Psychology Of Chinese Social Issues - Scholarly Study

Status
Not open for further replies.
Some time ago I remember a series of stories in the Chinese press about cheng guan/urban management officials getting out of control including a case where a group of them beat up a policeman/public security official who was responding to a call about a brawl between cheng guan and civilians over something. Has there been any follow up on how the cheng guan system is working these days?
 

shen

Senior Member
Rule of law by itself is not enough to end corruption.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


The "three stages of anti-corruption" comprehensive plan as outlined by the 18th party congress.
1) "don't dare to be corruption" achieved through punishment of corrupt officials
2) "don't need to be corruption" involves institutional changes such as reduced state power, cut regulatory hurdles and red tapes, so there is less need to resort to corruption
3) "don't think about corruption" final stage is improved moral education so people would be more self regulating.
 
t stuffs, then I believe it helps people do the right thing and take a stand and know it's worth it and people will stand for them. It's pitiful what's happening as of now yet still, and that's all due to the corruption and ineffectiveness of the rule of law, assurances, and lack of education/awareness and societal adoption off the right norms.

I think his anticorruption campaign may last 2 decades, but if new officials are being trained to adhere to the rule of law and the system and play by the rules, then China's system can effectively change. It's gonna be worth it.[/QUOTE]
Rule of law by itself is not enough to end corruption.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


The "three stages of anti-corruption" comprehensive plan as outlined by the 18th party congress.
1) "don't dare to be corruption" achieved through punishment of corrupt officials
2) "don't need to be corruption" involves institutional changes such as reduced state power, cut regulatory hurdles and red tapes, so there is less need to resort to corruption
3) "don't think about corruption" final stage is improved moral education so people would be more self regulating.

Let's not forget about making sure the compensation of public officials is competitive/high enough to attract quality people to those jobs in the first place and once they are there for them to feel appreciated enough to not want to participate in corruption.
 

solarz

Brigadier
Let's not forget about making sure the compensation of public officials is competitive/high enough to attract quality people to those jobs in the first place and once they are there for them to feel appreciated enough to not want to participate in corruption.

There is also the need to streamline and cut down the bureaucracy. There are too many pencil-pushers in the Chinese public sector. Some activities would definitely benefit from contracting out to the private sector.
 

broadsword

Brigadier
After all the boast about individualism and disdain for collectivism from both East and West, here comes the anticlimax. I remember a few Chinese professors in China and the US who claimed that China could never excel due to its culture of uniformity. As if the police would send you to one of those black jails for inventing a better mouse trap.

How creative are you? Study shows culture impacts creativity

With the "creative class" on the rise, many businesses are trying to capitalize on imagination and innovation. But when it comes to creative juices, some societies have a faster flow than others. That's because, as new research from Concordia University suggests, creativity is tied to culture.

The study, recently published in the Journal of Business Research, compared nearly 300 individuals from Taiwan, a collectivist society, and Canada, a more individualistic country. Results show that those from individualist societies generate a greater number of ideas as compared to their collectivist counterparts - though the cultures were on nearly equal footing when it came to the quality of that creative output.

Gad Saad, a professor at Concordia's John Molson School of Business, co-authored the study with Concordia graduate student Louis Ho and Mark Cleveland from the University of Western Ontario. They theorized that where a country falls on the individualism vs. collectivism continuum would affect the creative juices that might be "permitted" to flow from members of a particular culture.

"Brainstorming is often used as a proxy for creativity, so we decided to conduct brainstorming tasks using culturally neutral stimuli in Taiwan and in Canada," Saad says.

He and his co-authors hypothesized that members of an individualistic society would perform particularly well in a task that promotes out-of-the-box thinking such as coming up with the proverbial million-dollar idea, compared with those from a collectivist ethos, who wouldn't be as willing to engage in that kind of thinking because they would be more reluctant to stand out from the group.

