Russian Military News, Reports, Data, etc.

Jeff Head

General
Registered Member
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


000-su33.jpg

News Max said:
A second Russian jet has crashed while trying to land on the aircraft carrier Admiral Kuznetsov after a combat mission over Syria. A similar accident occurred less than a month ago.

According to
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
on Monday, the Russian Defense Ministry said a Sukhoi-33 fighter jet crashed in the Mediterranean Sea while attempting to land on the carrier. The pilot ejected safely.

After performing a combat mission over Syria a Sukhoi-33 fighter-jet overran the runway while trying to land on The Admiral Kuznetsov aircraft carrier. The arresting cable's rupture was the reason," said the defense ministry.

The defense ministry said that despite the incident, the carrier's lead group continued "operating in the Mediterranean in accordance with the long voyage plan," wrote TASS.

According to
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
magazine, on Nov. 13 a Russian Navy Mikoyan MiG-29KR/KUBR fighter crashed in the Mediterranean during operations from the Admiral Kuznetsov. A source told Combat Aircraft that the fighter was returning from a mission flown over Syria when it crashed.

Russian Navy Aviation had hoped to evaluate its newly minted MiG-29KR/KUBR fighters and its modernized Sukhoi Su-33 with the deployment of the carrier to the eastern Mediterranean, noted Combat Aircraft.

"This latest crash is another blow to the Russians, who specifically brought the carrier to the Mediterranean so they could launch airstrikes against rebel-held areas of Aleppo," said Chris Summers of the
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
.

"…The battle group has travelled from the North Sea through the English Channel in the biggest such naval deployment in recent years as part of Russia's military intervention in Syria. Russia has been flying a bombing campaign in Syria for the past year in support of President Assad and has deployed a naval contingent to back up its operation."
THe airwing is small to begin with and now they have lost two aircraft.

Look, high tempo operation of a carrier are togh and dangerous. The US trains and practises this stuff ALL THE TIME with their carriers and politos and those pilots have to maintain certain very high levels of expertise.

I doubt...in fact I know for sure...that the Russians do not maintain such a dedicated and intensive program.

I am sure thw Chinense are waatching and wil ensure that their own program is as intensive as it needs to be in order to be prepared for combat operations.

This is the permier combat operation for the Kuznetsov...IMHO, they were not ready, and probably did not even know that they were not ready to be able to avoid these kind of problems. Quite frankly it sounds like their maitnenace of the anding operations is simply below the standards it needs to be to be able to handle the amunt of traffic they are putting n it in this deployment.

Again, I am sure the PLAN is taking notes.
 

delft

Brigadier
This is the permier combat operation for the Kuznetsov...IMHO, they were not ready, and probably did not even know that they were not ready to be able to avoid these kind of problems. Quite frankly it sounds like their maitnenace of the anding operations is simply below the standards it needs to be to be able to handle the amunt of traffic they are putting n it in this deployment.
They have been looking at USN operations for decades. I'm sure they knew they couldn't judge how far from ready they were. That was a good reason to go and try it anyway. I remember an article written by Adm K in the fifties in which he said that in view of the approach of war more risks were taken by the Soviet navy in the exercises of 1939 and later and that had cost lives. The situation is not as bad as in 1939 of course but sacrificing aircraft in more realistic operations is well worth while when money is not as limited as it was.
 

Equation

Lieutenant General
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!



THe airwing is small to begin with and now they have lost two aircraft.

Look, high tempo operation of a carrier are togh and dangerous. The US trains and practises this stuff ALL THE TIME with their carriers and politos and those pilots have to maintain certain very high levels of expertise.

I doubt...in fact I know for sure...that the Russians do not maintain such a dedicated and intensive program.

I am sure thw Chinense are waatching and wil ensure that their own program is as intensive as it needs to be in order to be prepared for combat operations.

This is the permier combat operation for the Kuznetsov...IMHO, they were not ready, and probably did not even know that they were not ready to be able to avoid these kind of problems. Quite frankly it sounds like their maitnenace of the anding operations is simply below the standards it needs to be to be able to handle the amunt of traffic they are putting n it in this deployment.

Again, I am sure the PLAN is taking notes.

