The War in the Ukraine

Hyper

Junior Member
Registered Member
IMO, the only way acceptable for Putin is to pardon all Wagner soldiers in the mutiny who were only acting under order. Any officier including Prigozhin must be put on trial openly.

Even though Wagner is a commercial company working with the government, in times of war the government has absolute dictation including forfeit any contract obligations. That means Wagner is no different from regular citizen or soldiers in the rugular army. Any act of disobidience of Wagner is NOT a disbute of contract terms but treason. The only thing that Wagner could have done when dispute with the army arised was to disband itself and stop fullfilling the contract as they claimes that the army has broken it. And even so the army still have the legal upper hand because of the mobolisation.

This means that it is Russian state's authority and legitimacy being openly challenged by a rouge soldier. There is no way Russian government would let it go other ways even if the war on Ukraine is at risk. Otherwise the Russian state's authority is finished, there will be more such actions from various sectors including regular Russian army and civilian refusing to serve the war.
Only governments are supposed to have a monopoly on violence. Putin just negotiated with a terrorist. Very bad optics.
 

taxiya

Brigadier
Registered Member
Exile to Belarus I guess. More details to come when article is updated.


Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
That is very linient of Russian government. I was thinking Prigozhin "fled Russia" (self exile) while Russia keeps the criminal charge, so to maintain a formal cover for legal principle.

On the other hand, this whole thing is so bizzare. Either Prigozhin is an idiot or there is a huge trick hidden. I think he is just idiotic though.
 

Antey1

Just Hatched
Registered Member
Ok guys, prigo saga is over. I personally think he is a russian patriot, he wanted Shoigu and Germasimov out. I think that will be part of the deal with the MoD. it's a win win for russia at the end of the day.

Anyways, ukraine tried again to go through russian defenses in the Zaporizhzhia front, it didnt go well... at all.

more pics here

 

Attachments

  • Fza-FzKWAAEeBi8.jpg
    Fza-FzKWAAEeBi8.jpg
    245.6 KB · Views: 42
  • Fza-Hv7WIAINUfK (1).jpg
    Fza-Hv7WIAINUfK (1).jpg
    227.7 KB · Views: 40
  • Fza-HcvWcAEnDfW.jpg
    Fza-HcvWcAEnDfW.jpg
    216.9 KB · Views: 37
  • Fza-G05XwAM1RJU.jpg
    Fza-G05XwAM1RJU.jpg
    266 KB · Views: 37
  • Fza-GTjWIAMW9Mo.jpg
    Fza-GTjWIAMW9Mo.jpg
    270.9 KB · Views: 38
  • Fza-FzKWAAEeBi8.jpg
    Fza-FzKWAAEeBi8.jpg
    245.6 KB · Views: 40

solarz

Brigadier
Well if this isn't a case of whiplash.

Declaring that the head of the most competent Russian military detachment committed treason, then in less than a day a deal is negotiated where people who had taken years to curry favor with Putin just resign and Prigozhin decides to exile himself. Plus immediate repair work done on all those infrastructures you tore up to delay the rebel's advance.

All this has really accomplished is show that Russia's as comical as it is incompetent.

If what you say is true, and I'm only saying if, then Putin just got rid of two less than competent military commanders (Shoigu and Gerasimov) while integrating a proven capable mercenary army into the Russian Armed Forces.

Sounds like killing two birds with one stone to me.

No chess. Wagner pissed themselves and surrendered.

Ok guys, prigo saga is over. I personally think he is a russian patriot, he wanted Shoigu and Germasimov out. I think that will be part of the deal with the MoD. it's a win win for russia at the end of the day.

The whole affair was over in less than 24 hours. Prigozhin only had the loyalty of Wagner foot soldiers. He couldn't command the air force, the artillery, or even the supply chain. If it came to a shooting war, the best they could accomplish was to destabilize Russia's war efforts in Ukraine, but the outcome for them would have been the same: utter annihilation.

