TerraN_EmpirE
Tyrant King
In that case the guard/handle would only be needed if the user is going to put some kind of optic device on the rifle. There are many firearms with reciprocating charging handles that are not recessed into any kind of guard, and they are usually in areas more inconvenient for the user (on the sides), but more convenient for optics.
We might want to move the rest of this to the QBZ thread. but I more or less agree. A better option IMO would be some thing like the sight bridge on the G36 with a replacement for the shark fin based being a T shaped set of tabs on either side or a design again akin to the G36.