Ladakh Flash Point

Status
Not open for further replies.
manqiangrexue

manqiangrexue

Brigadier
longmarch said:
The notion that Modi would escalate this into 1962 v2 just because China release some numbers is pure hallucination. Quite the opposite, had China released this video earlier, it would show the world what really happened, helped de-escalate instead of the other way around.
Click to expand...
Your hallucination. Nobody said that that's what would happen but in the heat of the moment, it could make it too difficult for them to calm down. You have no proof that this is wrong and you are in no position to judge. Your speculation < than the speculation of CCP planners with classified information.
longmarch said:
As Mao said, look down your opponent strategically, respect them tactically. PLA betrayed both principles and did just the opposite. I'm not the traiter, they are.
Click to expand...
People are not slaves to principles; there is no such thing as betrayal there. The PLA can make new principles for every conflict; it is adaptability.
longmarch said:
Strategically, PLA thinkers always give all sorts of excuses, concern about Taiwan, US, covid, logistics, blah blah, like Indians don't have their issues. Because of that, they are not willing to escalate, and yield all initiative to India side.
Click to expand...
China is in a very complicated and challenging situation as the rising power. They can't all enter conflicts empty-mindedly like you. India always had the initiative because they wanted to attack and change the status quo. China repelled them, inflicted casualties, and advanced on them; if they had double digit IQ, they would now know that America's words are worth less than the air they travel through.
longmarch said:
Tactically, they are daring, reckless and old-fashioned, their weakness in strategically thinking limited their minds, thus the miscalculation in Pangong Tso, resulting in defeat.
Click to expand...
By they, I'm going to assume you meant India because China never suffered and could never suffer a defeat by such an incompetent foe.
longmarch said:
The purpose of releasing this information now:
- they have no choice because of TASS report
- about save face at Pangong Tso .if there is anyway to link these two, this is the way.
- solidify their position in Galwan negotiation. As I said, releasing factual information helps de-escalate and solidify PLA, not stupidly thinking otherwise.
Click to expand...
Nonsense analysis. They obviously released this information after the de-escalation so that there is no (or minimal) chance of re-escalation by India. You tell them right afterwards that they lost 20 men and killed 4 in a cowardly ambush and the only thing on their little raging minds will be how to get at least 16 more to even the score, causing them to do more stupid reckless shit, getting more Indians killed like an idiot taking out 3 mortgages to try to win back his money from the casino until there's just no way to solve this without a large conflict. This is exactly what America wanted to see and you're the type of fellow to give it to them on a platter accusing others of thinking too much. No. You think too little.

They release it now because they have to recognize the heroes who died.
longmarch said:
I'm not Westerner, but I know pretty well what they think. Would they think this is smart way to handle it? Oh Gosh.
Click to expand...
So you claim. Don't see the point of this sentence.
longmarch said:
Being humiliated once is not a big problem, not learning your lessons and mishandling border issues for decades IS a big problem.
Click to expand...
That's been India's traditional failing.
longmarch said:
I'm not saying Indians did any better, but they are just being who they are.
Click to expand...
What is this, a Disney movie? Just be who you are? Drivel.
 
Last edited:
D

davidau

Senior Member
Registered Member
manqiangrexue said:
Your hallucination. Nobody said that that's what would happen but in the heat of the moment, it could make it too difficult for them to calm down. You have no proof that this is wrong and you are in no position to judge. Your speculation < than the speculation of CCP planners with classified information.

People are not slaves to principles; there is no such thing as betrayal there. The PLA can make new principles for every conflict; it is adaptability.

China is in a very complicated and challenging situation as the rising power. They can't all enter conflicts empty-mindedly like you. India always had the initiative because they wanted to attack and change the status quo. China repelled them, inflicted casualties, and advanced on them; if they had double digit IQ, they would now know that America's words are worth less than the air they travel through.

By they, I'm going to assume you meant India because China never suffered and could never suffer a defeat by such an incompetent foe.

Nonsense analysis. They obviously released this information after the de-escalation so that there is no (or minimal) chance of re-escalation by India. You tell them right afterwards that they lost 20 men and killed 4 in a cowardly ambush and the only thing on their little raging minds will be how to get at least 16 more to even the score, causing them to do more stupid reckless shit, getting more Indians killed like an idiot taking out 3 mortgages to try to win back his money from the casino until there's just no way to solve this without a large conflict. This is exactly what America wanted to see and you're the type of fellow to give it to them on a platter accusing others of thinking too much. No. You think too little.

They release it now because they have to recognize the heroes who died.

So you claim. Don't see the point of this sentence.

That's been India's traditional failing.

What is this, a Disney movie? Just be who you are? Drivel.
Click to expand...
India is a country full of holy cows. What they utter is a load of bullshits, at best!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top