Indian Military News, Reports, Data, etc.

pipaster

Junior Member
Registered Member
It seems to be willful ignorance. Basically ignoring the customer to continue pushing the line that the problem was due to training or maintenance.

Boeing did the same with the 738 Max, they attempted to blame Lion Air on poor training and maintenance when it was the MCAS. They couldn't continue with that lie when the 2nd plane went down in Ethiopia five months later.

With military airfcraft, the safety threshold is probably far lower. This Dhruv/ALH helo had been grounded repeatedly from earlier crashes. The entire fleet had been grounded so far this year.

Unbelievable that seriously deadly issues over a decade ago have not led to a safer aircraft today. When you lose 4 out 7 to an export customer, it should have started ringing bells at the corporate level.

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

HAL's 3-week timeline ends, no breakthrough on fate of grounded Dhruv choppers

A fleet of 300 Dhruv Advanced Light Helicopters (ALH) has been grounded since January after a crash, and defence experts have raised concerns about their operational reliability.

SAR is a no fail mission, someone else's life is on the line usually. Having a grounded SAR fleet is catastrophic, it is the last place to desire national industrial benefits.
 

Nevermore

New Member
Registered Member
"[...]We may have to go in for off-the-shelf purchases with indigenous content until AMCA gets developed. Or develop AMCA at a faster pace,” Singh admitted.[...]"

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
I hope India will purchase the Su-57 because buying the F35 will lead to India being more controlled by the United States and more anti China. But from India's perspective, considering the benefits for the short to medium term economy, cooperation with the United States may be beneficial for India.
 

Lethe

Captain
"[...]We may have to go in for off-the-shelf purchases with indigenous content until AMCA gets developed. Or develop AMCA at a faster pace,” Singh admitted.[...]"

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

That the IAF wants to import combat aircraft is not exactly news. The IAF always wants to import combat aircraft. Since 2018, this objective has been advanced via the MRFA requirement for 114 aircraft. The difficulty is in bringing the Ministry of Defence and upper echelons of GoI onboard to approve the large capital expenditure required in the context of myriad other competing priorities, including LCA and AMCA. The relevant development is that there has
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!
been some movement at the MoD level to look more favourably upon the IAF's agitation in this respect.

It is tempting to see this as a reflex response to renewed pitches from Russia and USA for Su-57 and F-35 respectively, but I am not convinced that is the case. To the extent that this is a real and meaningful shift (which is not yet clear), it could well be informed by internal evaluations re: LCA Mk. 2 and AMCA development trajectories, perhaps in the context of anticipated PAF and PLAAF developments in the 2030s. It may even be informed by renewed consciousness of the strategic risk embodied in the fact that India's indigenous combat aircraft programs are, across the board, tied to engines supplied by the United States.
 
Last edited:
Top