Ahem,perhaps the Russian Kuznetsov crew could always get some more training from the PLAN Liaoning and see how a real upgraded Kuznetsov type class carrier and crew does it.;):D

Putin Shows Off Russia's Embarrassing Aircraft Carrier
198
DEC 5, 2016 1:47 PM EST
By
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

I've written before on how Russian involvement in the war in Syria is about more than just propping up the Assad regime. President Vladimir Putin has also been putting on a demonstration of military might, both to enhance Russia's status as a resurgent power and to
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
to prospective international buyers.

And things had been going well: Ground-based Russian planes have been flying sorties at a highly efficient pace; warships in the Caspian Sea have
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
in northern Syria with cruise missiles; one of Russia's new T-90 tanks
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
relatively unscathed after being hit by a U.S.-made TOW missile.

But when Putin decided to send Russia's lone aircraft carrier, the Admiral Kuznetsov, down to the Mediterranean, he blundered. First, there is no military purpose: The carrier was designed to protect home waters, not for
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
, and with only 15 planes aboard, will do little to augment Russia's ground-based aerial assault.

Second, the ship is simply embarrassing to look at. It lumbers along belching black smoke, accompanied by
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
standing ready to tow because of frequent breakdowns. Its distinctive "ski jump" prow is an admission of technological defeat -- because the deck lacks the catapults found on U.S. carriers, jets need the extra boost of the ramp to avoid toppling into the ocean.

In service since the mid-1980s when it was part of the Soviet navy (and called, variously, the Riga, the Leonid Brezhnev and the Tbilisi), it has made only a handful of deployments in its history, none further than the Mediterranean. According to media reports, problems with
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
have reduced it to just 25 latrines for a crew of 2,000. In 2012 it broke down in the Bay of Biscay and had to be towed thousands of miles to its home port near Murmansk. It had a particularly bad year in 2009, spilling hundreds of metric tons of oil off the coast of Ireland and catching fire near Turkey, an accident in which one sailor died.


Now the Kuznetsov Curse has struck again. According to the trade website
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
, on Saturday an Su-33 Flanker returning to the carrier crashed into the sea after failing to hook onto the deck-top "arrestor cables" that slow the jets upon landing. A similar thing happened
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
with a Mig-29 fighter. (In both cases the pilots were able to eject before impact.)

Perhaps the Russian navy had been anticipating such problems. According to the military information service IHS Janes, the Russians have for weeks been
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
off the flattop to an airfield in Syria.

Even without these fiascos, it's unlikely there would be much of a market anyway if Russia decided to sell the Kuznetsov off -- as it did with the former Admiral Gorshkov to India for $2.35 billion in 2004 and Ukraine did with the hull of the Varyag to China in the late 1990s. In both cases, there was a fair amount of buyer's remorse.

The Chinese have spent hundreds of millions on repairs and new technology for a ship, now called the Liaoning, that's more or less
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
and really used for training. Delivery of India's ship, now called the Vikramaditya, was delayed for years, in part because seven of its eight steam boilers
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
. It was re-commissioned in 2013 and is patrolling the Indian Ocean, although the government has decided that its new, domestically built Tejas lightweight aircraft won't be able to land on the carrier's small deck.

Russia continues to roll out some impressive weaponry in Syria, most recently the sophisticated S-400 air-defense system at its naval base at Tartus. This is only going to help its arms exporting business, which hit a record $15 billion last year. But, unless the purpose was to show off the effectiveness of Russian ejector seats and tugboats, the Kuznetsov should have stayed home. Or, better yet, been sent to the graveyard. It's undoubtedly worth more as scrap metal than as a projection of Russian power.
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
 
Last edited:
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

in the most recent Propaganda footage from the Admiral Kuznetsov:

CNfhc.jpg

(I've posted the landing sequence in
Aircraft Carriers III https://www.sinodefenceforum.com/aircraft-carriers-iii.t7304/page-148#post-427390
 
Yesterday at 3:27 PM
nobody posted yet
Russian Su-33 crashed in the Mediterranean while attempting to land on Kuznetsov aircraft carrier
?
source:
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
and now a credibly Russian source
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

estimated $97m in total had been lost by those recent МиГ-29К & Су-33 Admiral Kuznetsov accidents (interestingly, it's an equivalent of fifteen (15) Kalibrs ... according to the source I quoted)
 
Top