2022 Olympic Winter Games Beijing

Tyler

Captain
Registered Member
No, China absolutely does not allow dual citizenship. If you're born in the US or other foreign countries and if either of your parents is Chinese citizen, you will still have a chance to decide whether you want to be Chinese citizen when you become an adult (don't remember the exact age, probably 21). For special talent, which Eileen Gu apparently is, you can apply to be a Chinese citizen even when you're an adult. Some non-Chinese athletes have chosen this route. Not sure which route Eileen Gu did. Her case is not unique. There have been precedents.
A couple of naturalized Brazilians have played for China's national soccer team.
 

OppositeDay

Senior Member
Registered Member
China does not recognize dual citizenship, and by law a Chinese citizen who acquires citizenship of another country loses her Chinese citizenship. However, it is possible for someone with a foreign citizenship by birth to be a Chinese citizen. Such a person are not recognized by Chinese law to have foreign citizenship, but the foreign country in question could recognize her as its citizen. It's entirely possible for Gu to be a Chinese citizen under Chinese law but American citizen under American law.
 

weig2000

Captain
I think you guys are both right lol.

The issue is dual citizenship. That is, holding citizenships from two countries at the same time. There is only person that is right here, and that is me. Because it is the Chinese law: no dual citizenship.

I want to make it absolutely clear. There should be no muddy water here. By the way, I have long advocated that China should allow dual citizenship, or at least in the model of NRI (Non-Resident Indian). The current no-dual-citizenship law is too rigid and no longer in China's best interest. An interesting but separate topic.
 

weig2000

Captain
It's entirely possible for Gu to be a Chinese citizen under Chinese law but American citizen under American law.

Not possible at all, at least not legally. The US does not care if you're a foreign citizenship or not at the same time while you're a US citizen. China does care, strictly. For example, the Nobel physics laureate CN Yang (杨振宁) had to renounce his American citizen first before restoring his Chinese citizenship. Personally, I think China can follow the US's model, but it doesn't currently.
 

OppositeDay

Senior Member
Registered Member
Not possible at all, at least not legally. The US does not care if you're a foreign citizenship or not at the same time while you're a US citizen. China does care, strictly. For example, the Nobel physics laureate CN Yang (杨振宁) had to renounce his American citizen first before restoring his Chinese citizenship. Personally, I think China can follow the US's model, but it doesn't currently.

Yang was a naturalized American citizen. He lost his Chinese citizenship at the time of his naturalization. He then had to renounce his American citizenship to reacquire Chinese citizenship.

Assuming one of Gu's parents was a Chinese citizen at the time of her birth, then she always has been a Chinese citizen. She didn't have to acquire Chinese citizenship, which would have required her to renounce her American citizenship. According to Chinese law, she has always been a Chinese citizen and never an American citizen.
 

weig2000

Captain
Yang was a naturalized American citizen. He lost his Chinese citizenship at the time of his naturalization. He then had to renounce his American citizenship to reacquire Chinese citizenship.

Assuming one of Gu's parents was a Chinese citizen at the time of her birth, then she always has been a Chinese citizen. She didn't have to acquire Chinese citizenship, which would have required her to renounce her American citizenship. According to Chinese law, she has always been a Chinese citizen and never an American citizen.

As I said above, if someone was born in a foreign country and hence automatically acquired foreign citizenship like in the US, she/he has a chance when becoming an adult (21?) to select to become a Chinese citizen on her/his own will. This is assuming, of course, at least one parent was a Chinese citizen.

Now, back to the core issue discussed here: whether she can be a dual citizen at this point. The answer is an absolute No. In both theory (law) and practice. Again I'm talking about legally which we should assume that's the case for a celebrity like her now. Just in case that you or someone still thinks there is a distinctive possibility or grey area that China in this case would pretend she would have renounced her US citizenship (benign negligence) and doesn't care, like the US practice effectively. The answer is still No. China strictly enforces this law. Heck, they even strictly enforce some policy on permanent resident or green card holders (like you have to give up your Hukou or something like that).

To be sure, there are Chinese citizens that effective violate the citizenship law by holding foreign passports without acknowledging it publicly or to the government. This is illegal and there have been crackdowns. In Eilleen Gu's case, I doubt that's the case. It's such a high-profile case and they will make sure she would provide the proof that she has renounced American citizenship first.

There is a similar case before about a guy from UK, he is called 华天. He participated in Equestrian representing China in 2008 Beijing Olympics.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
 

Bellum_Romanum

Brigadier
Registered Member
Anyone here know the cost for the Beijing Winter Olympics so far? Or the projected cost vs the actual cost? Tokyo Olympics was beyond costly..

 
Top