Get out of here with this holier than thou bullshit nonsense. This website is filled with speculation on events and isn't some great brain trust regarding international relations.
Yeah, we elect morons yet somehow managed build one of the wealthiest and most prosperous countries on the planet and we've managed to build and maintain that wealth for generations?
Oh, and American and Canadian relationships were built over shared core values and mutual defense along with being sustained for in a peaceful manner for decades. On top of that, the relationship has survived through many geopolitical changes and has proven itself to be durable.
Acting like it was forgone conclusion that it would end up in this manner is totally false or that the actions of Trump were somehow predicted by past American administrators despite the fact that everything he does is almost entirely unprecedented.
You lost me at "
MUH SHARED VALUES”—as if lofty ideals, not cold
necessity and geopolitical reality, drove then-P.M. Mackenzie-King’s government to cave to U.S. President FDR’s strategic maneuvering. Let’s not rewrite history: the 1940
Ogdensburg Agreement wasn’t some kumbaya moment. It was a survival play, forced by a world on fire, where Canada traded pretense of autonomy for American protection.
But sure, keep bleating about
“shared values” while ignoring the raw calculus that
actually binds nations.
The agreement resulted into the following:
- Establishment of the Permanent Joint Board on Defense (PJBD)
- Created a joint military committee with officials from both countries
- Tasked with coordinating defense plans and policies for North America
- Continues to exist today as an advisory body on North American defense issues
- Enhanced Canada-U.S. Relations
- Strengthened bilateral ties, especially in defense cooperation
- Established a framework for coordinated defense planning
- Reflected a commitment to shared security in North America
- Strategic Positioning
- Served as a preemptive defense measure against potential Axis threats
- Focused on defending the "north half of the Western Hemisphere"
- Aligned with UN Charter obligations for maintaining international peace and security
- Economic and Political Implications
- Laid groundwork for future economic collaboration (e.g., Hyde Park Declaration of 1941)
- Addressed sovereignty concerns while aiming to maintain Canada's autonomy
- Represented a shift in Canadian foreign policy, balancing U.S. and British relations
While the decision enjoyed broad support among Canadians, there were *notable exceptions*—including a certain former Conservative P.M. (whose name I can’t be bothered to Google)—who argued it would erode Canada’s "SOVEREIGNTY."
The chaos of Nazi Germany’s blitzkrieg, which crushed France—a preeminent European power—in mere weeks, forced leaders of the era to confront reality. They prioritized national defense and pragmatically aligned with the rising superpower: the U.S., then as now.
What began as Lloyd Mackenzie-King’s vision—positioning Canada as a sovereign “middle power” bridging Britain and the U.S.—degenerated into a lopsided bargain. Instead of autonomy, it birthed a vassal-state dynamic that you, and many others, now grudgingly acknowledge.
If this resistance is such a noble cause, such a war to wage, then by all means, send—or don't—your absent soldiers to fight, along with the
Eurocucks. But until then, Canada needs a policy that recognizes the new
world order and that its quasi-fake relationship and parasitic nature off the U.S. security-economic-diplomatic umbrella is never to be the same. Canada needs a policy that operates in the
world today, not in the fabricated international society from which it hopes to forever hold onto.
But it seems to me that still, far too many Canadians see this as a TRUMP ISSUE—not an AMERICAN ISSUE or a GEOPOLITICAL DISASTER that requires an ENTIRE CHANGE.
Don't come crying to me if your great solution for avoiding such calamitous threats is a wait-and-see approach hoping the Democrats vote in your favor. Open your eyes. Stop the charade. Get with it.