Ladakh Flash Point

Status
Not open for further replies.

Xizor

Captain
Registered Member
India was perfectly fine with pangong 4-8 being a buffer zone. Read what colonel Dinny wrote about that. It was China that tried to forcefully occupy that by building infrastructure that is permanent in nature to try and gain an advantage over India in the region, but was forced to withdraw. Even if that is not a complete Indian victory, I fail to see how that is a Chinese win.
No one is preaching about that being an exclusive Chinese win.

The buffer zone is between F2/3 to F8 with a good infra in place from F8 to F4.
 

manqiangrexue

Brigadier
PP 14 was a patrolling point that marked the end of the lac as per the 1992 agreement. India had never camped on the point, only patrolled up to it. But China decided the LAc was actually at the Galwan mouth, which is why they tried to occupy that point. The reason the melee started was because China set up an encampment on the point.
The reason the melee started was because China made you start an ambush? LOL Yeah, ok, the reason there are hostilities is because Indians exist. How's that?
Now that China disengaged, status quo ante has been restored, at the cost of dead soldiers on both sides.
Now that China let you off the hook, you can go lick your wounds and learn your lesson that being America's attack dog doesn't pay and China can go back to rising to the top of the world... except that never stopped.
 

lgnxz

Junior Member
Registered Member
India was perfectly fine with pangong 4-8 being a buffer zone
Well then did you just admit that you're losing since the buffer zone is actually between 3 to 8? ;)
Again what's up with the constant lying as well??
It was China that tried to forcefully occupy that by building infrastructure that is permanent in nature to try and gain an advantage over India in the region, but was forced to withdraw.
Uh seems to me that the PLA is withdrawing by itself, but do go on with your delusional narrative.
India had never camped on the point, only patrolled up to it.
China just today literally posted a video proof disproving this lie, but since even an evidence as jarring as video can't even penetrate the delusion and thickness of a skull indians have, as I said, discussion with you lot is always unfortunately pointless.
 

Nobonita Barua

Senior Member
Registered Member
Please pick a narrative and stick with it. Did evil Indians occupy Chinese territory, or did China capture 1000 sq km? both can't be true.
Sure they can be. If Indians can be those who were first to quote Chinese media to report fatality on both sides & now 8 months later can claim China is "admitting" fatality, I see no reason why China can't do that.
And the international media is already debunking the second claim by showing evidence of Chinese withdrawal
According to "international media" Alex navalny is going to be next Russian president.
 

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member
Well then did you just admit that you're losing since the buffer zone is actually between 3 to 8? ;)
Again what's up with the constant lying as well??

Uh seems to me that the PLA is withdrawing by itself, but do go on with your delusional narrative.

China just today literally posted a video proof disproving this lie, but since even an evidence as jarring as video can't even penetrate the delusion and thickness of a skull indians have, as I said, discussion with you lot is always unfortunately pointless.
So how do you explain the Chinese tents on pp14 prior to the clash?
 

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member
The reason the melee started was because China made you start an ambush? LOL Yeah, ok, the reason there are hostilities is because Indians exist. How's that?

Now that China let you off the hook, you can go lick your wounds and learn your lesson that being America's attack dog doesn't pay and China can go back to rising to the top of the world... except that never stopped.
When you finish retreating maybe we will think about that.
 

twineedle

Junior Member
Registered Member
No one is preaching about that being an exclusive Chinese win.

The buffer zone is between F2/3 to F8 with a good infra in place from F8 to F4.
As part of the deal, all infrastructure between 3 and 8 have been dismantled. Satellite images have shown that currently China is keeping its end of the deal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top