The only scenario that makes sense is something pissed Wagner off, and it might even be true that they were attacked by Russian forces, and they decided to gather en mass and march to Moscow as a sign of protest without thinking through the ramifications of their actions. Russian authorities understandably freaked out and took defensive measures, but then the leaders on either side came to their senses and negotiated a deal that was in the best interests of everyone involved.
 
Last edited:

siegecrossbow

General
Staff member
Super Moderator
Ok guys, prigo saga is over. I personally think he is a russian patriot, he wanted Shoigu and Germasimov out. I think that will be part of the deal with the MoD. it's a win win for russia at the end of the day.

Anyways, ukraine tried again to go through russian defenses in the Zaporizhzhia front, it didnt go well... at all.

more pics here


I think that the Ukrainians are better suited to using Soviet origin weapons. You can’t familiarize with new weapons to the same extent you have with something that you’ve trained with for decades.
 

FairAndUnbiased

Brigadier
Registered Member
I think that the Ukrainians are better suited to using Soviet origin weapons. You can’t familiarize with new weapons to the same extent you have with something that you’ve trained with for decades.
this is why when people talk about how amazing India or Taiwan are, its best to remember: you can't buy or be gifted greatness. its earned. being bought or gifted equipment only works against those who are on the same level, it doesn't work for those who make their own equipment because at minimum at least those who make their own equipment understand why its made that way and the doctrinal usages, while those who buy only know the paper specs.
 

Tam

Brigadier
Registered Member
Aside from the outcome of this Wagner mutiny, we also need to think about what happened prior to that. Was the unhinged Prigozhin tweets true? If he was telling the truth that his headquarter got bombed for no reason, maybe he has good reason to act desperately. Otherwise, if he was lying this entire time, then he was lying from the start, and possibly planned this eventual outcome from the start. What would that imply? Honestly the more I think about it the more I just do not understand. Unlike others I will not go with 5D chess puppet show by Putin. It just seems way too risky to almost have Moscow overrun just to troll the Ukrainians into attacking. It was also extremely embarrassing for everyone involved. Nevertheless, the possibility is still above zero. I keep an open mind to this, and I accept my limited knowledge. We simply just do not know, and we should stop pretending that we know what happened until further information.

You mean the so called missile strike in his camp? We have daily pictures and videos of what a real missile strike looks like from the ground and on air on both sides of the war. I wasn't comfortable thinking that was a missile or PGM strike.


Back to the front.

We are seeing lots of TOS everywhere. The production of these units have seriously ramped up. They come from the same factory that's ramping up production or is it refitting of T-80BVM tanks.


As the soon to be ex-Wagnerites, it's not necessary that they will be integrated directly into the Russian Armed Forces, but there are a whole host of DPR and LPR volunteer groups advertising in Russian Telegram channels for volunteers. Currently the most famous or notorious of these groups is the Kaskad Battalion or obtf Kaskad. They were a key point in the defense of Novodonetsk, and is responsible for tons of Lancet and sniper videos in the web.
 
Last edited:

zhangjim

Junior Member
Registered Member
That is very linient of Russian government. I was thinking Prigozhin "fled Russia" (self exile) while Russia keeps the criminal charge, so to maintain a formal cover for legal principle.

On the other hand, this whole thing is so bizzare. Either Prigozhin is an idiot or there is a huge trick hidden. I think he is just idiotic though.
I think this means that the situation has developed in a direction that everyone cannot predict.
Wake up in the morning, the mutiny ended, and both sides reached an agreement. Only VKS suffered the most severe losses.

Wagner's march towards Moscow was largely unimpeded, with only VKS taking direct action. The worst-case scenario was that the mutiny was tacitly sanctioned by the army, and they were seriously dissatisfied with the ministry of defense and VKS.

It is difficult to say what Putin's current thoughts are. Although pledging allegiance in various places is reassuring, he can see that Wagner is not the only one dissatisfied with the current situation.
 

LawLeadsToPeace

Senior Member
Staff member
Moderator - World Affairs
Registered Member
Given the fact that the Wagner - MoD fiasco is over, there is no need to write posts about this topic any more unless more groundbreaking information comes out that can influence the military operations on both sides. Any more such posts after this warning will be deleted.
 
Top