The researchers recruited students from two universities in Taipei and Montreal and collected data on five measures that will be familiar to anyone who has had to brainstorm in a group:

The number of generated ideas
The quality of the ideas, as evaluated by independent judges
The number of uttered negative statements within the brainstorming groups, such as "This is a dumb idea that will fail."
The valence of the negative statements—"This is the all-time dumbest idea" has a stronger negative connotation than "This idea is rather banal."
The confidence level exhibited by group members when asked to evaluate their performance in comparison to other teams.

When it comes to creativity, quality trumps quantity

"The study largely supported our hypotheses," Saad says. "We found that the individualists came up with many more ideas. They also uttered more negative statements—and those statements were more strongly negative. The Canadian group also displayed greater overconfidence than their Taiwanese counterparts."

But when it came to the quality of ideas produced, the collectivists scored marginally higher than the individualists.

"This is in line with another important cultural trait that some collectivist societies are known to possess—namely being more reflective as compared to action-oriented, having the reflex to think hard prior to committing to a course of action," Saad says.

Studies like this one are instrumental in understanding cultural differences that increasingly arise as the globe's economic centre of gravity shifts towards East Asia.

"To maximize the productivity of their international teams, global firms need to understand important cultural differences between Western and Eastern mindsets," Saad says. "Brainstorming, a technique often used to generate novel ideas such as new product innovations, might not be equally effective across cultural settings. Even though individuals from collectivistic societies might be coming up with fewer creative ideas, the quality of those ideas tends to be just as good as or marginally better than those of their individualistic counterparts. Employers need to recognize that."
 

solarz

Brigadier
After all the boast about individualism and disdain for collectivism from both East and West, here comes the anticlimax. I remember a few Chinese professors in China and the US who claimed that China could never excel due to its culture of uniformity. As if the police would send you to one of those black jails for inventing a better mouse trap.

Creativity is completely overrated. Like the proverb says, ideas are a dime a dozen. What matters is the implementation of those ideas.
 

AssassinsMace

Lieutenant General
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


How wonderful it is to be colonized yet colonization means a denial of democracy and human rights. Mainland Chinese bad behavior is due to lack colonization, therefore denial of democracy and human rights must be a good thing. Good well-mannered behavior just means how much more you're a lemming. It has nothing to do with being free and independent. A basic lack of understanding of true freedom but instead a brainwashed spin of it for followers only and not the leaders.

Basically it has nothing to do with what they advertise it is. No common sense.
 
Last edited:

solarz

Brigadier
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


How wonderful it is to be colonized yet colonization means a denial of democracy and human rights. Mainland Chinese bad behavior is due to lack colonization, therefore denial of democracy and human rights must be a good thing. Good well-mannered behavior just means how much more you're a lemming. It has nothing to do with being free and independent. A basic lack of understanding of true freedom but instead a brainwashed spin of it for followers only and not the leaders.

Basically it has nothing to do with what they advertise it is. No common sense.

It is also a textbook example of selection bias.

Why does Singapore have a better culture than Hong Kong? Because they whip you for chewing gum? Why is Vietnam more cultured than Mainland China just because they stop at red lights? Since when is obeying traffic laws a sign of culture???

By that logic, I could argue that Mainland Chinese are far more cultured than North Americans. Why? Because Mainland Chinese are far more likely to obey speed limit than North Americans. Isn't culture wonderful? :rolleyes:
 

AssassinsMace

Lieutenant General
Well some of the stuff I've read about Mainland behavior on Hong Kong's metro system, I just have to laugh. The San Francisco/ Bay Area metro transportation system is rated one of the best in the US. I know someone who works there and tells me what happens on the trains by passengers. If it were true that bad behavior of Mainlanders were at the heart of complaints, then they should start organizing hate organizations against Americans. But we know bad behavior being highlighted is not the reason, it's an excuse. They're just pointing at anything even superficially different as the difference.

I have friend where he and his family travel to Thailand a lot for vacation. They always have a stop-over at Taiwan. My friend's wife hates Taiwan because of their behavior. Taiwan is not immune to bad behavior. All this talk about superior culture is about snobbish elitism and nothing else. And ironically that attitude is a part of the same problem.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top