China's SCS Strategy Thread

LawLeadsToPeace

Senior Member
Staff member
Moderator - World Affairs
Registered Member
.

View attachment 117502
One of the resupply ship probably getting broaded by CCG.
Is there a confirmation that the Chinese boarded one of the resupply boats?

Edit: I read the Chinese Coast Guard's statement, and they seem to imply that they did. Despite the success of the Chinese essentially asserting control over the island, this was definitely a blow to the Chinese's PR image, thereby failing to resolve the issue at hand.
 
Last edited:

PhSt

Junior Member
Registered Member

In the latest press interview, the PCG spokesperson is outright calling the Chinese side liars and continued with the usual China bashing narrative. This is what China gets in return for showing a goodwill gesture to the PH.


Emboldened by China's goodwill, now the US is pressuring the PH government to build structures in Rén'ài Jiāo

 

Overbom

Brigadier
Registered Member

In the latest press interview, the PCG spokesperson is outright calling the Chinese side liars and continued with the usual China bashing narrative. This is what China gets in return for showing a goodwill gesture to the PH.


Emboldened by China's goodwill, now the US is pressuring the PH government to build structures in Rén'ài Jiāo

All that matters is if construction/repair supplies were delivered. If not, that's China's win. If yes, that's a humiliation and should expect other ASEAN countries to start making noises as well
 

Biscuits

Colonel
Registered Member

In the latest press interview, the PCG spokesperson is outright calling the Chinese side liars and continued with the usual China bashing narrative. This is what China gets in return for showing a goodwill gesture to the PH.


Emboldened by China's goodwill, now the US is pressuring the PH government to build structures in Rén'ài Jiāo

No pictures from the PH side? If the constructional materials got through, why not show it? For now it's just word against word, and I know which side is more trustworthy.
 

TK3600

Major
Registered Member
Time for China to master the art of "strategic face slapping". If the other party is not conducting diplomacy in good faith some face slapping on purpose is good for deterring opportunistic politicians. In this case China knows not allowing construction will eventually force the ship to disband, so they allowed some face saving for both sides. However if Philipine does not take the L quietly, there is also the option to make them take the L more obviously, which is to block food supply. Eventually the occupant either have mutiny, or need to be rescued off shore.

Such face slapping exercise may result in some whining, but it serves well to deter other nations looking to start up trouble with China. China does not want trouble yes, but this works both ways. Most other country don't like trouble either. China can avoid trouble by displaying ability to create bigger trouble than other party. That is the alternative to the "save face both sides" approach.

One example of this success is the infamous "create the conditions first" interaction between Justin Trudeau and Xi jinping. Despite Canada being the western poster boy the western media all made fun of Trudeau instead of the 'big bad Xi'. The truth is western society values looking tough than mutual face saving. They rather praise Xi looking tough even though he is the 'bad guy'. Gestures like having others save face will instead be interpreted as weakness. The gesture to moderately bully others is seen as desirable and respectable. This may seems tribal and primitive to people of Chinese culture, but this is how western civilization functions.

Emphasize on 'moderate bullying'. The gesture must be strong enough to look tough, but not enough to elicit terror. In this case I recommended blocking food instead of evict them by force. These is some art in balancing the act to fit the description.
 
Last edited:

PhSt

Junior Member
Registered Member
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

So suddenly the US is in quite a hurry to set up forward bases facing Taiwan in preparation for the upcoming Chinese liberation campaign.

The port infrastructures are planned to be built on Basco island, approximately 175 km from Hengchun, Taiwan.

12124211.png




Meanwhile, the Governor of Cagayan province (another northern province facing Taiwan) who opposed US plans to station troops and set up bases in his province is now under intense political harassment.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Recall that this governor is a staunch critic of American presence in northern Philippines. In a documentary by CNA below, he pointed out the obvious that the US never had any meaningful economic contribution to his province while China is by far the largest market for most of the region's agricultural products. So why create unnecessary tension with your biggest economic partner by allowing US forces in the area?

 
Top