Pinkov's latest articles

Temstar

Brigadier
Registered Member
you know... somehow I got the interesting idea that Pinkov is actually an elite agent of the Strategic Fool-You Agency under the command of Rear Admiral (Ret) Zhang Zhaozhong. /s

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
SFA doesn't exist, but if SFA did exist it would spend the majority of time telling the truth on inconsequential matters to build up credibility and then at a few key moments lie to lead people astray to gain strategic advantage, eg J-20

So doesn't really fit Pinkov's MO.

Unless you not only buy that SFA is real, but also Gordon Chang is a high ranking agent of the SFA.
 

The Observer

Junior Member
Registered Member
SFA doesn't exist, but if SFA did exist it would spend the majority of time telling the truth on inconsequential matters to build up credibility and then at a few key moments lie to lead people astray to gain strategic advantage, eg J-20

So doesn't really fit Pinkov's MO.

Unless you not only buy that SFA is real, but also Gordon Chang is a high ranking agent of the SFA.
Whoops. Looks like the Sarcasm tag was too small. Noted. Next time I'll put it in larger font, bolded and italicized.
 

supersnoop

Major
Registered Member
Does he actually have a valid business case for this Kanwa Defense Review thing?
As mentioned, he's been at this for at least 20 years, so unless he has some other income/assets, it's working for him.

If I remember from way way back, he had a listed office address in Toronto's old Chinatown, but I can't remember if anyone went as far as going inside. Again, if recalling correctly it was a small office space over a restaurant (very common in old Chinatown).

Just did a quick look of his current address and it is a PO Box north of the city, so he probably moved with most of the other old Cantonese to that area.

I risk sounding like a crazy doxxer now, but anyway, none of it was secret.

IMO, why was he able to make such a business for himself?
1. If you remember the 90's/early 00's, there was not a large base of information for PLA watchers.
These are the two most famous images (to me at least)
j10history_02large.jpgThe only image of J-10
xxj2.jpg The infamous XXJ Stealth fighter

2. Russia was the number 1 source of hardware at the time. So his knowledge of Russian (which no one AFAIK has doubted) was assumed to be an asset in researching PLA procurement. What was not well known at the time (but now well known) was that Russian sources are 90% BS and boasting, only 10% reality. So sometimes Pinkov could be right due to that 10%.
 
Last edited:

Skywatcher

Captain
SFA doesn't exist, but if SFA did exist it would spend the majority of time telling the truth on inconsequential matters to build up credibility and then at a few key moments lie to lead people astray to gain strategic advantage, eg J-20

So doesn't really fit Pinkov's MO.

Unless you not only buy that SFA is real, but also Gordon Chang is a high ranking agent of the SFA.
Well, Pinkov and GGC have to adopt the SFA playbook for the age of mass saturation cable news, Internet opeds and social media...
 

voyager1

Captain
Registered Member
Well, Pinkov and GGC have to adopt the SFA playbook for the age of mass saturation cable news, Internet opeds and social media...
Not a difficult thing to do. If Gordon Chang can make a living as an "expert" with his China collapse theory which is proved wrong every year, I cant see why that guy would find it difficult to find a similar market for his views

Failing power + delusional people + corporate interests + "exceptional" mindest = free real eastate for China's incoming collapse and weak military
 

supersnoop

Major
Registered Member
Took too long to edit, so continued

In the case of the 10% right, I believe he was one of the first to report the sale of S-300 PMU.

He basically continues to milk news outlets based on this past reputation. It also helps that China experts are predominantly white men who are basically interested in playing up the "China Threat" theory to maintain US military superiority.

Most of these China Experts do not understand Chinese (despite being experts, like an engineer not knowing math), and those that do (Pottinger-types) suffer from are deep tunnel vision.

Pinkov gives them exactly what the fodder want, rumours of Russian and Chinese military cooperation. Furthermore, he plays into their egos by adding in a dash of Chinese incompetence in many of his articles. (China can't copy this, China doesn't know how to use Su-35 etc.) This is a favourite stance of these 'experts', "China can't innovate... but they are the greatest threat to humanity because they are creating powerful weapons ... (err: divide by zero)...
 

ironborn

Junior Member
Registered Member
Is the youtube channel 'Binkov battleground' his channel, it has some following, but some of the stuff I watched are just illogical.
 
Top