PLAN SCS Bases/Islands/Vessels (Not a Strategy Page)

antiterror13

Brigadier
Well, there's no reason why the aquaculture farm has to be onshore on those islands or in the immediate adjacent waters. Further offshore in underwater cages would address the issue of waste. One could focus on raising species that are sought after in markets and help alleviate pressures on natural stock. A processing ship could be brought in during harvest to eliminate the issue of needing to dry the fish before bringing to market.

Seaweed farming? Oyster, pearls? :)

If the wind energy level over that area is plentiful, they should start erecting wind generators to provide more sustainable electricity.

100% agree

For fish farm : Open Ocean Fish Farm :
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Apart from Wind generation, I'd like to add micro nuclear power plant for the island (25 MW nett)
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
 

joshuatree

Captain
So that dredging at Drummond sorta ties in with this.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!



China is planning to build five lighthouses in the disputed Paracel Islands in a move analysts said shows Beijing's firm stance over its claims to sovereignty in the South China Sea.

The Navigation Guarantee Centre of South China Sea said it had decided on the locations of the lighthouses in the area, which the Chinese authorities call the Xisha Islands, the China News Service reported yesterday.

The deployment of a Chinese oil rig in the region in May sparked riots in Vietnam, which also claims the islands.

The lighthouses are planned for North Reef, Antelope Reef, Drummond Island, South Sand and Pyramid Rock, small islets and reefs with part of their land surface below the waves at high tide.

Vietnam's Ministry of Foreign Affairs has strongly criticised the plans, saying it has indisputable sovereignty over the islands and that the move is illegal.

Officials spent a week surveying the area before selecting the sites that offered a safe place to berth ships, the China News Service reported. The lighthouses will improve navigation in the area, according to Chinese officials.

Many islets and reefs in the region lack detailed maps for civilian ships, according to the report.

"A lighthouse is a symbol of the country's sovereignty in the islands," said Du Jifeng, a research fellow at the Institute of Asia-Pacific Studies at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.

"But building a lighthouse in the name of aiding navigation is a move unlikely to trigger a strong backlash in Vietnam since in theory civilian ships from other countries can also benefit from its services."

The plan to build the lighthouses showed Beijing was taking a tough line over the country's territorial disputes in the South China Sea, said Shen Shishun, an expert at the China Institute of International Studies.

"The public has long been calling on the mainland government to be more assertive in the territorial row," Shen said.

"There have been complaints China turned a blind eye to Vietnam's exploration of resources in the disputed waters."

Xinhua reported last month that China was also dredging navigation channels off one island in the Paracels.
 

Geographer

Junior Member
Thanks for posting that, joshuatree. This caught my eye:
Officials spent a week surveying the area before selecting the sites that offered a safe place to berth ships, the China News Service reported.
Is China planning to create more artificial harbors? You may be right that the dredging around Drummond Island is related to the lighthouses.
 

joshuatree

Captain
Thanks for posting that, joshuatree. This caught my eye:

Is China planning to create more artificial harbors? You may be right that the dredging around Drummond Island is related to the lighthouses.

I think at the very least, they've identified sites where the natural features would permit some safe harbor for ships. I think the plan is to extend presence via the lighthouses and any civilian fishing vessels making pit stops. Basically, populate the remote areas.

Now if they are going to dredge these places, will they simply dredge to make them deeper or actually create land in addition to a deeper harbor? I would hope if they dredge, they would bring the material back to Woody Island and finish land reclamation between the runway and Rocky Island. That would make prime real estate for an air base. As the neighboring countries improve their respective air forces, I think it's a given there will eventually be a SCS ADIZ of varying degree. But the infrastructure is needed first.

005621m9w4obzufx86b4br_zps877254fb.jpg~original
 

Geographer

Junior Member
Look at the left side of the picture (the north end of the island). There's some dredging going on next to Rocky Island which is new to that photography. The deep water area is not in any of Google Earth's photos. Could China be building a mini-harbor on the north side of the island? If so, for what purpose?
 

Equation

Lieutenant General
Look at the left side of the picture (the north end of the island). There's some dredging going on next to Rocky Island which is new to that photography. The deep water area is not in any of Google Earth's photos. Could China be building a mini-harbor on the north side of the island? If so, for what purpose?

That or a reservoir for fresh water.
 

pendragon

Junior Member
That or a reservoir for fresh water.

Could even be a swimmingpool for recreation, so as to keep swimmers out of the way of the boats.

But I don't think woody's has got a military vocation, i't's close enough to Hainan to be protected by the units stationed there.
The dredging and land creation could however have been an exercise to prepare for similar/larger undertaking in the spratly's.
There an airstrip (capable of handling Y-8 class aircraft) and decent harbourfacility's (for repairs and replenishment) are desperatly needed to counter Viet presence.
 

joshuatree

Captain
Could even be a swimmingpool for recreation, so as to keep swimmers out of the way of the boats.

But I don't think woody's has got a military vocation, i't's close enough to Hainan to be protected by the units stationed there.
The dredging and land creation could however have been an exercise to prepare for similar/larger undertaking in the spratly's.
There an airstrip (capable of handling Y-8 class aircraft) and decent harbourfacility's (for repairs and replenishment) are desperatly needed to counter Viet presence.

Woody can most certainly be an important forward base. We're not talking about protection but rather power projection into the SCS. Shaving off a 300 nm roundtrip between Woody and Hainan for any fighter, patrol plane, ASW plane, patrol boat, is 300 nm more loitering time for such craft in the SCS or 300 nm more in range in the SCS.

It's also closer to the Spratlys to help reinforce any facilities down there.
 

plawolf

Lieutenant General
Woody can most certainly be an important forward base. We're not talking about protection but rather power projection into the SCS. Shaving off a 300 nm roundtrip between Woody and Hainan for any fighter, patrol plane, ASW plane, patrol boat, is 300 nm more loitering time for such craft in the SCS or 300 nm more in range in the SCS.

It's also closer to the Spratlys to help reinforce any facilities down there.

China will not based any military aircraft on Woody as it would be a needless escalation and provocation.

What China will do is build up the infrastructure so it that could deploy air power and naval forces to Woody and other developed islands at very short notice. That will serve as a deterrence against aggression or escalation from others, and if anyone is too stupid or stubborn to get the hint, China could always forward deploy military forces as a powerful counter move against any major escalating action by others.

Similar deal with a SCS AIDZ. China will not bother setting one up unless someone seriously ticks China off, like Japan has done.
 
Top