J-20... The New Generation Fighter III

Status
Not open for further replies.

Blitzo

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
Registered Member
^ It is kind of interesting that kopp is mostly using J-20 as the carry for bashing JSF and superbugs though. I wonder why the lack of PAK FA promotion.
 

AssassinsMace

Lieutenant General
Wow pretty pathetic. The second rehash of an old accusation presented as a new revelation. First the Pakistanis let China examine the stealth helicopter and now this one again.

New Chinese stealth jet starts talk of Russian help
By Thomas Grove | Reuters – 11 mins ago

MOSCOW (Reuters) - Similarities between a new Chinese fighter jet and a prototype Russian plane have brought suggestions that Moscow may be quietly helping Beijing compete with the world's military powers.

Experts say the fifth-generation J-20 fighter, which made its maiden flight in January during a visit of the U.S. defense secretary, could have its origins in the Mikoyan 1.44 stealth jet that never made it to the production line.

A highly placed source close to Russia's defense industry said the similarities suggested Mikoyan technology had been passed into the hands of Chinese arms designers.

"It looks like they got access...to documents relating to the Mikoyan -- the aircraft that the Ministry of Defense skipped over in its tender to create a stealth fighter," he said, speaking on condition of anonymity.

He said it was not clear whether such a transfer of technology had been legal. Analysts say Russia's assistance to the Chinese may help Moscow keep tabs on the rising military power's defense capabilities of its eastern neighbor.

Independent analyst Adil Mukashev, who specializes in ties between Russia and China, suggested there had been a financial transaction.

"China bought the technology for parts, including the tail of the Mikoyan, for money," he said.

China's Defense Ministry declined a request for comment. Russia's United Aircraft Corporation (UAC), which oversees production of the Mikoyan jets, denies any technology or design transfer took place with China.

Only the United States has an operational fifth-generation fighter, which is nearly impossible to track on radar. Russia is working to start serial production of its prototype craft in the next five to six years.

China's creation of such a plane would put the country into an elite group of military powers, although analysts say it will take years to perfect the craft.

The source said Chinese officials had been invited to the plane's first public display when Russia was in the early stages of creating a fighter jet to compete with the U.S. F-22.

Rival designer Sukhoi was eventually contracted to help build the fighter and the Mikoyan 1.44, which lacks the radar-evading engineering of the U.S. F-22, was passed over.

DEVELOPING MILITARY TIES

Russia, the world's top energy producer, has fed China, the largest energy consumer, with natural gas and oil in its fast rise to become a global power. But it has been unable to keep up with China's military spending, which was second only to the United States' in 2010.

Relations between the two countries are cordial but, in a sign that the two sides are suspicious of each other, Moscow is boosting its military capabilities in Russia's Far East to defend its position in resource-rich Siberia.

China, once a big buyer of Russian tanks, helicopters and jet fighters, has slowed its purchases from Moscow as its own production grew but military ties remain.

China's ambassador to Russia, Li Huei, was quoted last year as saying defense cooperation with Russia was moving beyond the buying and selling of weapons.

China is also trying to boost its naval power and its first aircraft carrier had its maiden voyage this month. The re-fitted Soviet craft was bought from Ukraine.

"The Chinese aerospace industry is booming and developing rapidly," said Mikhail Pogosyan, head of UAC.

"In the aerospace industry what matters is the experience you have -- not only to start a project but to see it through," he said on the sidelines of Russia's premiere air show, MAKS.

(Additional reporting by Sabrina Mao in Beijing)

(Editing by Timothy Heritage and Angus MacSwan)
..
 

getready

Senior Member
^ It is kind of interesting that kopp is mostly using J-20 as the carry for bashing JSF and superbugs though. I wonder why the lack of PAK FA promotion.

interesting, did he do an assesment of the pak fa when it first appeared like the J-20 paper he wrote?
 

kroko

Senior Member
Some have resorted to their childishness in other recent event threads. The mods must sleeping over there because they're certainly allowing Pakistan bashing and crying the US and Russia should gang up on China. It always happens when some positive military event happens in China. I especially like the one who thinks somehow it's wrong for China to throw money on the J-20 or the Varyag without any accountability.

The ideia that US and russia will gang up on china is totally ridiculous. china is far more important to russia than the US (economically and strategically). russia state media (Ria novosti and RT) always badmouths US, rarely (almost never) china.

that is just a popular fantasy of us military fans (whose vast majority is anti-chinese) and some russian military fans (who resent china surpassing them, after enjoying vast superiority during the USSR times)

Although i post in others forums, i have found SDF to be the only china-friendly english-language military forum. If you think keypub is china unfriendly, you havent seen MP.net
 

Quickie

Colonel
Wow pretty pathetic. The second rehash of an old accusation presented as a new revelation. First the Pakistanis let China examine the stealth helicopter and now this one again.

You know what. The Eurofighter is derived from the Mig 1.44. Use one tailfin instead of two. Then, move the canards to a more forward position, and the basic configuration is all there.
 

broadsword

Brigadier
The ideia that US and russia will gang up on china is totally ridiculous. china is far more important to russia than the US (economically and strategically). russia state media (Ria novosti and RT) always badmouths US, rarely (almost never) china.

At the start of the financial crisis 2-3 years ago, Putin suggested to Chinese leaders to dump US debt holdings. Western instigators are not aware of the friendship building deeds of both nations so they think that inflammatory stories will damage the strong ties.
 

i.e.

Senior Member
The ideia that US and russia will gang up on china is totally ridiculous. china is far more important to russia than the US (economically and strategically). russia state media (Ria novosti and RT) always badmouths US, rarely (almost never) china.

that is just a popular fantasy of us military fans (whose vast majority is anti-chinese) and some russian military fans (who resent china surpassing them, after enjoying vast superiority during the USSR times)

more likely hotheads of subcontinent extraction whose hatred for their fellow subcontinentals carries over to their enemie's allies.

yes, I am talking about a certain 4 wheel off round vehicle.


Most Russians I met with are proud of their country but rational.

Most American hotheads, once they got the round the fact that china does not only make crap stuff for walmart, almost has a grudging respect for the pragmaticism of chinese.

Most Brits hotheads are bit more snoody but resigns to the fact that they are not going to out compete China so cheer india on.

of course this is my extreme stereotypical generalization.

anyhoo. (in canadian accent)

back to topic. before the Vader comes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top