Returning to a conversation from some months back...
Did you see the new Witcher 4 trailer? Looks pretty good. CDPR looks to be delivering another GOTY contender as long as it doesn't release the same year as GTA 6. I was hoping they would drop new info on Cyberpunk 2 but oh well.
I'm sure it'll be fantastic, but the trailer basically just serves to introduce the idea of Ciri as the main player character, about which I have no strong feelings one way or the other. We already knew that Witcher 4 was in development and that it is (unfortunately) being developed using Unreal Engine 5. CDPR's track record is pretty consistent at this point: they shoot for the moon, get halfway there by release date, then spend the next 12-18 months patching the game to bring it progressively closer to that original vision. It's difficult to be too critical of that cycle when the spectrum of their output ranges from compelling-but-flawed through to excellent through to phenomenal, but still.... it's a ways away. I'm mostly a console gamer these days (I played the first two Witcher games on PC back in 2008/2011 respectively, but CP2077 and now Witcher 3 on PS5) and I wouldn't be at all surprised if Witcher 4 runs as poorly on PS5 as CP2077 did on PS4.
That game is already buried under a new controversy right now due to allegations of woke and not following book canon. So whether the gaming community at large will like this I don’t know. This will provide further opportunities for Chinese games but western games in general will always be under scrutiny due to the fear of more DEI and woke being slipped into any game they came get their hands on to spread ‘the message’. If you like woke and the American messaging, you might be ok but many including myself are getting quite sick of this nonsense and hope that China and the like can make more of a scene to show how’s things are supposed to be done
Lmao, just realized you were talking about Witcher 4 and not Cyberpunk regarding the drama. Didn't hit me till I was talking with a Witcher fan and he explained it more to me. Kinda interested in how they will handle the lore for this change. Funnily enough, a similar drama is happening with their Cyberpunk dev team as well (devs attacking gamers / woke shenanigans).
Well, having now spent some 200 hours playing through
The Witcher III over the past three months, the "controversy" over Ciri being a witcher and the main character in
The Witcher IV makes less sense to me than ever. Ciri is
de facto Geralt's adopted daughter, and her growth over the course of TW3 culminates, at least in the most compelling ending for the game, in her stepping directly into the role of witcher as Geralt's apprentice. Meanwhile, Geralt's estate at Corvo Bianco in the
Blood and Wine expansion, while not directly announcing his retirement, clearly implies that he has more witchering adventures behind him than remaining ahead of him, a theme that is reinforced throughout the expansion with its focus on the echoes into the present of things past, and the notion that idyllic, apparently unchanging appearances must inevitably give way to change.
From the perspective of TW3, that TW4 is shifting to Ciri as the main character, and as a witcher, seems not only reasonable but the natural and almost inevitable extension of the story already told. Of course that may not fit with the book canon. I haven't read the books, though I'm intrigued to do so, so I can't speak to that aspect of things. Changes are inevitable in adapting one medium to the other, the only question is whether those changes are good or bad, both in and of themselves and in the broader context of the narrative goals they advance. If the complaint is that Ciri hasn't gone through or shouldn't be capable of surviving the Trial of the Grasses and so shouldn't have access to the full suite of witcher mutations, that strikes me as a very thin objection. I mean, this is a girl who was wandering through multiverses in order to avert the apocalypse, and folks are quibbling about witcher mutations? The
real narrative challenge is to de-power Ciri enough from her end-TW3 state that she can be credibly threatened by a hostile world and have a narrative of personal growth/discovery in TW4. It's also clear that Geralt will still be part of the story, and that will be great to see.
Attached are a couple of clips from the "Ciri as Witcher" endings for the base game and
Blood and Wine expansions respectively, of which the
Witcher IV trailer released a few months ago seems a natural extension:
In any case, TW3 was an amazing experience from start to finish. But with that colossus out of the way, minus a few map markers remaining to clear up, I want to get to
Black Myth: Wukong and
Control before Switch 2 arrives and likely brings
Metroid Prime 4 and a new flagship
Mario title with it...