Re: Movies in General/ Star Trek etc etc
Let the nerdiness begin.
I thought this through while I was watching Star Trek. It would seem that it would happen the way you said at first, and if the Enterprise ever got close it would indeed go down that way. But let's remember the Galactica has an entire airwing. That is the key to victory. The Galactica can just instantaneously jump around, and so can its Raptors, until it finds the Enterprise, lay an ambush with its air wing or deploy the air wing them jump away. One nuke from a Raptor should be enough to disable the Enterprise to the point that the Vipers could finish it off. The Enterprise has no weapons suitable for use against lots of independent small craft in all directions.
Basically its like the Prinice of Wales and the Repulse (a fast battleship and a battlecruiser) off of Malaysia in 1941. If they had ever gotten close to the Japanese fleet they would have gone through them like tissue paper but they were destroyed by naval aviation before they could even find the enemy much less get within gun range. It's basically just the classic carrier vs. battleship situation in space.
Yes in your scenario and assuming the Galactica was in full fighting trim, she should win out, but lets alter things by introducing a scenario from their respective storylines.
On the one hand there's the Galactica a battle damaged and manned by a battle fatigued crew. With her support squadrons seriously depleted over time, which amounted to many earth years, in warding off the Cylons,and with the remaining surviving ships to protect the captain adopts a defensive rather than offensive position with his remaining birds finds earth. but with the Enterprise in the way.
The Enterprise is in home territory with a well maintained ship and a crew rearing to go after a period of RR. This is where the Captain of the Galactica makes his mistake by not launching any birds, because he's unaware that the Enterprise doesn't have any.
Meanwhile wily old Captain Kirk having armed torps long ago leaves his shields down and refrains from powering up his lasers to prevent any sign of hostility manoeuvres the Enterprise into a position to fire the torps. . The Captain of the Galactica only realised he's been suckered by Kirks action with the sound of the first torpeodo strikes.
Actually I vaguely remember Kirk did employing such a tactic when he encountered a better armed foe.