MwRYum
Major
QJY-88's problem in my opinion are as follows:
As a SAW it is too long and the handgrip is too flimsy;
As a GPMG it leaves a range + firepower gap between 5.8mm and 12.7mm, which'd have been plugged by 7.62mm assets in other armies.
The resurgence of 7.62mm in both battle rifle and MG has a lot to do with the proliferation of body armor which nowadays not only regular military formations afford as part of their foot soldier's basic kits, paramilitary outfits and even terrorist organisations have them; also, indirect support fire whether in range or in penetration power, in urban situations or rural combat situations, 7.62mm or higher serves as GPMG would yield more advantage than that of the smaller calibre, that of the 5.56 / 5.45 / 5.8mm variety.
The PLA had thought of the 5.8mm as "one size fits all" + "one do-everything ammo" solution like the rest of the world did a few decades back, but the lesson learned by the US and USSR / Russia told us all otherwise; hell, even the Chinese learned with the QBU-88 marksman rifle that there's a need of different ammo types, and that means the supply chain still needs to provide for different ammo for the rifleman / MG team / marksman / sniper for optimal performance anyway.
It'd be better off if they upsize the QJY-88 to take the 7.62mm / 8.6mm, or at least dumped the QBB-95 while do a short barrel + folding / telescopic stock version of QJY-88 for SAW or paratrooper versions.
But then again, it really depends on how this new initiative plays out. Words on the street said that the new boss who oversee this had fought the Sino-Vietnam war back in the day as a company-level officer, and he ain't a fan of bullpup design. Also, if the PLA preparing for a war that'd breakout before or around 2020, introduce a new rifle series and a modernized version of QJY-88 would be the uppermost they'd allow to happen, after all introduce a new rifle series means more than just iron out the kinks, go into series production and give it to the troops, you still need to train them to use it properly.
For now, the rifle candidates seems to be of the same mechanism but with different external features, probably testing out to see what's preferable and what's not.
As a SAW it is too long and the handgrip is too flimsy;
As a GPMG it leaves a range + firepower gap between 5.8mm and 12.7mm, which'd have been plugged by 7.62mm assets in other armies.
The resurgence of 7.62mm in both battle rifle and MG has a lot to do with the proliferation of body armor which nowadays not only regular military formations afford as part of their foot soldier's basic kits, paramilitary outfits and even terrorist organisations have them; also, indirect support fire whether in range or in penetration power, in urban situations or rural combat situations, 7.62mm or higher serves as GPMG would yield more advantage than that of the smaller calibre, that of the 5.56 / 5.45 / 5.8mm variety.
The PLA had thought of the 5.8mm as "one size fits all" + "one do-everything ammo" solution like the rest of the world did a few decades back, but the lesson learned by the US and USSR / Russia told us all otherwise; hell, even the Chinese learned with the QBU-88 marksman rifle that there's a need of different ammo types, and that means the supply chain still needs to provide for different ammo for the rifleman / MG team / marksman / sniper for optimal performance anyway.
It'd be better off if they upsize the QJY-88 to take the 7.62mm / 8.6mm, or at least dumped the QBB-95 while do a short barrel + folding / telescopic stock version of QJY-88 for SAW or paratrooper versions.
But then again, it really depends on how this new initiative plays out. Words on the street said that the new boss who oversee this had fought the Sino-Vietnam war back in the day as a company-level officer, and he ain't a fan of bullpup design. Also, if the PLA preparing for a war that'd breakout before or around 2020, introduce a new rifle series and a modernized version of QJY-88 would be the uppermost they'd allow to happen, after all introduce a new rifle series means more than just iron out the kinks, go into series production and give it to the troops, you still need to train them to use it properly.
For now, the rifle candidates seems to be of the same mechanism but with different external features, probably testing out to see what's preferable and what's not.