052C/052D Class Destroyers

daifo

Captain
Registered Member
Maybe the Saudis would like to at least "appear" like they are capable or can contribute to protecting their trade routes. At this point, its completely dependent on the US.
 

TK3600

Major
Registered Member
Someone on Weibo had a really good analogy for 052DE: it's like as if during the interbellum UK went on the market and offered to sell to anyone Hood class battlecruiser.
It will have to be 055E. Hood was the best battlecruiser in UK and no newer class is planned.
 

ACuriousPLAFan

Brigadier
Registered Member
Not directly related to the discussion, just a small snippet on warships from the WW1-WW2 era.
It will have to be 055E.
Agree with @Gloire_bb here. The 055s (or 055E) won't be capital ships for the PLAN. In the PLAN, that title belongs to the carriers.

Hood was the best battlecruiser in UK and no newer class is planned.
Nope.

After Hood, there are actually more advanced battlecruiser designs being worked on by the Royal Navy that were meant to succeed the Admiral-class, especially with the incorporation of lessons from Jutland in mind. One of the most prominent designs is the G3-class:
1200px-Duncan_wows_main.jpg
The G3-class battlecruiser (named HMS Duncan in-game) from World of Warships for illustration purposes.

Armed with 9x 406mm main guns in 3 three-gun turrets, better protection system through rather unconventional turret, superstructure and propulsion system arrangements, plus a thicker deck armor than the Hood, the G3 would have been an even better battlecruiser than the Hood (or, perhaps the first REAL fast battleship) had it not been cancelled by the 1920 Washington Naval Treaty.

I think in this analogy 055 would be King George V class. People already knew by then that Hood is no longer state of art due to poor protection and future is fast battleship.
King Geoge V-class is pretty much a battleship that is handicapped by the 1936 London Naval Treaty. Had the Admiralty went the same way as the Americans with the 381mm or even 406mm calibres for their main guns in three-gun turrets instead of the 356mm guns in four-gun turrets with unsatisfactory performances, the class would have performed better in engagements against the Bismarck and Scharnhorst.

I won't call the King George Vs the best for said analogy, but at least the Brits managed to make do with what the treaty limitations had provided.
 
Last edited:

Andy1974

Senior Member
Registered Member
Who would they be guarding those waters against, in that case?
The USA, and any country they can convince to blow up pipelines etc. The USA is directly threatening Saudi basically constantly, and Saudi must be very worried about having all their money stolen just like their neighbor Iraq right now.

A Type 052 will allow Saudi to hold huge areas at risk and deny choke points which are absolutely vital to the US. It can threaten the USA homeland easily while jointly exercising in the Caribbean with Algeria, or BRICS countries in the South Atlantic.

A batch of 052’s can close the Indian Ocean from the West and they should have an easy time getting foreign basing rights given how much aid Saudi gives.
 
Top