You dont negotiate with the enemy who encroaches your territory and now trying to justify. I say treatment by IA is justified.
Blame PLA for running away leaving behind so called negotiator, it was their job to protect him. But like always blame enemy for your own mistakes and start crying, making propaganda videos. I mean who does this?
Okay here you're making more sense. So what you're saying is Indians are justified because it is China encroaching India. You know what? Here I am personally on your "side". I think this stretch of land was never demarcated in its entire history of being known. Tibet's history has gone from not being "China" to conquered by the Mongol empire under China many centuries ago, to becoming semi independent during a period of China closing off and then back to China. But the lines between Tibet and India have never been demarcated.
However in all fairness, I do agree that this stretch is more
important to India than it is to China, even after considering China's interest in securing safe routes to Pakistan Iran and the Middle East. These problems could have found solutions in good diplomacy between China and India but Chinese leaders considered confrontation to be preferable. Perhaps after Nehru, they had much less faith in the workings of the Indian culture and system in creating a relationship that can be relied upon.
And so I understand perfectly why Indian leaders have and will want to create a sense of entitlement to these disputes. It is certainly an unfortunate dilemma for both nations because there is simply no easy solution because even eating up the land may mean further trouble down the line and certainly a spoken and unspoken unease in diplomatic relations in the future. The choice by the Chinese side to insist rather than relent even back in the 1950s, we could really only speculate on. Perhaps they were right to choose this path and continue on it. It isn't something for us to judge because we don't have a complete picture or see the entire motivation. Technical neither side has any more right to it but Chinese leaders could have conceded it to India seeing as this is so close to India's major population areas. Perhaps that was the motivation, a little cynical to say the least.
But in light of acknowledging this being a dispute, there is no more right to initiate violence. If India sees fit, they will probably meet with responses and they have in this case.
