Whats written above can apply to highly urbanized countries, not completely to developing countries with urbanization rate of 60% or below... There must be appropriate balance of high end/low end/machine work that follows current rate of country`s developement and urbanization.
Apply that to India now, and a billion people would never have a chance to lift up their living conditions step by step and will permanently remain in rural environment without a chance to move out.
Somebody on some thread from some other forum had an interesting thoughts of maintaining some volume of urban villages in/near major cities in China for some longer time giving an opportunity to seasonal workers to keep their low end jobs, coz otherwise they couldnt afford to rent any other accommodation and would be forced to back to their villages...
Dont forget that 40% of Chinese rural population (some 560 million) are still out of reach of any higher education unless their parents work hard for their children, or if some smaller percentage of super talented kids get some kind of schoolarship (yes education is free on the paper, but not really free in real life).
Its all about appropriate balance for current conditions
Apply that to India now, and a billion people would never have a chance to lift up their living conditions step by step and will permanently remain in rural environment without a chance to move out.
Somebody on some thread from some other forum had an interesting thoughts of maintaining some volume of urban villages in/near major cities in China for some longer time giving an opportunity to seasonal workers to keep their low end jobs, coz otherwise they couldnt afford to rent any other accommodation and would be forced to back to their villages...
Dont forget that 40% of Chinese rural population (some 560 million) are still out of reach of any higher education unless their parents work hard for their children, or if some smaller percentage of super talented kids get some kind of schoolarship (yes education is free on the paper, but not really free in real life).
Its all about appropriate balance for current conditions