2013 China Russia Joint Naval Training

Status
Not open for further replies.

franco-russe

Senior Member
I suppose Pacific Fleet sailors are used to the sight of PLAN ships since these Sino-Russian joint naval exercises have been going on since 2005.

What is meant by "they have 5, we have 16"? PLAN will have quite a long way to go before it is as powerful as the Russian Navy.
 

Lion

Senior Member
PLAN will have quite a long way to go before it is as powerful as the Russian Navy.

Long way to go before as powerful as Russian Navy? I will not say PLAN has long surpassed Russian Navy but PLAN has its strong point while Russian has hers.
For example, Russian amphibious forces is virtually non existent.
 

Jeff Head

General
Registered Member
I suppose Pacific Fleet sailors are used to the sight of PLAN ships since these Sino-Russian joint naval exercises have been going on since 2005.

What is meant by "they have 5, we have 16"? PLAN will have quite a long way to go before it is as powerful as the Russian Navy.
I believe he was answering Blackstone's question about what goes through a Russian sailors mind as he saw the Chinese vessels passing by in the exercise.

In that exercise the Russians had 16 vessels and the PLAN 5, so a Russian might think, "We have 16, they have 5."
 

tphuang

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
VIP Professional
Registered Member
I suppose Pacific Fleet sailors are used to the sight of PLAN ships since these Sino-Russian joint naval exercises have been going on since 2005.

What is meant by "they have 5, we have 16"? PLAN will have quite a long way to go before it is as powerful as the Russian Navy.

in terms of surface fleet, PLAN is quite a bit ahead of RN now. Submarines is a different story though. Especially nuclear subs, that's where PLAN really trails behind.
 

astrotrain

Just Hatched
Registered Member
I am not sure if anyone has touched on this but I wonder based on exercises like this, has either side proposed testing of the effectiveness of the stealthified hulls of the PLAN vessels? This would answer a multitude of questions for the engineers that designed these vessels based on a close to real world combat environment.

What I am talking about is a weapons lock both from air (helo) and ship to ship. Possibly a dummy antiship missile test as well: testing the hull radar signature/lock + effective range, the vessels air defense/antiship CIWS etc. I believe the Russian destroyers are carrying Sunburns? What a great test that would be.

I know either side has their own testing facilities but nothing would beat real world data from excersies with a opposing navy.

Man you can get a boat load of data if one wanted to but I doubt either side would want to show such vulnerabiliities.
 

vesicles

Colonel
I am not sure if anyone has touched on this but I wonder based on exercises like this, has either side proposed testing of the effectiveness of the stealthified hulls of the PLAN vessels? This would answer a multitude of questions for the engineers that designed these vessels based on a close to real world combat environment.

What I am talking about is a weapons lock both from air (helo) and ship to ship. Possibly a dummy antiship missile test as well: testing the hull radar signature/lock + effective range, the vessels air defense/antiship CIWS etc. I believe the Russian destroyers are carrying Sunburns? What a great test that would be.

I know either side has their own testing facilities but nothing would beat real world data from excersies with a opposing navy.

Man you can get a boat load of data if one wanted to but I doubt either side would want to show such vulnerabiliities.

Wouldn't that expose too much classified info? I mean the PLAN doesn't really want the another country to have detailed knowledge of their vessels radar signature. And at the same time, the Russians don't want the Chinese to know what the detection limit is for their radars/sonars. I think this is something no one wants to do...
 
Last edited:

escobar

Brigadier
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


The China-Russia maritime joint exercise codenamed “Maritime Joint Exercise 2013” will officially kick off in the waters of the Peter the Great Gulf in the Sea of Japan on July 5. According to Rear Admiral Yin Zhuo, a renowned military expert, the fire-control radars in this maritime joint exercise will use training frequencies instead of operation frequencies in order to prevent such electronic information as the operation frequencies of fire-control radars from being obtained by the U.S. and Japan.

Senior Captain Zhang Junshe, a researcher with the Naval Military Academic Research Institute under the Navy of the Chinese People's Liberation Army (PLAN), stated in an interview on July 2 that during the anti-submarine and air-defense drills in this China-Russia maritime joint military exercise, the warships from both sides will open their own radars, including the fire-control radar and the illumination radar. In addition, the missile-guidance radar and other radars as well as the sonar, photoelectric communication, electronic equipment, and others will also be used.

In regards to this issue, Yin Zhuo further explained that the fire-control radars opened by the warships in this exercise would use their training frequencies, because operation frequencies are improper to be used. They can be used only during actual combats. Since the aircraft from the U.S., Japan, the Republic of Korea (ROK) and other countries will surely be active in the surrounding airspace collecting electronic information while the China-Russia maritime joint military exercise is being held, if the operational fire-control radars are all opened, their information will be obtained by the U.S., Japan and other countries.

The opening of the fire-control radar indicates that weapons will be used in the exercise regardless of whether the exercise is a live-fire exercise or not. As long as the fire-control radar is opened, it means that live ammunition attacks or simulated attacks are being carried out, which explains that all weapons are going to be operated in use during the exercise.
 

thunderchief

Senior Member
Yanking Japan's chain a bit is all. That was the purpose. Pretty good show of force too, with both the Russian and Chinese Task Forces transitting at different times.

Actually , one part of the exercise was repealing invasion of Sakhalin Island by unmentioned country . Go figure . ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top