Miscellaneous News

Thecore

Junior Member
Registered Member
Because they are less of a western worshipper than East Asians. Arabs also did not adopt the western suit. India/Pakistan/South Asia despite being colonized has more of its traditional culture than China or other east asian cultures who whole heartedly abandoned their older culture and customs for western customs.

Compare Indian wedding and Chinese wedding wearing western style dresses and suits. East Asians think Western style wedding as cool and romantic, and their own wedding customs as boring and outdated. South Asians and Middle-easterners don't think like that.

South Asians and Middle-easterners still wear their own style of dresses in everyday life. I see a fundamental difference in thinking between East Asia on this where European customs, dress and culture is seen as cool. South Asians or Middle-easterners consider European/Western culture as corrupting their own culture.

East Asians probably developed faster because of their wholesale adoption of the west, but they also have little of their own culture in day-to-day life.
You may say it’s worshipping but it also reflects the difference between insular thinking and open-mindedness.
 

pmc

Colonel
Registered Member
I think I was NOT Clear. I was referring to the period when Russian Tsar was removed. Long before Putin, Even Russian Christians were victimized and millions died along with Muslims and even Ukrainians at that time.

The man charge of that mass murder was Leon Trotsky among others. Yes there were others. All of them claimed to be Zionists. I was NOT supporting Ukraine here. I was saying, long before Putin ever existed, during early soviet era this happened. I was referring to the period during which Russian monarch was removed. During that period, the Bolsheviks murdered millions.

It were mostly Christians,, Muslims and some other people that were horrifically killed. s. I meant the period between 1918 tp 1939 when people like Leon Trotsky who being Jewish hardliners hated both Muslims and christian. Millions of Christians, Muslims died in the hands of Leon Trotsky who ran a terror campaign unlike another. This is historic fact. In old archives in Germany and Russia, There are documents that show some scale of terror. Lot of it was destroyed to hid true scale of crimes. Even christian and muslims babies were not spared, so many died of hunger and disses. Entire Chechnya was expelled into Siberia, and more than half of them starve to death in extreme cold and despair. Mothers Froze with babies in their hands. Thats was nearly a 100 years ago.

A true holocaust of Russian christian and Muslims was committed by what later became creators of Israel. , some authers estimated nearly 30 million dead, in Russia, Ukraine, and surrounding regions.

But moving to the present, I was surprised that while Ukrain and Russian Chrsitians (as well muslims) are fighting each other.

that is Russian muslims are fighting along side with Russian chrisitans against Ukrainian christians and ukranians muslims.

But jewish people are NOT fighting with each other. Meaning Russian jewish community continued to maintain good relationships with Ukrainian Jewish people. They both are benificiary of this war. I did NOT say muslims and chrisitans are fighting each othter. Far from it, Muslims are fighting muslims such as Russian muslims are fighting ukranian muslims (with some chechen exceptions, as chechen fighting on both sides due to being pro or anti russian). Furthmore Russian chrisitans are fighting Ukranian Christians.

But Rusisan jewish community to my surprise, mixing, mingling with love with Ukranian community. On both sides they are the richest, having powerful people. Even gettng married in the middle of the war.

They are benefiting from the war, even in Ukraine most powerful are making money while average Russian and Ukrainian soldiers are losing their limbs and life. Many of those who are benefiting from this war, have Israeli citizenship. Look at zelensky;s cabinet when war started. almost all of them are jewish and all of them stole money form western funds so much that some had to go, and many went back to Israel. This war was planned by US. To force Russian into the war so that Russian suffers and so would the average Ukranian. Ukranians are led to the false believe that US is their friend whenn Ukrainians are nothing but a tool to harm Russia. In the process They are canon fodder. They die for nothing. Zelensky himself lost nothing.

Zelensky is a clear case of a psychopath. He should NOT have involved western nations if he was sincere. He should have tried to resolve all issues directly with Putin. He should have refused Nato. If he had done that, today there would be no war. Clearly He is making money out of it. All those western billlions went somewhere. Zelensky and his people are making money and want to contiue this war for their benefits.

In any event I understand you meant well. I was essentially angry at US. a country totally out control and very cruel too.
I dont want to be impolite. you have very little understanding of reality. 1100 of years of celebrating Islam means it include all the history of the region and that include past 100 years. You cannot fool that Green flag. Most of Global South is lucky that there is no treaty alliance of Israel-Russia and US. and one more correction Current Chechnya is now wealthy enough that it can outsources the war to other people and they enjoy wealth and provide spiritual guidance to next generation. and when Putin see this success he forcing it on whole country. i havent even shown next generation of Putin girls. those thousands of Mosques some of them very luxurious are the tourist attraction.



1756699177638.png
 

Randomuser

Captain
Registered Member
Because they are less of a western worshipper than East Asians. Arabs also did not adopt the western suit. India/Pakistan/South Asia despite being colonized has more of its traditional culture than China or other east asian cultures who whole heartedly abandoned their older culture and customs for western customs.

Compare Indian wedding and Chinese wedding wearing western style dresses and suits. East Asians think Western style wedding as cool and romantic, and their own wedding customs as boring and outdated. South Asians and Middle-easterners don't think like that.

South Asians and Middle-easterners still wear their own style of dresses in everyday life. I see a fundamental difference in thinking between East Asia on this where European customs, dress and culture is seen as cool. South Asians or Middle-easterners consider European/Western culture as corrupting their own culture.

East Asians probably developed faster because of their wholesale adoption of the west, but they also have little of their own culture in day-to-day life.
I hear this said by Indians a lot. If they want to be consistent, they should stop using English, using western technology, western administration methods, hollywood film methods and all the other stuff. They should stop using weather observations or whatever and just pray to Shiva like the old days. They can't just cherrypick stuff like we wear our own clothes while taking everything else and claiming they are not influenced heavily.

