SOMERVILLE, N.J. — After knocking her unconscious with a sucker punch to the face and strangling her neck, Gary Wilson stood over Carolyn Stone's naked motionless body and dropped a 25-pound cinder block on her head.
Then he picked up the bloody cinder block and dropped it on her head again.
That's what he told a hushed courtroom Wednesday, explaining that he had "snapped" after Stone, 45, laughed when he couldn't get an erection in order to have sex with her.
After the murder, Wilson said, he concocted a story about raping Stone because he didn't want her family to feel bad that she would cheat on her boyfriend with his friend.
But Wilson, 31, is not on trial. In 2011 he pleaded guilty to the 2009 Memorial Day weekend slaying of Stone and in July 2013 was sentenced to 45 years in prison.
Wilson, however, is not a witness for the prosecution, which is trying to convince a Somerset County jury that David Granskie Jr., the son of Stone's boyfriend, was one of three men who raped and brutally killed Stone.
Wilson is a witness for the defense and his testimony this week — that he alone killed Stone and that there was no rape — may strike a blow to the state's case, which hinges on an inconsistent confession by Granskie. The defense has said that the confession should not be believed because it is the product of a heroin junkie's drug-addled mind "parroting back" what police had suggested during the interrogation.
Somerset County Assistant Prosecutor Tim Van Hise rested his case Wednesday. He did not bring before the jury any witnesses to the crime and called neither Wilson nor Rocky DiTaranto, who agreed to a five-year prison sentence in exchange for pleading guilty to conspiracy to commit aggravated sexual assault and to testify against Granskie. DiTaranto already is out of prison because he spent four years and five months in jail after his arrest waiting for a trial that never happened.
With the jury out of the room, Granskie's attorney, Katherine Errickson, tried to have the case dismissed, arguing that the prosecution has not been able to corroborate Granskie's confession.
"This is a very unusual case for the prosecution to try a horrible offense and not call any co-defendants or any witnesses," Errickson said.
Superior Court Judge Robert Reed did not throw out the case saying that it's the job of the jury to determine the weight of the confession and any evidence.
Granskie091814b
David Granskie is accused of taking part in the sexual assault and murder of Carolyn Stone, who was murdered in 2009.(Photo: Kathy Johnson, The (Bridgewater, N.J.) Courier News)
But on the stand, wearing red prison garb and hand and ankle shackles, a slimmer-looking Wilson said everything that Granskie had confessed to doing or to seeing was not true.
Wilson said Granskie did not have vaginal or oral sex with Stone, that he did not drop the cinder block on her, and could not have seen anyone else drop the cinder block because Granskie was inside sleeping at the time of the murder.
Wilson and other guests had spent the afternoon and early evening drinking, smoking marijuana and snorting cocaine at the Granskie home. Wilson said Stone and Granskie Sr. had done drugs but was not sure whether Granskie Jr. did.
Wilson said Stone was acting "odd" by making fun of him for living with this parents and not having a driver's license.
Later on, she began rubbing his feet by the chiminea, an outdoor fireplace.
"It felt weird when her boyfriend is right there," he said about the affection.
Stone decided to go inside and sleep as the party continued outside, he said. Eventually Wilson's close friend left, leaving the Granskies, DiTaranto and Wilson. Wilson said he went to the bathroom and saw that Stone's bedroom door was open and that she was awake.
"I walked in, bent down to kiss her and made out," which he said was consensual. "I told her to come outside after Big Dave (her boyfriend) went in to sleep."
DiTaranto
Rocky DiTaranto is on trial in connection with the 2009 death of Carolyn Stone in Somerville, N.J.(Photo: Kathy Johnson, The (Bridgewater, N.J.) Courier News)
Later, Granskie Jr. went to bed. He was followed by his father, Wilson said. Stone came to the door when he and DiTaranto were outside. Wilson said he asked her if Big Dave was asleep. She said yes.
"I kissed her and decided to go to the backyard to hook up."
Wilson said he motioned for DiTaranto to join them. After Wilson took off his shorts, leaving just his swim trunks on, he said he needed to go to the restroom and told DiTaranto to "keep her company while I'm gone."
But in the restroom, Wilson said he realized that he probably would not be able to get an erection because "it has happened before" when he's had too much to drink and done too much cocaine.
After about five minutes, Wilson went outside and saw DiTaranto walking toward him.
"I'm done man," Wilson said DiTaranto said. "I'm going home."
Wilson said he went behind the shed and saw that Stone was on her knees, naked except a shirt around her neck.
Wilson said he told her that he wouldn't be able to have sex with her.
"What kind of man can't get aroused in front of a naked woman?" she said, according to his testimony.
"I tried to explain that I had been drinking too much and she just started laughing.
"I told her it's not funny; it happens. And she kept laughing.
"So I snapped and I punched her. She fell back unconscious. After I had hit her I began to choke her and she had no fight in her.
"I didn't want people to know that I had hit her or to find out why she was in the backyard. I didn't want Big Dave to know that I had betrayed his friendship. So I started to choke her so that he would never know we betrayed him.
"I know it doesn't make sense. It just seemed to be the logical thing to do at the time to get rid of the situation that I had made very bad. At that point it seemed like my only option.
"After choking her for a while I decided I had to finish what I started. It didn't seem like it was working. I saw a cinder block and knew from my work in construction that it was a very heavy object. I stood over her. I lifted it over my head. I looked down, said I'm sorry, and hit her with the cinder block.
"I decided to do it again. I didn't want her to suffer. It took everything in me to lift that cinder block back up again."
Wilson said he walked back to his parent's home in Bradley Gardens barefoot and shirtless. He told his stepfather to call police because he had killed someone.
"I needed to go to jail because I killed someone," he said. "That's where I deserve to be."
After being charged with murder, Wilson provided three statements to police but testified Wednesday that he was not completely truthful with them.
"The truth didn't seem fair," he said about concocting a rape story. "I wanted to make it easier for them. I did not want to drag her name through the mud."
Wilson, however, never told police that Granskie was involved. Even after being offered a 30-year plea deal to testify against Granskie, Wilson said he turned it down.
"Because he is innocent," he said.