D
Deleted member 23272
Guest
You always have to strike the right balance. In the case of Alibaba, even without government intervention they were already kind of stagnating, continuously losing ground to other e-commerce companies like JD and PDD, the latter of which seems like its doing what Alibaba never managed to do in breaking into Western markets, declining from being the top dog in Chinese e-commerce to simply only having Taking the hulking machinery that they were and breaking off into six autonomous entities pursuing their own market and development goals, seems like a necessary step to allow for more flexibility and increasing competition.Alibaba and Amazon are 商人 (traders) passing things and money from one hand to the other making no added values to the society. They are like lubricant of machine, necessary and even critical at some point but never the core and foundation, should never to be allowed to take the major chunk of resources and profit. Whenever they become too dominant, they should be cut into pieces, but we are not going to remove them.
BYD and CATL are making real things, they are the machines. They will be encouraged to be big, but on the condition that they don't suffocate the tech development, that is not being a patent bully to stop competitions.
In principle, there should be NO dominant power in industry, NOT even SOEs. The only dominant entity is the State, the country. Chinese businesses are only to be large to compete with foreign powers, but not to overshadow the state power. They are the tools of the state, not the owner and ruler of the state. If you study the Chinese history, you will realize that it is always like this. And this is the very reason that China remained an unified state for more than 2000 years.
But as always, even if business can't too big for its britches and threaten the state, so too can the state not be too heavy handed in controlling big business, less they wish to stifle competition, innovation, and drive up unemployment. You can't just kneejerk cut up a company just because it gets too big, since that destroys market confidence. And some big businesses like BYD, Baidu, Bytedance, Huawei, and DJI actually do have the right idea in investing in R&D to churn out groundbreaking technologies.
Of course, even if you're in charge of 1.4 billion people, you're still human in the end, so sometimes you get it right and sometimes you don't. Just got to pray in the end that wisdom and experience influence decision making so that they more often than not it get it right for the sake of fostering healthy development and innovation.