J-10 Thread IV

Phead128

Captain
Staff member
Moderator - World Affairs
The problem with J10 is that it was designed as a quantity and 'good enough' jet. I suppose you can say that about F16 but bear in mind Rafale, Gripen, EFT are designed to be the only fighter that supposedly can handle all tasks for operating nation. How good will J10CP be in Pakistani service remains to be seen.
J-10A was quantity and 'good enough' jet.
J-10C has AESA+DSI+PL-15 which put it in the top-tier of 4.5 gen fighters.

Also, Pakistan bought J-10C primarily for it's A2A capability to counter Rafale (which it is highly competitive in A2A) so it doesn't really matter if it's multirole capability it not as robust, because Pakistan has other assets for multirole capability.
 

Gloire_bb

Captain
Registered Member
The problem with J10 is that it was designed as a quantity and 'good enough' jet. I suppose you can say that about F16 but bear in mind Rafale, Gripen, EFT are designed to be the only fighter that supposedly can handle all tasks for operating nation. How good will J10CP be in Pakistani service remains to be seen.
The question is, does this "quantity/good enough" make for actual (measurable) difference?
Missies fly worse, radars detect less targets, or anything else?

I.e. gripen is indeed very special. That doesn't change the fact that outside of its very special circumstances it tends to be rated worse than literally anyone else. Not always - but often.

In the end, all of them have a conops and have their strong sides. For J-10 its pretty straightforward - sleek a2a-focused airframe, large radome (largest in class actually). Yes, it is very straightforward. Straightforward doesn't mean bad - quite the opposite. Especially when networked.
 

tphuang

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
VIP Professional
Registered Member
According to SIPRI reporting, 25 J-10Cs cost $1.4 billion. A little more than the $50 million per that Shilao quoted. It's possible the $1.4 billion also included some other costs like spare parts.

Interestingly, I did not see an order for PL-15 and PL-10 in there.
 

LCR34

Junior Member
Registered Member
According to SIPRI reporting, 25 J-10Cs cost $1.4 billion. A little more than the $50 million per that Shilao quoted. It's possible the $1.4 billion also included some other costs like spare parts.

Interestingly, I did not see an order for PL-15 and PL-10 in there.
Probably consolidated in the package for JF17?
 

antiterror13

Brigadier
According to SIPRI reporting, 25 J-10Cs cost $1.4 billion. A little more than the $50 million per that Shilao quoted. It's possible the $1.4 billion also included some other costs like spare parts.

Interestingly, I did not see an order for PL-15 and PL-10 in there.

Do you think Pakistan would get very long soft loan from China, even with barter with seafood probably?
 

PeoplesPoster

Junior Member
Top