense, but was never especially cautious, and never reached the line). In Saudi Arabia, trying to buy a can of drink at the wrong time of day is enough excuse for a good kicking (for reals - I actually saw this happen to some poor sod).

This is nothing more than personal paranoia.. Sorry for saying this but it feels like it is taken from a low-budget sci-fi movie and I swear Saudi Arabia is the opposite of what you said.. Obviously there are laws in each country but definitely you described scenes from resident evil part 5 and Honestly detached from reality.. Iran is politically unsafe as tourist destination nobody goes there and that is ground reality.. Approx 20m go in and out of KSA each year pre-covid they are used to this life of having overcrowding tourists.

Here you have solo women travellers in Saudi Arabia




The problem is there is hyperbolic fiction and ground reality.. Why are 300k westerners living in Saudi arabia if they are in danger? The reality is they are not in fact more westerners living in the gulf than anywhere else in the world. I have meet dozens of westerners telling me that there is more street safety in the Gulf general than anywhere else in the world which is true crime is almost a myth because they take it serious and counter it effectively thieves have sort of given up on their careers. There is street and harmony unlike anywhere else in the world
 
Last edited:

Gatekeeper

Brigadier
Registered Member
This is nothing more than personal paranoia.. Sorry for saying this but it feels like it is taken from a low-budget sci-fi movie and I swear Saudi Arabia is the opposite of what you said.

Oh dear. I'm not sure you realised what you just said there. You're pouring scorn over someone's own personal experiences. Tut tut. The contempt and disrespect you showed is on par with the former POTUS.
 

Arnies

Junior Member
Registered Member
As awhole the Chinese should attempt to balance their policies and friends in the region because one signal of unforeseen move could land someone in trouble around this region example like being over cosy with one entity could create many enemies without you never doing them any harm directly but someone could be labelled in that axis automatically and you don't wanna be framed into an axis or become exclusive with someone.. Example suspicion of China tilt towards Iran could force overnight 25-30 KSA allied countries to exit the neutrality stance in the US-china game and join the US camp against China. They have neutral stance in the US-China beef but such things will make them tilt towards the west officially joining the Huawei ban and other chinese trade bans and trade blockades
 

Arnies

Junior Member
Registered Member
Potentially, Afghnistan could, in the longer term, be a strategic asset for China, giving her an alternative overland route through the Pamirs to Pakistan and Iran should the karakorum highway be damaged - the tax revenue from which the Taliban is unlikely to turn their nose up at.

Technically IEA's plan is to develop the country and advance it technologically. Getting these Lithum out of the ground is the first goal and plan to be executed and to create a market of lithum and even use the lithum for development and technological advancement and procurement of armements is also high on IEA agenda. They don't want repeat of the Americans coming back even tho it is unlikely for decades upon decades still if they were to misadventure which is unlikely but IEA doesn't wanna take gamble on it's sovereignty..
 

Arnies

Junior Member
Registered Member
Oh dear. I'm not sure you realised what you just said there. You're pouring scorn over someone's own personal experiences. Tut tut. The contempt and disrespect you showed is on par with the former POTUS.

I am calm about it
 
Top