China's SCS Strategy Thread

Hendrik_2000

Lieutenant General

plawolf

Lieutenant General
Building a nuclear reactor in the South China Sea is a dangerous undertaking, and most countries in South-East Asia will be unhappy. Enough said about serious problems at Fukushima & Chernobyl melt downs. I believe that most countries are wary about the building of nuclear reactors, regardless of claims of safety & expertise of the builder of whatever country it maybe.

You do understand that a ship based nuclear reactor can go anywhere it likes and isn’t rooted in place right? That is the whole point - rather than trying to make a weather proof nuclear reactor, China will simply sail said reactor out of the way of any storms that might threaten it. Being ship based would also make it immune to earthquakes and tsunamis. That pretty much covers all natural threats to nuclear reactors.

As others have pointed out already, countries sail nuclear powered carriers and subs in the SCS all the time, if those countries had no problems before, they have no reasonable groups to have a problem now.

Countries in SE Asia has precisely as much say about China building a ship based floating nuclear reactor as they do about China/America/Russia/Britain/France etc building nuclear powered subs and ships.

Similarly, they have precisely as much say about China sailing said floating nuclear reactor into the SCS as they have aboutChina/America/Russia/Britain/France etc sailing nuclear subs and carriers into the SCS.

If they want to restrict access of the floating Chinese reactor, then they need to get on China’s side on freedom of navigation vs rights of coastal states.
 

Rettam Stacf

Junior Member
Registered Member
You do understand that a ship based nuclear reactor can go anywhere it likes and isn’t rooted in place right? That is the whole point - rather than trying to make a weather proof nuclear reactor, China will simply sail said reactor out of the way of any storms that might threaten it. Being ship based would also make it immune to earthquakes and tsunamis. That pretty much covers all natural threats to nuclear reactors.

As others have pointed out already, countries sail nuclear powered carriers and subs in the SCS all the time, if those countries had no problems before, they have no reasonable groups to have a problem now.

Countries in SE Asia has precisely as much say about China building a ship based floating nuclear reactor as they do about China/America/Russia/Britain/France etc building nuclear powered subs and ships.

Similarly, they have precisely as much say about China sailing said floating nuclear reactor into the SCS as they have aboutChina/America/Russia/Britain/France etc sailing nuclear subs and carriers into the SCS.

If they want to restrict access of the floating Chinese reactor, then they need to get on China’s side on freedom of navigation vs rights of coastal states.

Very good point, Wolf.

Coastal states of South China Sea should jointly declare it a nuclear free zone and no ship powered by nuclear reactors or carry nuclear weapons be allowed to sail into South China Sea.
 

pendragon

Junior Member
Re: What military options available now in Spratly Islands.

IMO, an aircraft carrier is needed in order to secure china' s interest. China could tow varyag to park beside the Spratly Island and use it as a airport?
Any carrier can sink! An airfield can not; moreover you can scatter planes and equipment over a superior surface on an island rendering total destruction much harder.
 

pendragon

Junior Member
Any carrier can sink! An airfield can not; moreover you can scatter planes and equipment over a superior surface on an island rendering total destruction much harder.
having (a) carrier(s) sail between island airbases is to introduce a new invariable into the prospect towards the possible ennemy; china is following the teachings of its ancient martial master!
 

pendragon

Junior Member
has anyone any reports on how china'srecent actions in the scs has affected the acts of international naval piracy in the region?
 
Top