2025 Israel - Iranian conflict

neutralobserver

Junior Member
Registered Member
But they haven't so far, not in a huge significant anyway. Maybe that will change in the future if relations sour. But at least for now Pakistan held onto their word for most part. Trust and reliance is actually quite a rare commodity right now.

Iran on the other hand can promise everything but its worthless if they cannot effectively enforce it even if they had the best intentions.
Pakistan-China relations dates back to 1960's, so that is a special relationship that has been built over decades. Not easy to replicate with other countries.
 

FairAndUnbiased

Brigadier
Registered Member
You are comparing insurgencies fought on the ground vs a formal conventional war utilising primarily missile stockpiles? Sorry but this seems like absolutely poor logic.

The Afghans, Vietnamese, Iraqis were successful because they had more than enough men willing to sacrifice their lives to drain the energy out of occupying western armies, however this dynamic does not apply to a war of attrition based on missile exchanges, the west can outproduce them, and outgun them. It will not be an insurgency reliant on men willing to die.

The Iranians have a roughly ~2000 missile stockpile, with capacity to produce ~50 a month. This won't last. And they're already being rendered useless by constant bombardment at the storage sites.
Vietnamese shot down 10k US planes in a conventional war. They also fought conventional battles like Battle of Khe Sanh, an army Corp level conventional maneuver with tanks, artillery and air power on both sides. During Operation Linebacker and Linebacker 2, the US lost dozens of literally irreplaceable B-52s in air to air combat.

US also never occupied North Vietnam. In fact they couldn't even invade it. It wasn't for a lack of trying either, as they lost the border battle at Khe Sanh and lost their rematch at Dewey Canyon. They were in South Vietnam as a nominal ally but mostly killed Southern civilians.

Imagine if Russia couldn't invade Ukraine at all because it was defeated at a hypothetical Battle of Southern Kherson, got the entire Russian Air Force shot down, and they took out their anger by shooting a bunch of people in Crimea and Donetsk before Ukrainian Leopards blasted through Sevastopol and the Russian black sea commanders fled by clinging to helicopters.
 

tamsen_ikard

Senior Member
Registered Member
Man seeing a country like Israel wreaking havoc in the middle east with no one stopping them is scary.
Consequences of a unipolar world
Muslims need these kinds of slaps to start removing their divisions and start uniting against the common threat that is Israel and its western backers. If all the muslims in the middle east get their act together, 350 million of them will overwhelm Israel in a week. Iran and Turkey are actually quite good in this. They have the industrial capacity, education and good leadership to develop strong military capabilities. Gulf Arabs are ofcource completely hopeless but all these Israeli attacks could give them the shock to start allying more with Iran and Turkey rather than consider them enemies.

I think in the long term Israel will be destroyed and Israelis will be forced to flee to Europe and US. But it will be a long process. US spending its energy to save Israel is the energy it cannot use against China, Russia and rest of the world. So, its a good thing for the rest of the world as well.
 

Randomuser

Captain
Registered Member
Man seeing a country like Israel wreaking havoc in the middle east with no one stopping them is scary.
Consequences of a unipolar world
They have US backing for one.

But another thing that might offend some middle eastern posters here is unfortunately, most countries in the middle east are like level 10 and Israel is level 50 in terms of competency. These guys literally teamed up against Israel in the past and got all their planes blown up in a few days. Its basically a pro guy farming the noob servers. Iran was supposed to be different coz they are Persians or whatever but right now sadly that may not be the case.
 

AndrewJ

Junior Member
Registered Member
Chief of Staff - dead
Head of IRGC - dead
Head of IRGC-ASF - dead

How they heck were they able to locate and target all these high profile people? There were so many hints of attacks, they should have moved top leadership to secure locations...

Turns out any "secure" locations in Iran are not secure actually... :rolleyes:

Look on the bright side, maybe Israel accidentally killed a bunch of Iranian traitors with their strikes....

The real rats will never get striked. :(
 
Last edited:

manqiangrexue

Brigadier
Muslims need these kinds of slaps to start removing their divisions and start uniting against the common threat that is Israel and its western backers. If all the muslims in the middle east get their act together, 350 million of them will overwhelm Israel in a week. Iran and Turkey are actually quite good in this. They have the industrial capacity, education and good leadership to develop strong military capabilities. Gulf Arabs are ofcource completely hopeless but all these Israeli attacks could give them the shock to start allying more with Iran and Turkey rather than consider them enemies.
Verrry very optimistic view of what they can do seeing what they are currently doing.
I think in the long term Israel will be destroyed and Israelis will be forced to flee to Europe and US. But it will be a long process.
I think.... yeah I think that'd be even more satisfying than retaking Taiwan right now. But realistically for that to happen, China would be the main force in global power shift and we would have to muzzle and leash the West in a new Pax Sinica. Muslims alone cannot do it.
 

tamsen_ikard

Senior Member
Registered Member
Verrry very optimistic view of what they can do seeing what they are currently doing.

I think.... yeah I think that'd be even more satisfying than retaking Taiwan right now. But realistically for that to happen, China would be the main force in global power shift and we would have to muzzle and leash the West in a new Pax Sinica. Muslims alone cannot do it.
China was doing far worse in the 1920-30s. Muslims also had quite a dominating presence against europe under the early ottoman empire. So, its not like Muslims have never been strong.

If we look at the big picture for the last several centuries. Muslim lands in the middle east was united under one Ottoman empire for a long time. Only this last century did it break up into pieces and gotten weak in the process. The geography and culture there is suitable for another reconsolidation into a more united state but it will take some time for it to happen. Middle East is now going through its own century of humiliation but that could be the catalyst that creates the right mindset and leadership to get more united and focused on development. Essentially this is modernisation by foreign humiliation
 
Top