Pakistan to receive Spruance Class destroyer from the US

Gollevainen

Colonel
VIP Professional
Registered Member
well slava isent conceptionally a AAW ship, but anti-carrier boomer...and adding completely alien russian technology into so traditionally western navy...
 

crazyinsane105

Junior Member
VIP Professional
Gollevainen said:
well slava isent conceptionally a AAW ship, but anti-carrier boomer...and adding completely alien russian technology into so traditionally western navy...

Above that, even with Russia-Pakistan ties warming up, it may still be a few years before the Russians actually start to sell weapons to Pakistan. And another interesting fact is that the IN is more into Israeli air defense systems than Russian air defense systems.:coffee:
 

Gollevainen

Colonel
VIP Professional
Registered Member
well only if Israelis would have to offer something more of fleet size AAW assets rather than unit size...
But I rather doupt that Slavas comes the first on the list when Moscow starts to sell arms to Pakistan...
 

isthvan

Tailgunner
VIP Professional
Slava class cruiser are bad idea since Pak navy has no prior experience whit cruiser class ships… Basically they would face the same problems that possibly made them to drop Spruance purchase…
As for interdiction of completely different technology in traditionally western navy; they are doing that write now (F-22P whit Chinese weapons systems)…
 
Last edited:

tphuang

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
VIP Professional
Registered Member
Finn McCool said:
Agreed Isthvan. Perhaps the PN should look into procuring something like a Slava. This would be cheaper (I'm assuming that it would be cheaper because its Russian.) than a couple of OHPs, it comes with the S-300 and also SS-N-12s. Assuming that Russia gives them everything right away. Just a thought.
a Sov cost China 700 million US. I doubt a Slava would cost less than that. Don't quote listed price of Ukrina, the listed price for a sov was 425 million (it obviously cost China a lot more) So what am I saying? A slava would be too expensive. Not just the procurement cost, but also the operating costs.
 

Gollevainen

Colonel
VIP Professional
Registered Member
actually Pakistanis did operate ex-hms diadem as Babur up till 80's and briefely a county class DLG that could consider as cruiser...but your rigth, it havent operated asuw missile destroyer, so alien to all other naval doctrines outside USSR....
 

MIGleader

Banned Idiot
crazyinsane105 said:
Above that, even with Russia-Pakistan ties warming up, it may still be a few years before the Russians actually start to sell weapons to Pakistan. And another interesting fact is that the IN is more into Israeli air defense systems than Russian air defense systems.:coffee:

Even if Pakistan cant buy weapons directly from russia, do you think it could try to get some weapons from russia via retail from China?

something like the 9m38 missle would be good for pakistan. Efective but not too advanced.
 

Gollevainen

Colonel
VIP Professional
Registered Member
I think the same rules apply to russia-china arms trade as to other trade in general. You cannot sell goods bougth from another to third party wihtout its approval or facing the risk of loosing the trade relationship.
 

maglomanic

Junior Member
Gollevainen said:
I think the same rules apply to russia-china arms trade as to other trade in general. You cannot sell goods bougth from another to third party wihtout its approval or facing the risk of loosing the trade relationship.
Actually if i understand miggy correctly he is trying to point to the rd-93 deal in which Russia has a face saving argument that it's not selling to Pakistan directly. If similar kind of deal could be done in which Russia sells to china and gives it tacit approval to seel to Pakistan.

My opnion is that Pakistan won't go for such a deal keeping in mind all the complexities and diplomatic sensitivities involved.
 

Gollevainen

Colonel
VIP Professional
Registered Member
Well yeas that could be possiple, but I cannot see whether there is any real reason for it. I mean, in whose chruch has it been decleared that Russia cannot sell arms to Pakistan? Only the trade whit India migth prevent it, but Russian arms deals have had colorull history of beeing rather illogical and short sighted what comes to good deals. Its too complicated and gives too much for 'free' to china and in the end, it wouldnt fool indians in any aspect. A bad busines basicly....
 
Top