Red___Sword
Junior Member
The PLA could use a 500km/h underground train at various secret locations for transporting troops and equipment. It doesn't have to be all civilian use.
ehhhh..... cautiously asking: This is humor right?
The PLA could use a 500km/h underground train at various secret locations for transporting troops and equipment. It doesn't have to be all civilian use.
ehhhh..... cautiously asking: This is humor right?
The PLA could use a 500km/h underground train at various secret locations for transporting troops and equipment. It doesn't have to be all civilian use.
Actually no. Think about it, the logistics would be an advantage towards China's defense system. Sending mass troops and supplies to a certain location is very difficult and time consuming.
OK then, dude, what you smoke these days?
Your visualize is like to use super-luxury-cruiser to transport troops and better - rations, if possible. (Chinese joke is "to use airliner to transport bricks" "砖机")
- and, at the same time rely on totally unrelyable super-sensitive super-fragile tech and management system to do so.
OK, in light of the rising potential that if the idea of underground railway system that "image" the one on the ground, to secretly transport military related staff and stuff, is not a bad idea - but why 500km/h? why the safety (and reliability) hassle it brings along? Can't we simply use "green wagon" and flat top like what the PLA done on the ground?
Imagine if the Germans would have this capability just in France and Italy alone, they could turn any Allied invasion forces into something worse then Dunkirk. Remember it's all about fuel and energy to mobilize an army and fire power to produce mass destruction to the enemy with as much efficiency as possible.
The Germans COULD have done that if they hadn't opened the second front to their east. Most of their resources were spread thin because of fighting both fronts, especially the Eastern front. Given the amount of man power, equipment and other stuff, Germany could easily defend the Normandy beaches against any large scale invasion IF they did not start the fight with the Soviets.
What is also different between Normandy and possibly China is that Normandy beaches are a short distance away from many large landmasses. It would be difficult for the defenders to predict where the enemy will be coming from and it would be easier for attackers to conceal itself. Most of the China's beaches, on the other hand, face open ocean. It would be very difficult for any potential attackers to hide themselves and hide their intentions. There is only a handful of potential locations where the potential attackers can use as launchpads. So any potential enemies will be spotted long before they have any chance of attacking. So a Normandy scenario probably won't be seen in China.
A fast train in a tunnel experiences a huge drag unless the train cross-section is small compared with the cross-section of the tunnel or, more practical, if the tunnel is evacuated. It has been proposed, many years ago already, that Switzerland would build a country-wide metro system with magnetically suspended trains running in evacuated tunnels at 1000 km/h. Think about it, in a few minutes from Bern to Geneva! But a country-wide network for China would be extremely expensive. And, if you build it, to limit its use to the military would be absurd.The PLA could use a 500km/h underground train at various secret locations for transporting troops and equipment. It doesn't have to be all civilian use.
A fast train in a tunnel experiences a huge drag unless the train cross-section is small compared with the cross-section of the tunnel or, more practical, if the tunnel is evacuated. It has been proposed, many years ago already, that Switzerland would build a country-wide metro system with magnetically suspended trains running in evacuated tunnels at 1000 km/h. Think about it, in a few minutes from Bern to Geneva! But a country-wide network for China would be extremely expensive. And, if you build it, to limit its use to the military would be absurd.