I have never dismissed a presentation as BS in the sense that it is wrong but what he usually posts falls into the area of "too much information for the casual reader, far too little information for a tech company."
He can present a plan, but I didn't see one that wasn't made of Google-able information that would be educational to us but completely useless to a real company. I like to embarrass people who have no humility. A guy with nothing who curses on forums saying Ren Zhengfei doesn't know what he's doing?? Yeah, he needs to be embarrassed for that.
Who? Here? Every industry complains that their government isn't giving them enough attention to prosper. Nobody steps up to the plate. If someone had the research and needed a grant from the Chinese government to make it work, they would get it. Instead what is it? Bunch of useless hacks complaining without any usable input, complaining that blue isn't green, and I think it's obvious that Huawei and the CCP are very open to talent wanting to help Chinese tech.
I don't care if it bothers you but all I can do is give a big picture of the trend of success and how equipped they are economically and manpower-wise to succeed again. Nobody, not me, not tidalwave, not anybody unless they have access to privileged information, can tell you more about what is going on inside China to create this tech. And pretending that you know things that you don't, or that all X values are 0 is much worse than just saying you don't know the specifics but can get a gist from the big picture.
Why didn't you respond that that discussion when I had put it there, with all the points? I had written a fairly long post to you that you did not reply to and now you dredge that up here? I think the teenager with a low IQ is much more likely to be you than an entire government, especially because you could not answer my rebuttal to your "fixes" which I feel would be unlikely to to improve anything measurably.
China's entire rise is an epic success; people who bet against China have experienced the epic failures. That is the big picture and it supersedes any nit-picked ones you can imagine.
I am not sure whether you are genuinely trying to help or despising China/Huawei or just being arrogant.
That seems completely implausible. If that were to be the case, then the US would stop trying attack China and China would dismantle some of its programs. Instead, we see the US trying to do everything in its power to stunt China and China pouring money and resources getting fast improvements in its fields. MIC 2025 isn't mentioned anymore because now it's MIC ASAP! This has all the markings of a full on tech war instead of any side making concessions.
Huawei press guy couldnt even speak English without accent, reading from a script, and was not polished at all, those pressers were clearly intended for western audience so yes it was PR fail.
Obviously, because he drew diagrams with information you could find on Google. Does that sound like something useful to a major tech company??
And you are putting the cart before the horse. I never accepted and you never proved that your proposed changes to the media would yield anything. I rebutted your argument and you never replied, now don't go assuming they are points already made until you've met me in that debate.
Yeah, that was quite a serious mistake, I agree. Hopefully, it serves as an example for Chinese people to be more careful if they hold valuable information.