Here we are once more. It's time for my mental dump from today (don't complain about the smell, please) of the events of today in, about and around Ukraine. This is my opinion and worth as much as you paid for it. We are here at the end of day 4.
1. On the ground, the Russians are still winning. They appear to be moving forward with attempting to create a kessel for the eastern Ukrainian forces. However, how much progress they have made to do so is, IMO, tbd. We don't see a lot of reports on the ground from those areas where the maps show them, except for the one russian tank found abandoned near-ish Poltava.
2. The Russians yoloed into Kharkov. They appear to have been beaten back. Fighting in Kharkov continues. As a recon-in-force, I can accept, but...it just felt weird. The nearest equivalent was the so-called Thunder Run the US Army did in Baghdad, but the Americans used M-1 tanks and M-2 bradleys to do it rather than TIGRs and other armored trucks.
3. Mariupol is surrounded. Kiev may be (probably is) surrounded. Klitschko might have been knocked in the head too many times and either said the quiet thing out loud. Or he might have said the wrong thing and been wrong. Or whatever. if the Russians haven't surrounded Kiev, I'd be surprised.
4. The battle for Bucha seems like it was the armoured thrust forward we have been expecting into Kiev and yet, it seems (stress seems) to have been beaten back.
5. Near Kherson, the Russians are starting to use the artillery we've been expecting. The grandchildren of Stalin's pipe organs have started playing the song we all expected from the start.
6. The Russians have deployed between 2/3s to 3/4s of their forces they moved up in preparation for the war. 1/4 to 1/3 are still in reserve. I have to ask if anyone has been watching to see if the Russians are moving more in? Or if there are just supply trains coming? or...?
7. The Iskandrs were touted as terrifying weapons and until the night before and today, they seemed to not do as much damage as their reputation would have implied. Or maybe I am wrong. I've been rather underwhelmed by their effectiveness.
8. Gotta say it...but where the fsck is the RuAF? I mean, Turkish made drones are still striking and whacking Russian ground troops. These are not Anjian or F-35s, they ought to have been swept from the skies. The primary kills of Ukrainian Su-25s have been SAMs, not fighters. Writing that feels weird. The vaunted Russian Air Force can't sweep from the skies a 3rd or 4th rate air force. I...I...where's that milk carton meme again?
9. Logistical problems seem to continue. Equipment is being found, often operational, and taken by Ukrainians. Most of the time by the Ukrainian Army, sometimes by farmers with tractors or even just driven away.
10. The Russians are asking for the Belarusians to join them in their war. That's...kinda astounding when I stop and think about it. Why are they relying on Belarus for troops? The Russians asked the Khazaks and were also declined. This is just...odd. Are the Russians just not able to take Ukraine on their own?
11. Russian operations except by the VDV and Spetznaz has been awfully. The bunching up of convoys, bumper to bumper is a great example. If the Ukrainains had more drones or Su-25, the Russian armour would have been buzzsawed.
12. To the Ukrainian side here. They're still here. They're still in play. That means their air force (!!!) and army. They are losing, but they are meat grinding the Russians far and away better than I could have ever expected. I had thought this was the mouse flipping off the hawk - at best - but instead it has been still far more effective than I could have ever expected. I like Ukrainians. Now I've started to grow to admire them.
13. That said though, they have been caught propagandizing things (and outright lying) a few times now. Whether its the Ghost of Kiev or the killing of Chechen leaders or Snake Island, they have been noted to bend, warp and make the truth dance a mighty fine gig.
14. Where the Ukrainians are absolutely winning is on the international stage. They now have a supply line set up from NATO. They have even fighter planes coming in from Europe. Enough to replenish their operational mig-29s 2x over. They're going to have more ATGMs than the Russians have tanks in theater at this rate. Ammo and fuel, etc. coming in. Then on top of that, there is the sanctions the West has implemented and are going to at least during this war hammer the Russians. Perhaps not in the long run, but in the medium to short. Well played, President Zelinskyy. Well played.
I still only give Ukrainians a 6% to 7% chance of winning, but that's increasing faster than I would have said earlier.
The Russians are winning. The Ukrainians are losing.
But the Russians are making a dog's breakfast of their wins and the Ukrainians seem to be making a confection of the shbt sandwich they have.
I expected Kharkov to fall today. It did not. I expected the Russians to push into Kiev. They did not.
Clearly, my expectations are off. Then again, Ukrainian farmers are dragging off APCs and MRAPs with tractors.
This war is so weird in so many ways.