Asians do this coz its the international norm. In the future, if some other country designs those futuristic like clothing, east asia will adopt it. It doesn't have to be from the west, it comes from whoever designed it and therefore sets the international standard.
 

tamsen_ikard

Senior Member
Registered Member
I hear this said by Indians a lot. If they want to be consistent, they should stop using English, using western technology, western administration methods, hollywood film methods and all the other stuff. They should stop using weather observations or whatever and just pray to Shiva like the old days. They can't just cherrypick stuff like we wear our own clothes while taking everything else and claiming they are not influenced heavily.

Asians do this coz its the international norm. In the future, if some other country designs those futuristic like clothing, east asia will adopt it. It doesn't have to be from the west, it comes from whoever designed it and therefore sets the international standard.
Western Europeans of the middle ages adopted Chinese technology, Tea, Silk and so on. But they didn't adopt Chinese customs and clothing. And that didn't stop them from progressing.

So, yes you can, and most certainly should cherry pick what you adopt from other countries and cultures, unless you want to lose your own identity. There are plenty of examples of cultures and people who essentially went extinct cause they adopted too much of other peoples cultures and languages until nothing remains of their own, so now they are essentially assimilated.
 

steemdrice

New Member
Registered Member
Because they are less of a western worshipper than East Asians. Arabs also did not adopt the western suit. India/Pakistan/South Asia despite being colonized has more of its traditional culture than China or other east asian cultures who whole heartedly abandoned their older culture and customs for western customs.

Compare Indian wedding and Chinese wedding wearing western style dresses and suits. East Asians think Western style wedding as cool and romantic, and their own wedding customs as boring and outdated. South Asians and Middle-easterners don't think like that.

South Asians and Middle-easterners still wear their own style of dresses in everyday life. I see a fundamental difference in thinking between East Asia on this where European customs, dress and culture is seen as cool. South Asians or Middle-easterners consider European/Western culture as corrupting their own culture.

East Asians probably developed faster because of their wholesale adoption of the west, but they also have little of their own culture in day-to-day life.
The absolute explosion of popularity of Hanfu would suggest that your thinking on how Chinese view Western fashion is severely outdated.

Also I wasn't aware that the bridesmaids testing the husband on the wedding day was a Western tradition. Or that red is the colour that Western brides wear. Or that the tea ceremony is a Western invention.
 

tamsen_ikard

Senior Member
Registered Member
The absolute explosion of popularity of Hanfu would suggest that your thinking on how Chinese view Western fashion is severely outdated.

Also I wasn't aware that the bridesmaids testing the husband on the wedding day was a Western tradition. Or that red is the colour that Western brides wear. Or that the tea ceremony is a Western invention.
Western White wedding is the overwhelming popular type of wedding happening in most east asian countries. Yes, there is a movement in China to revive old traditions, clothing and some Chinese are choosing traditional wedding again. This is a positive step towards reviving their own cultural identity. But this is still in the early stages.
 

Randomuser

Captain
Registered Member
Western Europeans of the middle ages adopted Chinese technology, Tea, Silk and so on. But they didn't adopt Chinese customs and clothing. And that didn't stop them from progressing.

So, yes you can, and most certainly should cherry pick what you adopt from other countries and cultures, unless you want to lose your own identity. There are plenty of examples of cultures and people who essentially went extinct cause they adopted too much of other peoples cultures and languages until nothing remains of their own, so now they are essentially assimilated.
Europeans simply aren't giving credit. Before they claim they got nothing from China until they were forced to admit that stuff like guns and paper came from there so now they claim its only tech. They don't realize the whole education system we have today from deciding people who can lead by meritocracy exams which affects their lives is based on the imperial exams. Leibniz and Voltaire were influenced by Confucius for what good governance is yet this was downplayed. I wonder what other stuff will be eventually discovered. Its simply more subtle so they can get away with it.

Also you mentioned the middle east and south asia. The more I think about it, the more I realize this keeping local culture thing just means the country is less developed. Look at the middle east in places like UAE. Maybe they wear those arab clothing but beyond that they use western skyscrapers, engage in western habits of blowing money, spending on western crap like paying all those western sports athletes to come over. There actually is very little "culture" once you see past the surface and coincidently its like this most for the richest parts. Saudi Arabia even allows women to drive now.
 

steemdrice

New Member
Registered Member
Western White wedding is the overwhelming popular type of wedding happening in most east asian countries. Yes, there is a movement in China to revive old traditions, clothing and some Chinese are choosing traditional wedding again. This is a positive step towards reviving their own cultural identity. But this is still in the early stages.
This is simply not consistent with my experiences or those of people I know. Even when they wore white, the wedding itself involved the tea ceremony. Even when the groom wore a suit, they were challenged at the door by the bridesmaids. I have yet to meet a single Chinese person who got married after 2005 who did not wear red at their reception.

I have no idea what the rest of East Asia does, but a Chinese wedding, even when they wear a suit or white dress or whatever, is a very different affair from any "Western" wedding I have ever attended. At the most it is a synthesis of traditions, not a wholesale abandonment of Chinese tradition (either long standing, such as wearing red, or newer, such as collecting the red wedding booklet and certificate).
 

37thCommando

Just Hatched
Registered Member

Why does Modi always dress like that? I mean, it would be a bit odd if XJP turned up to events in Hanfu and Putin dressed as a Cossack.

Even Chiang Kai-Shek wore national dress when he wasn’t wearing his uniform. Seems by the end of WW2 most Asian nations lost their pride and stopped wearing national dress, and only now have they looked back and started wearing it again

Though India was always unique in this regard since they wore their own clothing very early on starting in the 1950s, probably as an FU to colonialism. Mishima praised this practice when he visited india
 
Top