China's SCS Strategy Thread

Janiz

Senior Member
By contrast, you're proposing the US evict the indigenous settlers of Fiji so they can make it a military base.
Nah, I wouldn't even touch poor Fijians. US could claim some underwater reef which Fijians thought that was theirs but can't claim it on UNCLOS based law. If they want to defend it - shoot 'em all! Then you can start building a new airbase!

Sounds familiar, isn't it?

So US would be 'good' or 'bad'? I think the answer here should be clear.

'Yeah, this time US did a good job protecting it's core national intrests and showing weaklings where their place is!' should be the answers on this forum.
 

PiSigma

"the engineer"
Nah, I wouldn't even touch poor Fijians. US could claim some underwater reef which Fijians thought that was theirs but can't claim it on UNCLOS based law. If they want to defend it - shoot 'em all! Then you can start building a new airbase!

Sounds familiar, isn't it?

So US would be 'good' or 'bad'? I think the answer here should be clear.

'Yeah, this time US did a good job protecting it's core national intrests and showing weaklings where their place is!' should be the answers on this forum.
It's comments like these that I think janiz deserves a permanent ban. And mods want to take action?
 

jobjed

Captain
It's comments like these that I think janiz deserves a permanent ban. And mods want to take action?

You know in medieval times when kings paid people to do stupid stuff for the court's entertainment? Yeah, Janiz is SDF's own jester. I don't want him banned, I want to see him do and say stupid stuff for many years to come for our entertainment, free of charge too, which is nice of him.
 

Janiz

Senior Member
It's comments like these that I think janiz deserves a permanent ban. And mods want to take action?
Last time you wanted to ban me you got warned and for that you'll always want my account banned. I'm sure of that. And I bet you have good memory...

The same with jobjed - I found a weak claim in his post which I quickly translated into real life (1988, as most of you should know) and now he's calling me a jester... Of course he's empty handed when it comes to arguments.
 

jobjed

Captain
Last time you wanted to ban me you got warned and for that you'll always want my account banned. I'm sure of that. And I bet you have good memory...

The same with jobjed - I found a weak claim in his post which I quickly translated into real life (1988, as most of you should know) and now he's calling me a jester... Of course he's empty handed when it comes to arguments.

Ok, I'm gonna try the Socratic method.

1. Who do you think should own the SCS islands?

2. Why?
 

Janiz

Senior Member
Who do you think should own the SCS islands?
I think that post WWII status quo should be held until there's a chance for peaceful and non-militaristic ways of resolving those issues,
Because there won't be any more blood spilled over this dispute. I'm against postings all the time how PRC will deal with US, Taiwan, Japan etc in many threads on this forum as well.

My views on this case is in any way provocative, warmongering or against rules on this forum? If so - where?
 

jobjed

Captain
I think that post WWII status quo should be held until there's a chance for peaceful and non-militaristic ways of resolving those issues
You must have answered some other guy's question 'cause mine had nothing to do with what you just said.

I asked "who should own the SCS islands", not "what should be done in the short-term future?"

Because there won't be any more blood spilled over those issues. I'm against postings all the time how PRC will deal with US, Taiwan, Japan etc in many threads on this forum as well.
No blood has been spilt over the Spratlys. Millions of tonnes of sand has been poured but not a single drop of blood. Your concerns are unfounded and not reflected by reality.

Please actually answer my question.
 

PiSigma

"the engineer"
Trolls like janiz which doesnt contribute anything and just end up creating pages of useless flame bait drives good members away, which in turn kills the forum.

If the current mods are not interested in moderating these trolls, then I won't be surprised to see the good members leaving.
 

Janiz

Senior Member
No blood has been spilt over the Spratlys.
There was a blood bath in Spratly Islands. I thought that all of the users knew what I meant with 'Shoot 'em all!' in my earlier post but I was wrong. Here's a link for the start:

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!


Maybe it slipped down in your memory. Whatever.
who should own the SCS islands
For me it could be closed area without any inhibitants or commercial activities around for now. Just like Japanese did with Senkaku. But I know it can't happen unfortunately...
 
Top