J-20 5th Gen Fighter Thread VIII

Mearex

New Member
Registered Member
any idea on the credibility of this old article? Specifically the part about J-20 having a mach 2 top speed:
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

If it is credible, then based on the date of publish, is it safe to assume that the mach 2 top speed is achieved with older ws-10 engines?
 

Gloire_bb

Major
Registered Member
If it is credible, then based on the date of publish, is it safe to assume that the mach 2 top speed is achieved with older ws-10 engines?
Absolutely majority of modern fighters are mach 2 limited. Doing more costs money, takes structural compromises and research (especially for stealth aircraft, as you need your absorbing coatings and edge treatment to somehow survive long exposure to high temperatures, and this is very contradictory). All the trouble for something that in 99.99% situations is absolutely useless.

Every next typical speed limit (M=2.13, 2.35, 2.55) is determined by materials and not by engines, and you can see that the older plane design is, the higher the mach limit. Simply because it was but a redundant appendix of 3rd generation, slowly going down to useful levels.

The only exception in the world is Mig-31, because it's very specifically built and meant to dash around at high mach, achieving intercept points over endless northern Russia in time.
 

siegecrossbow

General
Staff member
Super Moderator
Absolutely majority of modern fighters are mach 2 limited. Doing more costs money, takes structural compromises and research (especially for stealth aircraft, as you need your absorbing coatings and edge treatment to somehow survive long exposure to high temperatures, and this is very contradictory). All the trouble for something that in 99.99% situations is absolutely useless.

Every next typical speed limit (M=2.13, 2.35, 2.55) is determined by materials and not by engines, and you can see that the older plane design is, the higher the mach limit. Simply because it was but a redundant appendix of 3rd generation, slowly going down to useful levels.

The only exception in the world is Mig-31, because it's very specifically built and meant to dash around at high mach, achieving intercept points over endless northern Russia in time.

It also destroys RAM on stealth aircraft.
 

cdj20

New Member
Registered Member
any idea on the credibility of this old article? Specifically the part about J-20 having a mach 2 top speed:
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

If it is credible, then based on the date of publish, is it safe to assume that the mach 2 top speed is achieved with older ws-10 engines?

The "Mach 2" is not necessarily constrained by the engines. The SU57 and F22 also have the "Mach 2" limit.

1744474371342.pngSU57Compressed.png
 

SinoAmericanCW

Junior Member
Registered Member
The "Mach 2" is not necessarily constrained by the engines. The SU57 and F22 also have the "Mach 2" limit.

View attachment 149967View attachment 149968
I was under the impression that the F-22 could, *technically speaking*, reach Mach 2.25 at altitude with afterburners, whereas the Su-57 could reach Mach 2.45 - albeit obviously doing so would negatively impact stealth coatings and increase IR signature.
 

Dante80

Junior Member
Registered Member
F-22 can reach (and has reached in trials) a lot more than Mach2 with the afterburner on, but it is tactically pointless, especially given its high altitude super-cruise speed. It is also taxing the airframe and the engines, while being damaging to the RAM coating.

You will never see them zooming at this speed in service.
 
Last edited:

Gloire_bb

Major
Registered Member
F-22 can reach (and has reached in trials) a lot more than Mach2 with the afterburner on, but it is tactically pointless, especially given its high altitude super-cruise speed.
YF-22 did, not F-22. It had adjustable intakes (for the original specified Vmax of M=2.6), but, just as important, it didn't have actual RAM coatings. Composites(if we want to decrease weight) don't like crossing over M=2 either.
F-22 is already temperature limited, even for it's rather short super cruise capability, and you want it to go faster still.

Tactically pointless - it most definitely isn't. It just was prohibitively expensive on a stealth fighter on ca.1990 technology, especially after 1991.

Treat all stories about speeds over mach 2 for modern fighters that don't list it specifically as more or less hunters tales.
 
Top