PLA Strategy in a Taiwan Contingency

Biscuits

Major
Registered Member
Taiwan still have 2nm which barred Cuba treatment. After china get EUV or graphene chip tech, Taiwan will get cuba'd.
Beijing can already do whatever they want, the 2nm is China's technology. It's companies registered and operating in China.

The politicians can order them to set up somewhere else other than Taiwan, if it was an issue of urgent national security.

Cuba is an inappropriate comparison because whatever is between US and Cuba is an issue of geopolitical argument between 2 national entities.

Whereas China is trying to control a delicate internal situation, it is more comparable to the situation of Israel and the West bank. Going in with soldiers IS an option that they shouldn't take off the table. Cutting off everything is also an option that must remain. But any such options can (like you see in the west bank) create a different and potentially not advantageous change in local attitude.

Balancing national defense and avoiding local discontent is the name of the game.
 

resistance

Junior Member
Registered Member
Why are people so obsessed with the idea of Cuba style embargo? I’m always of the opinion that the ruling elite should be punished, not the average people, which embargoes actually impact most heavily.
To be fair, this is the least impact with high probability to get reunification. Obsessed with embargoes is far better than obsessed with using force.
Beijing can already do whatever they want, the 2nm is China's technology. It's companies registered and operating in China.

The politicians can order them to set up somewhere else other than Taiwan, if it was an issue of urgent national security.

Cuba is an inappropriate comparison because whatever is between US and Cuba is an issue of geopolitical argument between 2 national entities.

Whereas China is trying to control a delicate internal situation, it is more comparable to the situation of Israel and the West bank. Going in with soldiers IS an option that they shouldn't take off the table. Cutting off everything is also an option that must remain. But any such options can (like you see in the west bank) create a different and potentially not advantageous change in local attitude.

Balancing national defense and avoiding local discontent is the name of the game.
The semi tools aren't in full supply chain yet. So china can't do it. My though on embargoes is cut Taiwan off global trade but still allow Chinese company to trade via giving license. This will make Taiwan rely on china even more and also hurts economy at the same time.
 

drowingfish

Junior Member
Registered Member
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

An interesting column article.
This author carefully collected professional publications from the ROC military:
View attachment 123568
View attachment 123569
View attachment 123570

It is obvious that they are analyzing and summarizing the experience of the Ukrainian war, attempting to turn cities into fortresses for hidden ground and air unit operations.
In the past, comics drawn by their official propaganda personnel mentioned the tactic of using underground garages to hide tanks. Now they are carefully counting the number of underground garages and tunnels that can be used.

View attachment 123571
In addition, they also mentioned the guerrilla tactics of the Ukrainians and listed some cases, but these cases were mostly actions aimed at assassinating loyalists.

Addendum:
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

The author also provided their own insights on the issue of supply. He is concerned about the risk of the enemy using FPVs to attack vulnerable supply convoys. He opposes destroying the domestic water supply on the island, as it will only cause difficulties for the supply of landing troops.
Due to the immense firepower, ammunition consumption is enormous. Therefore, if sufficient supplies are not provided (assuming that the enemy destroyed port facilities and used sunken ships to block the port at the beginning of the war), it will be impossible to launch a sustained and strong offensive. The enemy will have sufficient time to reorganize their forces and build fortifications, and the war will become a stalemate similar to the Ukrainian war.
Unfortunately, I am not aware of the calculation method for this author's data. According to the author's statistics, transporting supplies through the beach without a port resulted in an effective supply of approximately 7000 tons per day. And these supplies can only support an inefficient attack of 100000 people and their support forces for six hours a day.
The author believes that the worst thing is that the resistance will of Taiwanese civilians is rising due to the impact of the Hong Kong incident, COVID-19 and the Ukrainian war. The reason is very clear, they cannot agree with the excessively harsh policies currently adopted by the mainland government. This means that civilians will actively provide intelligence and supply support to defenders.
According to his estimation, the defenders' ammunition and supplies were sufficient to sustain them for at least a month, buying enough time for Western military intervention and maritime blockade.

——I personally think his viewpoint has some value, but it is obviously too pessimistic.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

This special article is an analysis of the military simulation of CSIS, which mercilessly refutes all optimistic views that "war will end quickly". He believes that if the Taiwanese army engages in street warfare, it may take PLA 15-30 days to capture a city.

I lack the ability to translate long articles, so friends who understand Chinese need to read them on their own.
Taiwan tries to do way too much. they say they will stop PLA on the sea, on the beach, and now in the cities. fact is they dont have enough manpower to do all these at the same time. if your army is defeated on the beach, then sorry dont expect it to orderly withdraw to a city and put up a competent defense.
 

supersnoop

Major
Registered Member
Why are people so obsessed with the idea of Cuba style embargo? I’m always of the opinion that the ruling elite should be punished, not the average people, which embargoes actually impact most heavily.
Reminds me of something my family said they heard on a recent trip in Taiwan, roughly translated of course
"Maybe if the DPP and US just shut up, the mainland will just leave us alone!"

The Pelosi trip was a great example, there was a real fear of something bad happening, and what would it have been for?
 

coolgod

Colonel
Registered Member
Ren Yi thinks a KMT victory is possible. Pekingnology did a
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
. It would be a major upset, though.
Don't see it happening, TW domestic media is basically assuming Lai wins. China's moves towards ECFA is basically assuming Lai wins also. The US planning to send a delegation to Taipei is basically assuming Lai wins. I think nobody expects a KMT presidential victory at this point.
 
Top